Changes

{{Style P-Title|Letter XIII<ref>''Moscow News'', № 48, 18.02.1880, pp. 2-3; ''Russian Herald'', January 1883, Supplement, vol 163, pp. 120-126.</ref>}}

{{Style P-Title|Letter XIII<ref>''Moscow News'', № 48, 18.02.1880, pp. 2-3; ''Russian Herald'', January 1883, Supplement, vol 163, pp. 120-126.</ref>}}

Twelve miles [19.31&nbsp;km] south-east from Chandvad there is a whole town of subterranean temples, known under the name of Enkay-Tenkay. Here, again, the entrance is a hundred feet [30.48&nbsp;m] from the base, and the hill is pyramidal. I must not attempt to give a full description of these temples, as this subject must be worked out in a way quite impossible in a newspaper article. So I shall only note that here all the statues, idols, and carvings are ascribed to Buddhist ascetics of the first centuries after the death of Buddha. I could content myself with this statement, but misters archaeologists would meet here with an unexpected difficulty, and a more serious one than all the difficulties brought on them by the inconsistencies of all other temples put together. In these temples there are more idols designated ''Buddhas'' than anywhere else. They cover the main entrance, sit in thick rows along the balconies, occupy the inner walls of the cells, watch the entrances of all the doors like monster giants, and two of them sit in the chief tank, where spring water washes them up to their waist century after century without any harm to their granite bodies. Some of these Buddhas are decently clad, with pyramidal pagodas as their head gear; others are naked; some sit, others stand; some are real colossi, some tiny, some of middle size. However, all this would not matter; we may go so far as to overlook the fact of Gautama's or Siddhartha-Buddha's reform consisting precisely in his earnest desire to tear up by the roots the Brahminical idol-worship. Though, of course, we cannot help remembering that his religion remained pure from idol-worship of any kind during centuries, until the Lamas of Tibet, the Chinese, the Burmese, and the Siamese taking it into their lands disfigured it, and spoilt it with heresies. We cannot forget that, persecuted by conquering Brahmins, and expelled from India, it found, at last, a shelter in Ceylon where it still flourishes like the legendary aloe, which is said to blossom once in its lifetime and then to die, as the root is killed by the exuberance of blossom, and the seeds cannot produce anything but weeds. But main difficulty of the archaeologists still exists, if not in the fact of idols being ascribed to early Buddhists, then in the physiognomies, in the ''type'' of all these ''Enkay-Tenkay Buddhas''. They all, from the tiniest to the hugest, are Negroes, with flat noses, thick lips, forty five degrees of the facial angle, and curly hair! There is not the slightest likeness between these pure Negro faces and any of the Siamese or Tibetan Buddhas, which all have purely Mongolian features with wide cheek-bones, wide noses and perfectly ''straight'' hair. This unexpected African type, unheard of in India, upsets the antiquarians entirely. This is why the archaeologists avoid mentioning these remarkable caves. Enkay-Tenkay is a worse difficulty for them than even Nashik, real Thermopylae.<ref>A reference to the story of how a small detachment of Spartans prevented the passage of a huge Persian army through the narrow Thermopylae pass. – Ed.</ref>

Twelve miles [19.31&nbsp;km] south-east from Chandvad there is a whole town of subterranean temples, known under the name of Enkay-Tenkay. Here, again, the entrance is a hundred feet [30.48&nbsp;m] from the base, and the hill is pyramidal. I must not attempt to give a full description of these temples, as this subject must be worked out in a way quite impossible in a newspaper article. So I shall only note that here all the statues, idols, and carvings are ascribed to Buddhist ascetics of the first centuries after the death of Buddha. I could content myself with this statement, but "archaeologists" would meet here with an unexpected difficulty, and a more serious one than all the difficulties brought on them by the inconsistencies of all other temples put together. In these temples there are more idols designated ''Buddhas'' than anywhere else. They cover the main entrance, sit in thick rows along the balconies, occupy the inner walls of the cells, watch the entrances of all the doors like monster giants, and two of them sit in the chief tank, where spring water washes them up to their waist century after century without any harm to their granite bodies. Some of these Buddhas are decently clad, with pyramidal pagodas as their head gear; others are naked; some sit, others stand; some are real colossi, some tiny, some of middle size. However, all this would not matter; we may go so far as to overlook the fact of Gautama's or Siddhartha-Buddha's reform consisting precisely in his earnest desire to tear up by the roots the Brahminical idol-worship. Though, of course, we cannot help remembering that his religion remained pure from idol-worship of any kind during centuries, until the Lamas of Tibet, the Chinese, the Burmese, and the Siamese taking it into their lands disfigured it, and spoilt it with heresies. We cannot forget that, persecuted by conquering Brahmins, and expelled from India, it found, at last, a shelter in Ceylon where it still flourishes like the legendary aloe, which is said to blossom once in its lifetime and then to die, as the root is killed by the exuberance of blossom, and the seeds cannot produce anything but weeds. But main difficulty of the archaeologists still exists, if not in the fact of idols being ascribed to early Buddhists, then in the physiognomies, in the ''type'' of all these ''Enkay-Tenkay Buddhas''. They all, from the tiniest to the hugest, are Negroes, with flat noses, thick lips, forty five degrees of the facial angle, and curly hair! There is not the slightest likeness between these pure Negro faces and any of the Siamese or Tibetan Buddhas, which all have purely Mongolian features with wide cheek-bones, wide noses and perfectly ''straight'' hair. This unexpected African type, unheard of in India, upsets the antiquarians entirely. This is why the archaeologists avoid mentioning these remarkable caves. Enkay-Tenkay is a worse difficulty for them than even Nashik, real Thermopylae.<ref>A reference to the story of how a small detachment of Spartans prevented the passage of a huge Persian army through the narrow Thermopylae pass. – Ed.</ref>

We passed by Malegaon and Chikalval, where we examined an exceedingly curious and very ancient temple of the Jainas. No cement was used in the building of its outer walls, they consist entirely of square stones, which are so well wrought and so closely joined that the blade of the thinnest knife cannot be pushed between two of them; the interior of the temple is richly decorated.

We passed by Malegaon and Chikalval, where we examined an exceedingly curious and very ancient temple of the Jainas. No cement was used in the building of its outer walls, they consist entirely of square stones, which are so well wrought and so closely joined that the blade of the thinnest knife cannot be pushed between two of them; the interior of the temple is richly decorated.

On entering this vast city in its present state of solitude (the natives call it the “dead town”) we all experienced a peculiar feeling, not unlike the sensation of a man who enters Pompeii for the first time. Everything shows that Mandu was once one of the wealthiest towns of India. The town wall is ''thirty-seven'' miles [59.55&nbsp;km] long according to the measurement made in 1852. Streets ran whole miles, on their sides stand ruined palaces, and marble pillars lie on the ground. Black excavations of the subterranean halls, in the coolness of which sultanas spent the hottest hours of the day, peer from under dilapidated granite walls. Further on are broken stairs, dry tanks, waterless fountains, endless empty yards, marble platforms, and disfigured arches of majestic porches. All this is overgrown with creepers and shrubs, hiding the dens of wild beasts. Here and there a well-preserved wall of some palace rises high above the general wreck, its empty windows fringed with parasitic plants blinking and staring at us like sightless eyes, protesting against troublesome intruders. And still further, in the very center of the ruins, the heart of the dead town sends forth a whole crop of broken cypresses, an untrimmed grove on the place where heaved once so many breasts and clamoured so many passions...

On entering this vast city in its present state of solitude (the natives call it the “dead town”) we all experienced a peculiar feeling, not unlike the sensation of a man who enters Pompeii for the first time. Everything shows that Mandu was once one of the wealthiest towns of India. The town wall is ''thirty-seven'' miles [59.55&nbsp;km] long according to the measurement made in 1852. Streets ran whole miles, on their sides stand ruined palaces, and marble pillars lie on the ground. Black excavations of the subterranean halls, in the coolness of which sultanas spent the hottest hours of the day, peer from under dilapidated granite walls. Further on are broken stairs, dry tanks, waterless fountains, endless empty yards, marble platforms, and disfigured arches of majestic porches. All this is overgrown with creepers and shrubs, hiding the dens of wild beasts. Here and there a well-preserved wall of some palace rises high above the general wreck, its empty windows fringed with parasitic plants blinking and staring at us like sightless eyes, protesting against troublesome intruders. And still further, in the very center of the ruins, the heart of the dead town sends forth a whole crop of broken cypresses, an untrimmed grove on the place where heaved once so many breasts and clamoured so many passions...

In 1570 this town was called Shadiabad, the “abode of happiness”. The Franciscan missionaries, Adolf Aquaviva, Antario de Moncerotti, and others, who came here in that very year as an embassy from Goa to seek various privileges from the Mogul Government, described it over and over again. At this epoch it was one of the greatest cities of the world, whose magnificent streets and luxurious ways used to astonish the most pompous courts of India. It seems almost incredible that in such a short period nothing should remain of this town but the heaps of rubbish, amongst which we could hardly find room enough for our tent. At last we decided to pitch it in the only building which remained in a tolerable state of preservation, in Yami-Masjid, the “cathedral-mosque”, on a granite platform about twenty-five steps higher than the square. The stairs, constructed of pure marble like the greater part of the rest, are broad and almost untouched by time, but the roof has entirely disappeared, and so we were obliged to put up with the stars for a canopy, if it were for one circumstance, about which we shall tell below. All round this building runs a low gallery supported by several rows of huge pillars. From a distance it reminds one, in spite of its being somewhat clumsy and lacking in proportion, of the Acropolis of Athens. From the stairs, where we rested for a while, there was a view of the mausoleum of Gushanga-Guri, King of Malwa, in whose reign the town was at the culmination of its brilliancy and glory. It is a massive, majestic, white marble edifice, with a sheltered peristyle and finely carved pillars. This peristyle once led straight to the palace, but now it is surrounded with a deep ravine, full of broken stones and overgrown with cacti. The interior of the mausoleum is covered with golden lettering of inscriptions from the Koran, and the sarcophagus of the sultan is placed in the middle. Close by it stands the palace of Baz-Bahadur, all broken to pieces – nothing now but a heap of dust covered with trees...

In 1570 this town was called Shadiabad, the “abode of happiness”. The Franciscan missionaries, Adolf Aquaviva, Antario de Moncerotti, and others, who came here in that very year as an embassy from Goa to seek various privileges from the Mogul Government, described it over and over again. At this epoch it was one of the greatest cities of the world, whose magnificent streets and luxurious ways used to astonish the most pompous courts of India. It seems almost incredible that in such a short period nothing should remain of this town but the heaps of rubbish, amongst which we could hardly find room enough for our tent. At last we decided to pitch it in the only building which remained in a tolerable state of preservation, in Yami-Masjid, the “cathedral-mosque”, on a granite platform about twenty-five steps higher than the square. The stairs, constructed of pure marble like the greater part of the rest, are broad and almost untouched by time, but the roof has entirely disappeared, and so we were obliged to put up with the stars for a canopy, except for one event, about which we shall tell below. All round this building runs a low gallery supported by several rows of huge pillars. From a distance it reminds one, in spite of its being somewhat clumsy and lacking in proportion, of the Acropolis of Athens. From the stairs, where we rested for a while, there was a view of the mausoleum of Gushanga-Guri, King of Malwa, in whose reign the town was at the culmination of its brilliancy and glory. It is a massive, majestic, white marble edifice, with a sheltered peristyle and finely carved pillars. This peristyle once led straight to the palace, but now it is surrounded with a deep ravine, full of broken stones and overgrown with cacti. The interior of the mausoleum is covered with golden lettering of inscriptions from the Koran, and the sarcophagus of the sultan is placed in the middle. Close by it stands the palace of Baz-Bahadur, all broken to pieces – nothing now but a heap of dust covered with trees...

We spent the whole day visiting these sad remains, and returned to our sheltering place a little before sunset, exhausted with hunger and thirst, but triumphantly carrying on our sticks three snakes as a military trophy. Tea and supper were waiting for us. To our great astonishment we found visitors in the tent. The ''patel'' of the neighboring village – something between a tax-collector and a judge – and two ''zemindars'' (land owners) rode over to present us their respects and to invite us and our Hindu friends, some of whom they had known previously, to accompany them to their houses. On hearing that we intended to spend the night in the “dead town” they strongly opposed our plan. They assured us it was highly dangerous and utterly impossible. Two hours later hyenas, cheetahs and tigers were sure to come out from under every bush and every ruined wall, without mentioning thousands of jackals and wild cats. Our elephants either would flee or would be weakened and devoured. We ought to leave the ruins as quickly as possible and go with them to the nearest village, which would not take us more than half an hour. In the village everything had been prepared for us, and our friend the ''babu'' was already there, and getting impatient at our delay.

We spent the whole day visiting these sad remains, and returned to our sheltering place a little before sunset, exhausted with hunger and thirst, but triumphantly carrying on our sticks three snakes as a military trophy. Tea and supper were waiting for us. To our great astonishment we found visitors in the tent. The ''patel'' of the neighboring village – something between a tax-collector and a judge – and two ''zemindars'' (land owners) rode over to present us their respects and to invite us and our Hindu friends, some of whom they had known previously, to accompany them to their houses. On hearing that we intended to spend the night in the “dead town” they strongly opposed our plan. They assured us it was highly dangerous and utterly impossible. Two hours later hyenas, cheetahs and tigers were sure to come out from under every bush and every ruined wall, without mentioning thousands of jackals and wild cats. Our elephants either would flee or would be weakened and devoured. We ought to leave the ruins as quickly as possible and go with them to the nearest village, which would not take us more than half an hour. In the village everything had been prepared for us, and our friend the ''babu'' was already there, and getting impatient at our delay.

“But you positively must not dare to stay here,” insisted the fat ''patel''. “In case of accident, I shall be responsible for you to the Government. Is it possible you do not dread a sleepless night spent in fighting jackals, if not something worse?.. Don’t you believe us that you are surrounded with wild animals, which are invisible until sunset, but nevertheless the dangerous ones? Then do believe the instinct of the elephants, who are as brave as us, but a little more reasonable. Just look what they do!..”

“But you positively must not dare to stay here,” insisted the fat ''patel''. “In case of accident, I shall be responsible for you to the Government. Is it possible you do not dread a sleepless night spent in fighting jackals, if not something worse?.. Don’t you believe us that you are surrounded with wild animals, which are invisible until sunset, but nevertheless the dangerous ones? Then do believe the instinct of the elephants, who are as brave as us, but a little more reasonable. Just look what they do!..”

Indeed, our grave, philosophic-looking elephants behaved very strangely at this moment. Their lifted trunks looked like huge points of interrogation. They snorted and stamped restively. In another minute one of them tore the thick rope, with which he was tied to a broken pillar, made a sudden volte-face with all his heavy body, and stood against the wind, sniffing the air. He pulled the air strongly with his trunk, raising his right leg as if he was going to run... He obviously scented a dangerous beast.

Indeed, our grave, philosophic-looking elephants behaved very strangely at this moment. Their lifted trunks looked like huge points of interrogation. They snorted and stamped restively. In another minute one of them tore the thick rope, with which he was tied to a broken pillar, made a sudden about-face with all his heavy body, and stood against the wind, sniffing the air. He pulled the air strongly with his trunk, raising his right leg as if he was going to run... He obviously scented a dangerous beast.

The colonel stared at him through his spectacles and whistled very meaningly.

The colonel stared at him through his spectacles and whistled very meaningly.