At one of the subsequent séances, while the circle were singing, “Tramp, tramp, the boys are marching,” the voice of “Richard” was heard accompanying the singing, and at the same time a heavy tramping on the floor followed the voice about the room, keeping time to the singing, Mrs. Holmes’s voice indicating that she was in her seat at the same time. | At one of the subsequent séances, while the circle were singing, “Tramp, tramp, the boys are marching,” the voice of “Richard” was heard accompanying the singing, and at the same time a heavy tramping on the floor followed the voice about the room, keeping time to the singing, Mrs. Holmes’s voice indicating that she was in her seat at the same time. |