!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(October 1893)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. VIII, no. 7, October 1893, pp. 199-202
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Безант, Анни - Убеждение и догматизм
DATA
Title for references: Besant A - Conviction and Dogmatism
Short description: On the distinction between holding and clearly stating one's own convictions and the dogmatic imposi...
199Never was there an age more prone to confusion of thought than our own. In the rush and hurry of our "progressive civilization" men seem to have no time to think clearly, and they heap together incongruous thoughts and label them hastily, and then work on as though the labelling had been done after conscientious analysis. This superficial and mischievous habit has shown itself very clearly among the members of the Theosophical Society, some of whom are unable to distinguish between the holding of convictions and the desire to dogmatise as to the convictions that should be held by others. And by a quaint but not uncommon turn of fate, the very people who proclaim most loudly their detestation and fear of dogma are those who most dogmatically seek to impose their own vagueness of thought upon others as a thing necessary to salvation. "Whosoever will be saved, it is above all things necessary that he hold no belief with conviction and that he speak no belief with definiteness." So runs the modern version of the Athanasian Creed, and alack! I am among those doomed to perish everlastingly, for I not only have convictions and do not scruple to declare them, but I also hold the yet more damnable heresy of thinking that a life which is to be a force for good must believe firmly and speak clearly.
A "conviction" is a proposition held clearly and definitely in the mind, anything of the truth of which we feel sure. On such certainties we build our conduct, we mould our lives. By such certainties men's characters are formed. It is such certainties, and not all the drifting mass of thoughts that pass through our minds, that make us what we are. They are the anchors of the soul. Persons who have no certainties are swayed by every gust of feeling, changed in conduct by every passing phase of thought, swept hither and thither by every streamlet of opinion. Hence the enormous importance of right beliefs, for error in belief will inevitably bear fruit in error of conduct, and the usefulness of our lives be marred by intellectual mistake and spiritual blindness.
So also we see that all real science is built on certainties. Only when a fact is definitely established and its reality becomes a conviction, can it be of value to the world. A man of science, expounding scientific truths to the people, does not say, "It may be so, think as you like": he says, "It is so; disregard it at your peril." All that still awaits verification in the realm of may-be 200can serve as hypothesis, as speculation, as perhaps interesting and stimulating material for thought, but it offers no sure basis for the guidance of men's lives.
What is a dogma? In one sense of the word it is nothing more than a formulated statement, a clean-cut, definite presentment of a fact. It is a teaching put forward by knowledge, not a hypothesis but a certainty. In this sense every science consists of a set of dogmas fringed round by hypotheses, and the advanced or elementary stage reached by the science depends on the proportion which its dogmas bear to its hypotheses.
But the word "dogma" has come to bear an evil connotation, and has come to mean in the popular mind an assertion which is forced on others, instead of the clear presentation of a truth. And in this sense dogma is bad, a barrier to true knowledge and a hindrance to progress. If truth is to fructify in the mind, the mind must welcome it, assimilate it, become one with it. A truth, however true, which is authoritatively forced upon the mind unprepared for it, and which remains alien amid its surroundings, such a truth is not only useless but is a positive source of danger. It cramps and fetters mental action, it produces bewilderment and confusion; instead of educating it dwarfs, and it beats back mental capacity instead of drawing it forth. Such a dogma cannot be a conviction, it can only be an assertion, and its reiteration only increases its benumbing force. No man has a right to enforce his conviction on another, to demand assent to his statements, submission to his certainties. True to his own convictions he may be, hold to them, live by them, die for them: but force them on others—No. Not though they be the truest of truths, the most certain of certainties.
And here, as it seems to me, comes in the rule of right conduct. When a man has found a truth, or thinks he has found one, which is calculated to be of service to mankind, he should speak it out. Without such speech no intellectual progress is possible, and, historically, all pioneers of thought have taken this course, and by clear and unhesitating affirmation of what they know to be true they have helped mankind to make a forward step. Men are struck by the clear assertion; it may awaken in them some response; they feel stimulated; they enquire, they investigate, they become convinced. But while the pioneer should thus speak out, he should not endeavour to coerce others into acceptance of his truth. Let him speak it out clearly; whether others accept it or not should matter not to him. He is, for the nonce, the mouth through which Truth speaks, and his mission is fulfilled in the 201speaking. Let him tell forth the truth, let him show its bearing on life, the consequences of its acceptance or rejection. Having thus done, his duty is discharged, and the word should be left to go on its way, to be freely accepted or freely rejected by each who comes in contact with it.
But, it is sometimes argued, if a truth be not capable of general demonstration, it should not be publicly stated. Why not? No truths, save the most elementary, can be demonstrated to everyone. Each science has its abstruser verities that can only be demonstrated to those proficient in it, but none the less may it state these verities, assert them on the authority of the masters in science, state that the demonstration is beyond the reach of all save advanced students, and leave them to be accepted by the unlearned as reasonable hypotheses, congruous with accepted truths, or—if the unlearned so prefer—to be cast aside as unverifiable. The discovery and the assertion of discovered truth are not to be held back to suit the meagre efforts and capacities of the indifferent and the slothful; they have their right of rejection; let that suffice them.
The application of all this as regards members of the Theosophical Society is clear. We have no right to lay down dogmas to which we demand assent, be it explicit or implicit; we have no right to treat as less worthy members than ourselves any of our brothers who disagree from our views and who reject our statements. But we have the right to clearly and definitely utter our convictions, whether or not they are capable of demonstration to everyone on whose ears they may fall. The demonstration is attainable by all who choose to devote energy, time, endeavour, to gather the necessary capacities and knowledge: those who do not so choose—and surely such are within their right—have no claim to make their lack of capacity and knowledge the measure of our assertion.
And let it be clearly understood that there are truths the demonstration of which must be directed to the spirit and not to the intellect, and that the evolution of spiritual faculties is as rigorously necessary for their comprehension as the evolution of intellectual faculties is necessary to the comprehension of intellectual truths. Everyone admits that the demonstration of a difficult philosophical proposition cannot be appreciated by an untrained mind, and that intellectual capacity must be educed ere such a demonstration can be understood. It is equally true that the demonstration of a spiritual truth cannot be effectively made to anyone in whom the spiritual faculties have not been 202educed and trained. That there is hesitation in accepting this fact, that there is a general claim of ability to appreciate evidences addressed to the spiritual faculties whereas all men admit that training is necessary for the intellectual, is part of that scepticism as to the reality of the spiritual life which is characteristic of our generation. If the spiritual life be a reality, then there must be conditions for its evolution, and until those conditions are fulfilled, the life will not manifest. To take but one illustration: the existence of the Masters can be proven to the spiritual faculties, and their existence as Masters cannot be proven on the physical and intellectual planes. On the physical plane the existence of certain men with certain powers could be shown; on the intellectual plane, their possession of certain knowledge: but the Master is a spiritual life, the spirit triumphant, and only to the eyes of the spirit can He, as such, be shown. Let those who have been happy enough to catch but one glimpse of Him keep that memory ever, and be willing at fit times to bear reverent witness to Him. But what can avail words on this high theme? The eyes of devotion alone can pierce the darkness, but verily the dawn shall come and we shall see.
Annie Besant.