!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(April 1894)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. IX, no. 1, April 1894, pp. 5-10
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Фуллертон, Александр - Необходимость иллюзии в Девачане
DATA
Title for references: Fullerton A - Necessity of Illusion in Devachan
Short description: Argues that illusion is both inevitable in Devachan and necessary to the soul's progress there, sinc...
Substance of an address before Aryan T.S.
5So much is said in Theosophical literature of the evils of illusion, and so many are the warnings against its influence, that most Theosophists are sensitive to the very word. Particularly is there felt a hardship at the apparent unreality of Devachan. After thirty, fifty, seventy years of subjection to all the mistakes, misconceptions, beguilements of an illusionary existence, it does seem grievous that the centuries of Devachanic life should be but a continuance of them, it to be succeeded by another period of deceptive earth-experience, and the series of alternate illusions to extend indefinitely. And yet the anomaly may be explained, even justified.
6But before such attempt, one should observe our arbitrary reversal of the terms "real" and "unreal". So accustomed are we to attribute reality to physical objects which may be seen and handled and examined, and to consider as visionary the contents of the super-physical world, that that only has become veritable to us which is material. And yet this it is which changes hourly, which is in perpetual state of flux, which cannot have fixedness or continuity; while the truly enduring, that which passes on undecayed through time, is the Mind, the Soul, the Spiritual Being. "The things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal".
But in this discussion one must use the terms in their ordinary sense, and, so doing, the subject divides itself into two propositions: 1st, that illusion is inevitable in Devachan, a requirement to its functions, inseparable from its nature; 2d, that illusion is a necessity to the progress of the Soul therein.
There are three considerations which go to prove the former of these propositions. The first is that the soul is as yet unfitted for the sphere of pure realities. It is, indeed, freed from the lower quaternary, and as Atma-Buddhi-Manas has passed the Devachanic portal. But it is fresh from earth-life; its interests and conceptions, however purged from lower quality and now the rarefied extract of highest experiences, are still colored from its late career; Manas is saturated with recent thought and habit. How impossible to translate the yet unfinished being to a region for which it is not fitted and the contents of which it is yet unable to appropriate! There is a homely proverb of "a fish out of water". The fish dwells in a dense medium, extracting from it by its gills the finer element — air — which pervades the water, thus maintaining its life. But place it entirely in that finer element and life becomes impossible because of that fineness; the fish gasps and struggles and dies. And so the soul, long accustomed to extract its nutriment of thought from the surrounding matter of terrestrial life, could not maintain itself as yet in a world of pure reality, but would succumb from the very perfection of its environment.
In the second place, there must persist an element of illusion so long as any trace of matter inheres in an organism. Imagine the spiritual realm and the material realm as at opposite ends of a prolonged line. As a spiritual being leaves its home and follows down that line, it reaches a point where the first faint 7aroma of matter is perceived. At once begins a slight illusionary tendency. As the being approaches more and more nearly the material realm, denser and denser grows the matter, and stronger and stronger the illusion; so that at the extremity of the line reality is farthest from perception and mistake rules. Reverse the process. The being leaves the material for the spiritual. As it does so and as the atmosphere rarefies, little by little illusionary proclivities drop away, the vision clears, the actual comes steadily into view. Yet not till the last trace of material association has been overpassed does illusion sink wholly to the rear. But in Devachan this is ungained. Higher Manas has still the aroma, the memory, the interests of its late embodiment in flesh, and with them must retain that illusion which pertains to the material sphere.
In the third place, we must remember the function of Devachan. It is two-fold, and one part is Happiness. But happiness is an individual thing, and consists to each man in the realization of his own ideal. There must be as many varieties of Devachan as there are varieties of Devachanees, each finding there the highest of his aspirations and hopes. Yet to all there is this common element, — that they are subjective conditions of the soul, with no corresponding objective reality, yet none the less actual, none the less certain. A man is a philosopher, a student, a scientist. The attainment of truth is his delight, and the means to which alone he is accustomed and of which he can conceive are books and scientific treatises and philosophical apparatus. His dream is of a future world where research is vastly facilitated, where the newest discoveries are spread broadcast, where apparatus exists so delicate and fine that ours appears but the clumsiest of contrivance. And yet is it possible in the supersensuous world that libraries and printing presses and experimental tools are to be as here? Is a disembodied soul, removed from the gross and the tangible, to continue handling and reading and testing? Impossible. But in the mind within, those processes may go on, and with all the reality of an actual experience may continue their educative function till their need has been overpassed. Take the artist, he whose soul is instinct with visions of beauty in form and color and suggestiveness. He looks for a land where transcendent glories flush the spirit, where light never seen on earthly seas and shores fills 8with measureless delight. Yet in Devachan there can be no Alpine sunrise, no picture gallery, no canvas or marble whereon he can work out his inspiration. Is he to be disappointed, or is the fullest of all possible satiations to expand his inner nature in a subjective, but a real, experience? Take the musician. Harmony and melody and perfect expression make his very life. Yet he knows their inadequacy to portray all that the soul can sense, and so he anticipates in heaven a feast unattained, unattainable here. There are to be the richest orchestrations, the noblest symphonies, the most glorious operas, the most entrancing voices and instruments, every elevated taste finding its amplest gratification. But are there opera-houses, orchestras, trained singers in Devachan? Or are those supernal joys in the soul within, in some strange way provided by beneficent Nature, — an illusion, if you please, because without a counterpart in fact, yet the reality of reality to him who is their subject.
The profoundest of all human emotions is Affection. Broken, disappointed, severed often here, it gazes onward to a land where sorrow is unknown and partings never to be feared. The mother leaves her child, the wife her husband, the friend his friend, calmed with the assurance that it is but for a time, and then will be the joy of an endless reunion. More than anything else is this conception of heaven; and you might fill the future world with every possible joy to intellect and soul, enrich it with the lavishness of a Divine treasury, yet all would be vain if the one desire was absent, all a desolation if the heart was chilled, unfed. If the beloved was away, heaven would be no heaven to the inmate. And yet see how impossible is such presence in any literal sense. If to the happiness of a Devachanee the actual existence there of the loved one is essential, then the child must accompany the departing mother, the husband the wife, the friend the friend. Would it be just that these should be cut off before their time, that they should be unwillingly deprived of their right to life merely that another might be made happy? But more than this. Every beloved has his beloveds, each has others dear and cherished; so that if they too are to be happy their loved ones must go with them; and thus the circle widens, widens without the 9possibility of stop. What follows? The death of a single individual would depopulate the world.
And so we see that illusion is a necessity to Devachan, that it cannot but exist, that the bliss of the soul is interior, not a reflection from objective surroundings.
Turn now to the second proposition: Illusion is a necessity to the progress of the soul in Devachan. Here again there are three considerations. The first is as to that progress itself, progress being the twin of happiness in the two-fold function. It would be a grievous mistake to suppose that the long centuries of Devachanic rest are but an idle dream, the soul making no advance, learning no new truth, a stationary thing in a universe of evolution, emerging from Devachan precisely as it entered it. H. P. B. distinctly states the contrary. And, indeed, it would be but reasonable to expect that in a world from which gross matter and its influences are excluded, a world finer than this, closer to reality, more in touch with eternal truth, there must be avenues to learning, facilities for progress, which we cannot now divine. Clogs from flesh and blood are removed. Prejudices, antipathies, limitations have vanished with the relinquished personality. New and larger methods, regions, pursuits open to the unfolding nature. And yet there is a condition to this finer state. It is that all obstruction though pain shall be effaced. How often in this present world an indigestion has made impossible a thought, a fever has paralyzed an aspiration, a headache has conquered a prayer! True, all physical evils are absent from Devachan because the body is; yet internal griefs are as fatal to progress as are external, and so from that progressing state must be banished every sorrow and memory and foreboding and regret which could arrest the Ego's march. But this, as we have seen, is not consistent with fact; it is an illusion, however indispensable to our needs.
Another consideration is that man is to round in his career the whole circle of experience, and so no segment of it can be omitted. At eras in his earth-pilgrimage he has tasted unqualified misery: he must now taste its antithesis — unqualified happiness. Yet this, as has been shown, is impossible through literal presence of conditions: they must be supplied by an illusionary belief.
And a third consideration is that "Nature does nothing by leaps". As a human soul evolves slowly up to that stature which lifts it above all deception or mistake and fits it for the realm of absolute reality, it parts from its illusions but gradually and by degrees. The great Law which pervades the rest of the Universe is not absent from Devachan. The Ego enters it as a pilgrim on his pilgrimage, not as a victor on his goal. And yet we may well believe that as centuries pass on and the changed existence modifies the character and its modes, there may come a truer view of 10all its inner life, a closer touch with real things. Illusion may steadily be mitigated as it is outgrown, direct percipience of fact taking steadily the place of imagination as a guide. And so when the Devachanic interlude is over, the Ego may return for its new incarnation with clearer views of truth, a less clouded sense of spiritual verities, a firmer hold on ultimate reality.
Thus we see, then, not only that there can be no Devachan without illusion, but that the very progress in Devachan is conditioned upon that illusion, and that the illusion must continue till its function has been fulfilled. When a man has become a Master, when he perceives not as through a glass darkly but face to face, illusion has no longer power over him. Devachan has become an impossibility, he is done with it forevermore.
I think that these truths should correct our attitude to Devachan. We should not look upon it as a deceptive state continuing the evils against which we vainly struggle here, but as a needful, an unavoidable experience wherein are found compensation for all the bitternesses encountered outside of it, a happiness adapted to the weary pilgrim, a gradual emancipation from the evils of illusion itself. There need not be suspicion of it, a protest against its wisdom, a saddened resignation to the inevitable. May there not be even a thankfulness for it? In the many hours of sorrow here, when hopes dearest to the heart are prostrated in the dust and the very life-blood of the spirit seems to ebb despairingly away, it is something to remember that these sacred desires are only postponed, not blasted, and that not a worthy wish or thought or purpose shall be permanently vain. All will revive in that sun-lit realm, and there in copious fulness delight the soul once desolated and forlorn. Infinite Wisdom and Infinite Love have framed a scene where each best hope of heart and mind shall bloom into a glorious fruitage.
It is said of the poet Burns that there was one passage in the Bible which he could never read without emotion: "And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes". Well, in a sense this is true of Devachan. The pathway of humanity as it goes onward to its heights is over many a broken heart, many a desolated life, many an extinguished hope, and it passes through many a starless night. And yet there are breaks, long breaks whereon not a shadow throws its chill, but where life and light and cheer are without a drawback. Those portals are open to every noble thought and desire and aspiration, and all accompany the pilgrim as he steps into the sunbeams, but they are rigorously barred to every pain or grief or disappointment. There sorrow finds its end; the very causes of sorrow are obliterated; and not a tear shall ever be wiped away, for none shall ever form.
Alexander Fullerton, F. T. S.