Fullerton A - Projected Hari-Kari

From Teopedia

!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!

Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Projected Hari-Kari

Alexander Fullerton

(English)

(February 1895)

A reply to E. T. Sturdy's anonymous article in The Unknown World proposing that the Theosophical Society disband itself, answering his specific allegations one by one and arguing that the Society's organization and literature are themselves evidence of its members' vitality and sincerity rather than of corruption.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Фуллертон, Александр

DATA

Title for references: Fullerton A - Projected Hari-Kari
Short description: A reply to E. T. Sturdy's anonymous article in The Unknown World proposing that the Theosophical...

Alexander Fullerton

Projected Hari-Kari

345

Projected Hari-Kari.

At an epoch of crisis in any organization with high aims, there always appear promoters of remedies. Sometimes they come from without, beneficently proffering advice though never having proffered service; sometimes from within, and then the advice either has the force of previous interest demonstrated by work, or has the familiar sound of that gratuitous counsel which is so proverbial of the idle. And once in a while a member steps forth in full garb as such, solemnly asseverating his deep interest in the organization and his calm conviction that its true policy is to commit hari-kari. Its purposes have been perverted, its mission a failure; his own moral earnestness gives pain as he compares it with the turpitude around; saddened at the prevalent corruption, he must voice the truths within his soul; really there is nothing to be done but for the organization to disembowel itself and to end its career of pitiable disaster. He will not resign; his heart still clings to the Cause; let all collapse together, and then there will be hope for the race.

In The Unknown World of December 15th is an article of this nature upon the Theosophical Society. The author signs his 346name,[1] a name perhaps less known for vigorous services to the Society than for criticism of its operations and for distrust of its active workers, and he frankly sustains all previous reputation, telling us of the lamentable pretensions of the Society from the first, the utter hypocrisy of its platform, the frightful corruption and folly continually accumulating, the error and humbug and conceit inevitably generated; the impending crash brought on by duplicity and fraud. And what is the conclusion? To withdraw from a body so deceptive and vile? To discountenance all such rascality by refusing longer connection with it? To attempt a reform and rally the pure to extrude the hypocritical and the pretending? Not at all. This: to disband the Branches, have as loose a connection as possible among all mystic bodies of every name, capture from Theosophists the property they hold as such, give the coup-de-grace to the Theosophical Society, and do so under the auspices of the author as an F.T.S.!

On the moral quality of the proposition there is perhaps no need to speak, but there are some assertions as to fact which should have notice because coming from one still proclaiming membership in the Society, a membership dear to him in spite of its revolting associations and of his own hopeful purpose to end up the Society itself. Among them are these: that the Society holds Oriental doctrines and discountenances others; that the General Secretaries virtually mould the faith of the Branches and members; that the use of literature and lectures is wrong and antagonizes spontaneous thought and study; that suspicion of individual officials blasts belief in Theosophy; that the T.S. teaches the existence of Mahatmas and a possible connection with them; that no proof of connection with Mahatmas can be other than subjective; and that the present need is to abolish organization and officers and have a book-depot and a magazine office.

Now one might combat these assertions seriatim. One might say that the disproof of the holding of doctrines by the T.S. is found in (a) the explicit language of its Constitution, (b) the absence of any such exaction from candidates for membership, (c) the unrestrained freedom of opinion and discussion in the T.S. which in fact obtains, (d) the universal opposition to any dogmatic stand, strongest in the most conspicuous workers. One might say as to the practical moulding by General Secretaries that of course their work in a Theosophical Society must necessarily pertain to Theosophical topics and efforts, and that the views of men put in office because of their capacity and record will 347naturally have weight with private members, just as in any other organization; but that (a) there is absolutely no evidence of any attempt to enforce or even unduly urge these views, (b) that the correspondence of their offices is adducible to show their insistance on freedom, (c) that the publications under their control (the Vâhan, the Prasnottara, and the Theosophical Forum) invite and publish views divergent from the Secretaries'. One might say (a) that a Theosophical Society without Theosophical literature and speakers might as well be a Society under any other name, or, better yet, not exist at all, (b) that both writings and speeches are avowedly on the basis of individual opinion, and, if sustained by contributions from members, are so on the right of free action guaranteed by our Constitution, (c) that the T.S. literature emphasizes spontaneous thought and study, giving them larger material for use and urging that use, (d) that if Theosophists desire to spread a knowledge of the truths they have found valuable, they are really manifesting the philanthropic spirit which Theosophy inculcates. One might say that the basing recognition of truth upon the characters of individual teachers is exactly one of those forms of personality which Theosophical literature discountenances, and that the man who does not find his best proof of truth in the affirmation of his own consciousness is precisely the man least influenced by the literature put forth; also that no evidence has been thus far adduced that any considerable number of Theosophists have abandoned Theosophy because T.S. officials have been accused of wrong,—no evidence, that is, other than the assertions of this article. One might say that the statement that the T.S. teaches the existence of Masters has no support in any of its authoritative pronouncements, but exactly the contrary, and that its highest tribunal refused only last July to decide a case which might imply such teaching, the writer of the Unknown World article being a member thereof, and not voting against the refusal. One might say that the assertion that no proof of intercourse with Masters can be other than subjective denies the contrary assertion of Madame Blavatsky, Col. Olcott, and various other witnesses, and sounds rather like the a priori dictum of an uninformed person generously confident of his own powers than the evidential result of actual experience. One might say that if literature perniciously checks spontaneous thought, the establishment of a book-depot and a magazine office would but intensify the evil, ensuring in the new system without organization and officers the very calamities which justify hari-kari to the old.

But having thus disposed of specific allegations, a reader might 348very well glance over the whole field and note the general conditions producing results which have thus been misrepresented by the writer. He would instantly perceive that in any Society the activities pursued must be by the more intense members and upon their lines. In the T.S. the only exacted belief, that in the doctrine of Universal Brotherhood, prompts to no special work. Members who hold that and no more do little but cherish a gracious sentiment. Those who, in addition, hold distinctively Theosophic tenets betake themselves to study and discussion. Those who, still further, are swayed by Theosophy as a regenerating influence naturally wish to extend its benefits in every direction. Not for sectarian propagandism, not as an effort to draw members into the T.S., but in order to enable all men to perceive the Laws of Life and thus to reform human existence, they endeavor to spread everywhere a knowledge of Karma and Reincarnation. They wish to persuade nobody, but they do wish to so pervade society with these facts that souls which are ready may seize them, as they did themselves. Therefore arise leaflets, pamphlets, treatises, lectures, the whole apparatus for dissemination of seed; and this is of necessity maintained by the earnest of the members, the real Theosophists. To complain that members are active is to complain that they are alive. Why should they not be alive if there is any vitality in Theosophy itself?

Furthermore, any rational activity uses for its methods that which all human experience shows most effective,—organization. If members desire the best books for study, the most profitable topics for Branch discussion, the most fruitful agencies for popular instruction, these can be most cheaply and valuably supplied through an organized experience. Hence a central office which has touch with all parts of the body falls inevitably into the work of help and suggestion and cooperation. Nobody is obliged to accept such who does not want to; why should anybody who wants it not have that privilege? Here again, to complain that the active section of the Theosophical Society does what every other united group does,—use the results of all human experience, is to complain that Theosophists are as intelligent as non-Theosophists.

And still further. F.T.S. having the constitutional right to think and speak as they please, many have concluded from evidence satisfactory to themselves that Masters exist and that They have directly instigated the formation and now directly promote the work of the Theosophical Society. These members believe that a Master has distinctly counselled, as the great Theosophic 349contribution to social regeneration, the most wide-spread promulgation of the doctrines of Karma and Reincarnation. To some has come conclusive proof that Masters are interested in their faithful servants and give them help and encouragement when needed. Is there any reason why a man should ignore the facts of his own experience and refuse the duties he feels incumbent, because another man has not had that experience and does not feel those duties? To complain that earnest Theosophists do not accept the test of Mahatmic intercourse prescribed by the non-earnest, that they speak that they do know and testify that they have seen rather than what others do not know and have not seen, is virtually to insist that the dog in the manger exemplifies true Theosophic polity.

That the Theosophical Society will welcome the proposal to commit suicide will seem probable only to the most sanguine natures. Possibly the Spartan virtue of the Unknown World contributor, still delicately sensitive after all these years of exposure to the corrupting influences of the Society, still stern to impurity in every form, may over-rate the general distress and despair. It may, indeed, be that the present tempest may prove too much for the rotten craft, and that she may soon founder in the deep, one voice heard to the very last in righteous denunciation of her officers and sturdily—as one may say—defying the thought of desertion. And yet it may be that the crew, less cognizant of the moral enormities so long befouling their vessel, may bestir themselves to greater effort, may carry through the voyage in spite of hostility without and defection within, and may even make port in safety, the old officers still on deck, after having invited Jonah to commit himself to the deep.

Alexander Fullerton, F.T.S.


Footnotes


  1. ↑ The author of the article is Mr. E. T. Sturdy, F.T.S.—[Ed.]