!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(January 1895)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. IX, no. 10, January 1895, pp. 307-310
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Фуллертон, Александр
DATA
Title for references: Fullerton A - The Real Reason
Short description: Argues that the bitter denial some Theosophists show toward reports of personal contact with the Mas...
307
The Real Reason.
When any doctrine or fact first presents itself before a public unacquainted with it, it has to make its way through no little indifferentism, and over-strong obstacles of prejudice, ignorance, vested interests, and bigotry. Conservatism will resist the intruder, and some of the most powerful forces in human nature will denounce him as a reckless disturber of settled faith, an audacious trifler with sacred institutions. Envy, hatred, malice, and all uncharitableness surge up to oppose and overwhelm him. If he conquers a foothold and establishes himself as a permanency, it is because he is too strong for successful opposition and because he has found friends among the multitude.
The progressing triumph in the Western hemisphere of belief in the existence of Masters is a very instructive case. When the doctrine was first put in popular form by Mr. Sinnett, it received welcome from not a few readers, but the public at large was little impressed. As Theosophists multiplied and as H. P. B.'s voice sounded over the world, the doctrine became better known and began to arouse antagonism. Her books and the literature they begot were full of references to the doctrine; it was perceived an integral part of the Religious Philosophy; no little teaching was avowedly from Masters; sometimes messages were distinctly proclaimed. As Theosophists grew bolder they became less reticent; a conviction spread that it was Masters' will that Their existence should be emphasized; the consequent efforts, together with the strangeness of the doctrine, forced the topic to the fore-front in Theosophic writings. And this has been helped by occasional communications vouchsafed to individual Theosophists and used fittingly by them for general or particular edification.
Of course this growing publicity has alarmed the orthodox in Church and Science, and the familiar battle is in full rage. Ridicule is naturally the most frequent weapon, reason being less available, and the Himalayas and Tibet and astral bodies have received from comic editors an attention which they never had when geographies and physiologies had no impetus from Theosophy. Not much can be attempted by argument, especially since Huxley proclaimed it flimsy, but it is easy to smile with complacent self-satisfaction or to joke at astral telegraphs and Mahatmic infallibility. But behind all this one can see the real alarm in conservative circles, for if belief in Masters together with its 308consequents establishes itself securely, a very different ideal and a very different method will displace those so dear to Theology.
Certainly there is ample reason for this alarm. Most members in the swelling ranks of the Theosophical Society, free as they are in respect to this as all other doctrines, do in fact hold it, and Theosophy itself is so coloring the thought of the age that minds everywhere are becoming tinged. Moreover, there are indications that Masters Themselves feel the time propitious for larger action, and that They are behind not only the T. S. but some of its operations. And it may even be said that occasional pupils, utterly unsuspected heretofore, are now quietly revealing themselves on fitting occasions and for authorized purposes, starting certain influences which have results on private members and the agencies they are working. As these increase—and the public is now sensing that they will—there will be reason to foresee a still greater sweep of Adept influence over the world.
Theosophic observers are deeply interested in all this, and one part of their observation is into the motives which excite such hostility to the doctrine of Masters. All the ordinary ones are very obvious,—dislike to novelty, fear of consequences, incompatibility with existing convictions, prejudice against Eastern beliefs, jealousy of higher beings, a materialistic bias, dread of ridicule, and many another force which springs instantly to its feet when unfamiliar sounds are heard. But these do not seem entirely to meet the case, for there is often a resentment, even a malignity, which does not exhibit itself over Karma, or Reincarnation, or the Seven Principles, or Devachan. Why should men become vexed about Masters while tolerant of Angels, and grow bitter against an unseen Man though benignant to an unseen Spirit? And why, above all, should any such feeling display itself in a Theosophist, one who may be supposed to concede the doctrine, even if not to welcome it?
In the case of such a Theosophist, and cases have undoubtedly occurred, for both in private letters and in public prints have appeared sentences rather angrily opposing the assertions of others that Masters exist and have actually communicated with workers, there must be some deeper reason than a latent unbelief or an opposition to public use of the doctrine. As we probe down, bringing each possible motive to the surface and finding it inadequate, can we stop short of this concealed, most probably unconscious, one,—that he himself has never received a message? Certainly this explanation would be indignantly repudiated; and yet as we examine the conditions of the case is not it the only 309satisfactory solution? For observe: such a Theosophist does not deny the possibility of Masters; he does not contest the continuity of the record of the historic belief, or its present potency in many sections of the world, or its value in the Theosophic scheme; he does not insist that Their present action is impossible, or that there can be no satisfactory evidence of its output, or that testimony from a quarter like H.P.B. can be discredited. He would not even say that no private individual could be the recipient of a demonstration, and that any assertion of such must inevitably be false. And yet when a concrete case occurs, when reputable persons affirm themselves to have seen a Master, or to have heard His words, or to have received from Him in any way a message, there is an instant uprising of protest, of denial, of angry contempt. Is there any possible way of accounting for this save as jealousy, the working of resentment at the uncomfortable thought that another has been preferred?
This view is corroborated by two facts. One is that the objectors in private or in public are invariably those who have not been thus favored, and who are also of the indolent, the lukewarm, the critical in Theosophical affairs. As one runs over the list of Theosophists who have thus resented the asserted experiences of others, they are at once recognized as among the light-weights in the Society, exactly those who would have no claim to help, and exactly those, therefore, whom one would expect not to receive it. The other fact is that denial is never heard from those who themselves know. If a man has ever been the recipient of proof that Masters exist, he is forever secure in his own belief, and he is also glad to avow that a privilege which has been granted to him is far more probable in the case of those more worthy. No readier concession to the likelihood of widespread help from Masters can be found than from him who has himself received that help.
And so, as we scan the problem of bitter denial, we find its only satisfactory solution in that pettiness of self-love, that lamentable littleness of vanity, which Theosophy itself so deplores and discountenances. A man does not like to admit as possible to another what he has not met himself and knows he cannot claim. It is solacing to wounded pride to deny the reality of a tribute elsewhere. And the wound to the pride makes the denial bitter.
True pride would refuse to allow the soul to express, even to feel, chagrin at another's honor. True dignity would rejoice if the race produces better fruits than oneself. True philanthropy 310would beam over happiness accruing to any fellow-worker. And true Theosophy would take courage as it found any additional evidence that Masters are alert for the common Cause, and eager to aid Their servants in a service which by that aid shall the sooner triumph.
Alexander Fullerton.