Karr TE - A Criticism Criticised

From Teopedia

!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!

Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

A Criticism Criticised
The Spheres of Inanimate Objects

Thomas E. Karr

(English)

(February 1893)

Publications:

CTD entry in Russian: Карр Т.Э. - Критика раскритикована

DATA

Title for references: Karr TE - A Criticism Criticised
Short description:

Thomas E. Karr

A Criticism Criticised

The Spheres of Inanimate Objects

A reply to Cyril Travers's critique, in the October 1892 Theosophist, of the author's earlier article "The Spheres of Inanimate Objects" (July 1892).

335My attention has only recently been called to a paper with the above title in the October Theosophist, in which my critic contends that it is difficult to determine by my article in July Path on the "Spheres of Inanimate Objects" "whether the writer was fully satisfied that his experiments reasonably demonstrate his hypothesis", when in the paragraph below it is stated that "Mr. Karr considers his hypothesis to have become reasonably demonstrated."

In the face of such cross-statements, and of others which will be noticed later on, it is somewhat difficult to handle the subject seriously.

Mr. Travers's next complaint is that I have failed to make it entirely clear in my paper whether inanimate objects are devoid, or not, of any aura. One would have thought from the mere title 336of the article in question let alone its matter, that this point had been given sufficient prominence, inasmuch as inanimate objects are admitted to have certain obscure properties that, for want of a better term, we call sphere or aura. But not mindful of this tacit admission my critic proceeds to ask, with a passing allusion to my confusion of mind, "What does Mr. Karr mean? Are his readers to understand that objects are devoid of any aura whatever?" Then, a ray of light flashing in upon his darkness, he demands, "Or does Mr. Karr mean that the aura of an object is barren until impressed by the thought of individuals or the associations of a locality?" Surely the instances I recorded would seem to make this latter surmise inferentially clear enough to most readers, even without the direct statement of such a belief on page 113 (July PATH.) It was the purpose of the writer throughout, to show from his own careful investigations that, however rank the scepticism and loud the denials of those unfamiliar with psychic phenomena, there manifestly is some inherent quality, call it what you will, resident in inanimate objects. That this quality appeared to be a neutral one seemed reasonably demonstrated by the experiments recorded: neutral, I say, forasmuch as the objects chosen were in each several instance incapable of giving out any clue to their structure, origin, or habitat, save as these missing facts were read into them, so to say, by the strongly positive current of a mind aware of all three factors, or, as in certain instances, where by personal contiguity the active quality of an organic structure had been superimposed on the passive sphere of the inanimate object.

Mr. Travers intimates it is from familiarity with Reichenbach's writings that I derive authorization for the idea of spheres around objects. I would, however, say that though possessing both Reichenbach's and Gregory's works, and especially curious as are the accounts given by the former experimenter, I do not place reliance for the fact of spheres surrounding objects on the record of these authors alone. Far more trustworthy, to my mind, is the evidence of independent clairvoyants of good character and undoubted sincerity who, with no theory behind them to sustain, claim to see the glow emanating from things. It may even become a question, in the light of a fuller knowledge of the powers of the mind and its strange intricacies, if in Reichenbach's experiments with his sensitives anything beyond the power of thought-transference is proved; for it must be borne in mind that his theory of crystals and metals was exceedingly dear unto him, and his mind, saturated with his own idea and dominating the plastic sphere of his 337sensitive, naturally projected all that he thought concerning their properties into the mind vibrating in unison with his own, and, as usual in such cases, the subject received the given idea pictorially, and saw what the agent wished him to see. This is not so unlikely an assumption in view of what takes place every day in experiments of an hypnotic order, when we remember that other investigators following Reichenbach's methods failed utterly to obtain his results.

Of Prof. Denton's experiments, which are also cited by my critic on one leaf as authoritative proofs (see p. 42, Theosophist, October) and on the page facing the former (see 43, ditto) are conceded to have been often carelessly made, it may be said that such slovenly conducted and badly recorded researches cannot be held to have much scientific value.

To turn now to Mr. Travers's examination in detail of my first batch of experiments which he refers to as Nos. I, II, III, and IV, but as he does not take them in the order related this numeration may be somewhat misleading.

In Case No. I the critic regrets that it was not stated whether the agent had actually visited the Palace of the Cæsars or not. It so happens that he had, and that it was familiar ground to him; but even were the reverse the case, given an educated person with the degree of cultivation that reading, familiarity with engravings, and conversation with travellers would bestow, the evidence for thought-transference would still be unshaken. In spite of the distinct assertion on p. 110 of Path article that there followed this test "a minute description of the past and present appearance of the historic site", our friend solemnly declares that this "very important point is left unmentioned by the writer." To a careful reader, therefore, the conclusion arrived at is hardly a forced one, that the description of the locality by the clairvoyant was in response to the clear mental image called up, consciously or unconsciously, in the agent's mind by the mere act of handling the bit of pavement. And here I must put in a mild protest to the charge advanced that "Mr. Karr seems to wish to explain the case as one of pure thought-transference", as I hoped I had made it quite patent in the preamble that neither I nor my coadjutors were laboring under any preconceptions for or against a particular theory, but were intent only on a search for facts, which motive would exclude any provings in accordance with merely personal preferences and wishes. The reason for advancing an explanation on the telepathic hypothesis is that in researches like these one takes a rational solution near at hand on familiar ground, rather 338than wander far afield for one based on some pet superstition, or on a vague and yet unproved theory.

In Case No. II it is contended that the servant girl test is useless, "because she may have overlaid the real aura of the object by her own aura, which seems to have been the case"; but unhappily this surmise is nowhere near the truth, for, as it happens, the girl hit off some correct items concerning individuals who had just before been handling the object (not last in the number), which demonstrates that if any aura overlaid the object's own it belonged to the forenamed persons. But the admission thus made by Mr. Travers that auras of objects can thus be overlaid affords valuable support to my hypothesis that the original spheres of things are neutral.

In a magazine article limited in length it is impossible to dwell upon details, else in No. III it would have been told how in the test with the "never worn trinket" what were characterized as the commonplace statements that would naturally be suggested by the object were in fact precisely those Mr. Travers makes, i. e., that it was of metal, had come from some dark place (presumably the mine or jeweller's box), had been handled by people with sharp things (tools?), etc., etc., all of which amounts to nothing as far as psychometry or clairvoyance is concerned, but which considerably strengthens the telepathic hypothesis, inasmuch as every one of the statements made was doubtless, and almost inevitably, formulated as an idea in the mind of the agent who handled the object. I will here say in passing that the suggestion offered by Mr. Travers for the purpose of testing the thought-transference theory, of taking a fragment of an Egyptian monument and thinking of it as a Roman relic whereby to conjure up before the sensitive's mind the scene of the Via Sacra overhung by the Arch of Titus, would make an extremely good experiment, and one I would gladly try on some future occasion.

In the case of the antique, which the sensitive failed so utterly to describe, it may be added now that, though it had never been worn by its past owner, she cherished it as the very apple of her eye, that it was for a quarter of a century in her immediate surroundings, often looked at and handled, hence one would not unnaturally have looked for some description of her and her environment, in the failure to obtain anything of the object's original surroundings. Oddly enough, in place of either of these reflections the article dimly gave out, as in the case of the "never worn trinket", its latest contacts. While I was packing it to send away by express, two interruptions came in the shape of visits. I 339left the article each time, and immediately returned to it upon my caller's departure to complete the preparations for its safe transit. All that the clairvoyant sensed of the actual history of the object was that a gentleman had got it travelling (which was only partially accurate), that it was silver (really gold), and that it had been made out of a dish or other vessel (not an unlikely assumption), — all of which, except the second statement, might have been conveyed through the agent's mind to the percipient's. What cannot be so explained is what followed, when the Christian name of one of my visitors and the relationship to me were given, coupled with a statement as to the person's health which had been a topic of conversation, though I was unaware at the time of having been much impressed by what had passed between us. The agent, it must be added, was unaware of the very existence of this individual, as was also the clairvoyant in her normal state.

If this does not go towards establishing the hypothesis that the sphere of objects is negative until stamped by the positive influences they have been in touch with, I am at a loss to know what it does point to, and will be much indebted to anyone who will advance a more plausible theory that will knock this one into a cocked hat. It would afford rare sport, and "may I be there to see!" — as Macaulay sang in his ballad.

That the sensitives with whom these experiments were conducted were clairvoyants and not psychometers, as Mr. Travers suggests, (if there be any appreciable distinction between the two), is controverted by the case of the watch when a house was described, unknown to the owner of the watch even by hearsay, which subsequently was found to be correct after long investigation. And here comes in the "sphere borrowed from a locality" on which Mr. Travers animadverts so strongly. A locality identified with human beings, such as the Palace of the Cæsars and a dwelling house in Italy, must have received more or less the imprint of the builders' and dwellers' and frequenters' minds, which collective forces could hardly fail to be mirrored in the, as contended, passive spheres of the surrounding inanimate objects. This is what I have meant to convey by a sphere borrowed from a locality, though necessarily the locality first receives the impress from the master force of man's mind. The hypothetical case of the sea-shell cited by Mr. Travers is not an analogous one; but it would afford an interesting trial, though I doubt much from my past experiences if anything more than its recent contacts and human environments would be elicited. Were, however, a correct picture of the bottom of the sea to be given by the sensitive, how 340could the possibility of thought-transference be guarded against, even with the agent consciously ignorant of the nature of the shell, when we take into consideration the evidence collected by some of the most acute investigators of England, Prof. Lodge, F. W. H. Myers, and others, for an underlying stratum of consciousness (which Theosophists will recognize as analogous to the plane of our Higher Ego) which is apparently almost omniscient in its quality, and which seems to be the telepathic channel of communication?

No one will endorse more heartily than I myself the recommendation of my critic as to the expediency of making trials with more than one percipient, though the difficulty of finding really reliable and otherwise competent sensitives is greater than anyone can imagine unless one has oneself set forth on the quest. All paid mediums, clairvoyants, and the like, have been excluded on account of the strong aversion they usually manifest to the imposition of scientific conditions, — without which all such trials are valueless. Sensitives in private circles are extremely difficult to approach, and, indeed, usually conceal their gifts with such care that the inquirer often remains ignorant of their possession by acquaintances tolerably well known to him. If any of my readers interested in the subject of these investigations, to whom good psychometers and sensitives of perfect integrity of character are personally known, such as exercise the faculty with no mercenary motive, I would be pleased to receive their names and addresses with a view to further trials in the same direction.

In conclusion, I would add a word on Mr. Travers's inclination to draw a distinction between psychometry and clairvoyance. In my experience the line seems so impalpable between them that it is doubtful if the processes are distinct. At all events, we must have more authentic cases of what he calls "pure psychometry" than are at present on record, before we can give it a place by itself; as yet, only "mixed psychometry" is the rule. The whole subject is so complicated, wheels within wheels involved, that the mind is led on to an inextricable tangle of conflicting theories, and that anyone at this stage of our knowledge should constitute himself a special pleader, as in fact Mr. Travers has done for the occult theory, when we have absolutely no proofs as yet wherewith to support it, seems to me not only futile, but also injurious to the full and free acquisition of further knowledge. On this ground it is not enough to say, "I believe": one must have a reason — that is, proof — of the faith that is in you.

Thomas E. Karr, F. T. S.