Krishnamacharya ST - Catechism of Brahmanism

From Teopedia

!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!

Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Catechism of Brahmanism
(Concluded from July.)

S. T. Krishnamacharya

(English)

(October 1892)

The concluding installment of a question-and-answer catechism on Brahmanical philosophy: the soul's embodied nature as taught by Panchasika and the Sankhya school (ignorance, Karma, and desire as its components), the Yoga school's five causes of misery, and the doctrine of justification by faith in the Upanishads, with the Editor's closing note on its parallels in the Bhagavad-Gita and in Japanese Pure Land Buddhism.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Кришнамачарья, С. Т. - Катехизис брахманизма

DATA

Title for references: Krishnamacharya ST - Catechism of Brahmanism
Short description: The concluding installment of a question-and-answer catechism on Brahmanical philosophy: the soul's ...

S. T. Krishnamacharya

Catechism of Brahmanism

(Concluded from July.)

217Question.—What is soul? Mention some theories about its origin and nature.

Answer.—In the Veda the soul in its embodied state is called Panchajana or five-fold composite, and also Shodasa-Kalapursha, or a Pursha of sixteen parts. In the Sankya sutras it is called the twenty-five tatwa entity, being:

(1.) Prakriti, Mahat, Manas, Ahankara.

(2.) Five intellectual organs.

(3.) Five active organs.

(4.) Five Tanmatras.

(5.) Five elements, and Purusha, the latter being composed of the twenty-four tatwas and being the entity. This division is said to have arisen from a false construction of a Vedic text.

(62.) Q.—What is meant by the Vedic term Shodoshakalapancha? Can you explain what the fifteen parts are of which the soul is composed?

A.—It is said that Panchasika explains those fifteen parts as follows:

The soul is composed of:

(1.) Sensation of five intellectual organs,

(2.) Sensation of five organs of action,

(3.) Manas-Chitta-Ahankara, and the three qualities, Satwa, Rajas, and Tamas, thus making up the sixteen component parts.

Asita Devata explains the soul in its embodied state as being composite of the sensations of the organs of intellect and action, Manas-Buddhi-Ahankara with the three qualities Satwa, Rajas, and Tamas.

(63.) Q.—What is the doctrine of Panchasika on the origin and nature of the Soul in its embodied state?

A.—According to him it is a collection of groups of sensations. The first factor in its formation is Avidya, ignorance. The others are Karma and Trishna or desire. He represents the origin figuratively as: Avidya as the field, Karma as the seed, Trishna as the water by which these components grow the idea of soul. He further maintains that there can be no personal identity between the embodied and unembodied soul. The "I" in the embodied soul, which is the product of the three forces of Avidya, Karma, and Trishna, and also of the several groups of sensation, has no 218manner of connection with the "I" of the unembodied soul, as the latter cannot be analyzed into any such parts.

(64.) Q.—What purpose does the doctrine of the non-identity of the emancipated and non-emancipated soul serve in the philosophy of Panchasika?

A.—It is the hinge-doctrine upon which his whole philosophy turns.

(65.) Q.—Explain this.

A.—We have seen that, according to Panchasika, Trishna or desire is one of the important factors in the formation of the soul and in its transmigration through various bodies; it is the principal cause of Egotism. If it even be proved that Egotism — which is founded upon the idea of "I" — does not belong to the embodied soul and that it is therefore a false idea, then, according to him, the misery of existence has no real foundation but is solely based upon ignorance. Therefore the means for destroying the misery of existence is by the knowledge that there is no identity between embodied and non-embodied souls. Hence he contends that by constantly meditating on this non-identity and by renouncing all merit, a man attains to emancipation or Nirvana.

(66.) Q.—Can you mention any divine philosophy which maintains the doctrine of emancipation by knowledge — called Nirvana by Gnyana, or knowledge?

A.—The Yoga school which believes in a Supreme Being maintains this doctrine.

(67.) Q.—According to the Yoga school, what are the causes of misery?

A.—The causes of misery according to that school are five.

(68.) Q.—What are those?

A.—(1.) Avidya or ignorance,

(2.) Asmita, or misapplication of concept,

(3.) Desire,

(4.) Aversion,

(5.) Attachment.

(69.) Q.—What is ignorance?

A.—The idea that,

(1.) What is not natural is natural,

(2.) What is not pure is pure,

(3.) What is not happy is happiness,

(4.) What is not so is so.

(70.) Q.—What is Asmita?

A.—The blending together the power which knows with the instruments for knowing.

219(71.) What is desire?

A.—It is that which dwells on pleasure.

(72.) Q.—What is aversion?

A.—It is that which dwells on pain.

(73.) Q.—What is attachment?

A.—It is the very strong desire for things of this world, which mislead even the learned.

(74.) Q.—What is the cause of emancipation from these?

A.—One must overcome them by knowledge and by resignation to the Supreme Being.

(75.) Q.—What is meant by resignation to the Supreme Being?

A.—Placing implicit faith in God and dedicating all our acts to Him. It is the same as the doctrine of justification by faith.

(76.) Q.—Is the doctrine of justification by faith taught in the Vedas?

A.—Yes, it is in the Taittireya Upanishad, where it is said that Nyassa Vidya, or the doctrine of justification by faith, is one which is different from all others, and that it consists in the dedication of and joining our souls with the Supreme Being. In the sacrificial phraseology it is known as the Soul Offering.

(77.) Q.—What are the essential points of the doctrine of justification by faith?

A.—Those are:

(1.) The inability of man to obtain salvation by means of Works.

(2.) The necessity for an implicit faith in the divine grace.

(3.) The grace of God comes of its own accord, irrespective of man's merit.

(78.) Q.—Can you quote a passage from the Upanishad to show that the divine grace proceeds at the first instance from the Divine Being directly, irrespective of man's merit?

A.—In the Katha Upanishad it is said: The Supreme Soul cannot be reached by constant lecturing nor by intelligence, nor by universal knowledge. To him whom the Supreme selects of its own accord it reveals its own nature.

(79.) Q.—You said that the doctrine of justification by faith is different from all other doctrines of salvation. Wherein consists the difference?

A.—In all the doctrines the means and the end are different. For instance, in the doctrine of justification by works, the Means are merits and God is the End. But in the doctrine of justification by faith the Means and the End are God himself. He is the Means for obtaining God, and works are not.

(80.) Q.—How is this idea expressed in the Upanishads?

220A.—There it is said: He is the Bridge. Now a bridge is only a means for crossing. By this phrase the Upanishad simply means that God is the means for obtaining God. From this fact the doctrine of Justification by Faith is also called the doctrine of Permanent Means.

OM. THE END.


[Note by the Editor on questions 76 to end.]

It has been commonly supposed by most Theosophists that only in the Christian religion the doctrine of Justification by Faith exists, or at least that it has no place in Brahmanism. But very clearly it is in Brahmanism, and all learned Brahmins will support the views put forward in the above questions. I remember a conversation I had with Mohini M. Chatterji, who is well versed in his own religion, in which he asserted this doctrine most positively as Brahmanical. He quoted Bhagavad-Gita where it says that the Self chooses its own. So also in the Japanese Buddhist sects the doctrine is found. The Shin-shu and the Jo-do-shu sects teach the Doctrine of the Pure Land by which one can be saved by faith alone. The Jo-do says: "In the great sea of the Law of Buddha faith is the only means to enter." But all this does not mean that salvation by works is not possible also. Indeed, it seems to me that in Brahmanism and the Japanese Buddhism reference is made only to this or any other present life, and it must be admitted that no Ego would have the faith in any life to rely solely on the doctrine unless in prior lives, no matter how far distant, it had by works acquired the ability to at last in that life attain to and have complete faith. If so, then the final faith leading to salvation resulted from works.