Bots, Editors (Semantic MediaWiki), trusted
6,234
edits
(Apply agreed Lucifer edition formatting, author categories, and journal text allocation.) |
(Prepare Lucifer volume VI: proofread journal texts, author cards, illustrations and linked contents.) |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
| original title = The Barisal Guns | | original title = The Barisal Guns | ||
| has text = yes | | has text = yes | ||
| publications = [[Lucifer/Vol3|''Lucifer'', vol. 3]], no. 13, September 1888, pp. 4-14 | | publications = [[Lucifer/Vol3|''Lucifer'', vol. 3]], no. 13, September 1888, pp. 4-14; [[Lucifer/Vol6|''Lucifer'', vol. 6]], no. 34, June 1890, pp. 287-291 | ||
| read links = [[Lucifer/Vol3/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]] | | read links = [[Lucifer/Vol3/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]]; [[Lucifer/Vol6/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]] | ||
| download links = [https://opusmagnum.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/lucifer_v3.pdf Original volume (PDF)] | | download links = [https://opusmagnum.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/lucifer_v3.pdf Original volume (PDF)]; {{tw|Text/English/Periodicals/Lucifer/|Original journal scans (PDF)|}} | ||
| origin = English: H.S. Olcott, ''The Barisal Guns'' | | origin = English: H.S. Olcott, ''The Barisal Guns'' | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 176: | Line 176: | ||
It seems to me – who am not a Hindu (this time) but only a believer in the Aryans and their wisdom – more than likely that the Barisâl Guns are occult phenomena, that the ''Devatas,'' or nature-spirits, are the artillerymen, and that possibly the thing traces back to some awful tragedy in or near the Gangetic Delta. About such astral detonations, in quality if not degree, there is a mass of accessible testimony in European books; but, as no more space can be spared in the present number of the magazine for enlargement upon the topic, I shall reserve for a future number what can be said on the occult side of the question. Our friends, the spiritualists, should be interested, as the discussion will have to deal with their own familiar phenomena. | It seems to me – who am not a Hindu (this time) but only a believer in the Aryans and their wisdom – more than likely that the Barisâl Guns are occult phenomena, that the ''Devatas,'' or nature-spirits, are the artillerymen, and that possibly the thing traces back to some awful tragedy in or near the Gangetic Delta. About such astral detonations, in quality if not degree, there is a mass of accessible testimony in European books; but, as no more space can be spared in the present number of the magazine for enlargement upon the topic, I shall reserve for a future number what can be said on the occult side of the question. Our friends, the spiritualists, should be interested, as the discussion will have to deal with their own familiar phenomena. | ||
{{Style P-Signature in capitals|1=H. S. Olcott.}} | {{Page aside in Lucifer|v=6|n=34|p=287}} | ||
<center>II.</center> | |||
[We reprint from the last number of the ''Theosophist'' an article on a most interesting and mysterious atmospheric phenomenon called the Barisál Gun, the discussion of which was begun in the ''Theosophist'' and ''Lucifer'' for September, 1888, by Colonel Olcott.] | |||
THOUGH nearly two years have passed since the Asiatic Society of Bengal issued a circular and organized a system of close scientific observation, the mystery remains as inexplicable as ever. Apparently it will ever remain so to those who confine their research to the theories and methods of physical science. If it is ever to be solved, it must be by the efforts of occult students working on the lines of the theory of the multiple constitution of all Nature. | |||
In the opening essay the several theories of men of science were passed in review, and all pronounced inadequate on scientific grounds. For the information of new subscribers who may not have seen what was before written, let me give a few facts. At the town of Barisál, on the banks of the Beeghaye River, and elsewhere in the Gangetic Delta, have been heard, sporadically, and without traceable cause, since time immemorial, loud detonations like cannon-shots. While at Barisál, I heard them myself one evening, and thought them a salvo of artillery, fired within the distance of a half mile or mile. The sound is like nothing else in Nature; it is neither a rumbling, a crashing, nor a roaring; hence neither like the sound of thunder, the sea beating upon a strand, the fall of forest trees or buildings, nor the effect of gusts of wind rushing into caverns or through rugged cliffs. They are like gun-fire and nothing else in the world. Like the roar of large ordnance, too, not like the ring of a howitzer or a cannonade. I heard seven successive reports with brief intervals between, but they occur without any regularity, at different seasons of the year, at places widely apart in and about the vast alluvial plain of the Gangetic Delta, and coming from different points of the compass. | |||
Five theories have been offered to account for them: ''viz.,'' I. Surf-beating upon the shore (sixty-five miles away as the crow flies). II. The breaking down of river banks (of alluvial soil, free from rocks, and only a few feet in height). III. The firing of bombs by natives (a childishly weak theory in view of the facts). IV. Subterranean or sub-aqueous volcanic or seismic agencies (a theory at variance with all the geographical features of the Delta). V. Atmospheric electricity (a theory based upon no observed facts and no recognized laws of electrical action). | |||
{{Page aside in Lucifer|v=6|n=34|p=288}} | |||
The Asiatic Society, as above stated, duly issued a circular, and the Honorary Secretary has now kindly sent me the reported results. Fifteen forms were filled up and returned to the Secretary. The observations were made at Khulna, Barisál, Moyapore, Narainganj, Noakhali, Harispur and Daulat. None of the reports refer to the same day, nor to the same hours, while the same observer would hear the “guns” at dates considerably apart. These plainly indicate that the “guns” are not waves of sound travelling over wide areas, but heard at isolated places: hence going to discredit the theory that they are due to the beating of surf-rollers upon the beach of the Bay of Bengal. The reports agree as to there having been cloudy or rainy weather at the time the sounds were heard or during the previous twenty-four hours. They seem to be independent of the wind, being heard as well against as with it: in one case while a strong wind was blowing from S.W. the “guns” were heard from S.S.E., as they had been two days before when there was a light wind from S.E. | |||
All the observers, save three, negative the theory that the “guns” are due to electrical disturbance, and all, that they are dependent upon the state of the tides in the Bay of Bengal or in the rivers. In the case for electricity, Mr. Rainey says thunder was heard before and after the sounds; but the thunder came from the S.E., while the “guns” were from the S.W. Though one observer, Mr. Waller, heard more “guns” on four days about the middle of August than on all others together, during which period there was disturbed weather at the head of the Bay, yet it is also noticed that they were heard during a period of calm weather, which again militates against the surf-roar theory. A river-steamer captain gives his evidence strongly against the theories of the sounds being caused by the falling of the river-banks and by bombs – therein corroborating the opinion expressed by myself in the former article. | |||
Finally, the Committee of the Asiatic Society unanimously declare against the theories of volcanic action and of the action of tides upon the shoal called the “Swash of no-ground”. They think the most plausible opinion thus far advanced is that the sounds may be “connected with the river banks, and that their frequent occurrence during two or three days immediately preceding the arrival of disturbed weather from the Bay of Bengal, may be attributed to the atmosphere being highly charged with moisture, and the comparatively calm weather which occurs at such times”. Which, under favor be it said, is about as pretty a case of ''petitio principii'' as I ever met with. Though the “guns” have been heard since several hundred years, and were never connected either by the native farmers, boatmen or seamen, with bad weather in the Bay; though they have been heard at all seasons of the year, in fair weather as in foul, from the southward and northward, and over a wide stretch of the Gangetic Delta – we are now asked by the Committee to accept their theory above stated. For my part, I decline; and I find the view very reasonable of Babu Gaurdás Bysack, a member of the Committee itself, that the sounds {{Page aside in Lucifer|v=6|n=34|p=289}}cannot be due to their transmission by the river banks, since there are many other river banks in other parts of the Ganges where similar sounds are ''never'' heard. | |||
One very curious fact crops up in these reports. Mr. Waller, riding up to his house and coming within fifty yards of the steps, ''did not hear the'' “''guns''”, ''while his bearer, standing on the steps waiting for his master, did hear them.'' Does this fit in with either of the physical theories under discussion? | |||
It is not my purpose to attempt any definite solution of this acoustic problem: I confine myself to the easy task of following the materialistic scientists through their speculative flounderings and showing their failure to come to any better hypothesis than the “superstitious” one of the “ignorant natives”, ''viz.,'' that the Barisál Gun is a phenomenon connected with the agency of elemental spirits ( ''devatas'' ). It is as valid a case for speculation as either of the others. At Barisál itself, the vortex of these phenomena, no change has been made in public opinion since the date of my previous reports, for Babu Aswini Kumar Datta, my learned correspondent, writes me under date of 23rd March: “We have not yet succeeded in finding out anything new about the Barisál Guns. All surmises and conjectures about them are known to you.” | |||
It must be noted that a variety of puzzling atmospheric acoustical phenomena are heard in different parts of the world, some like the Barisál Gun, others quite different. From the (Calcutta) ''Statesman'' of 11th January, 1890, I take the following: – | |||
{{Style P-Quote|1=“Various theories have been propounded from time to time to account for the phenomenon commonly known as the ‘Barisál Guns’, but so far as we know, none of them can be said to offer a satisfactory explanation. It is well known that this mysterious booming is not peculiar to Barisál, but has been noted in Cochin China and in certain islands in the West Indies. There seems, however, to be some difference in the sound heard, some authorities stating that it seems to proceed from a thousand Æolian harps, others that the noise was like that of the bursting of a huge bladder or like the booming of guns at sea, and in some cases it was compared to a humming similar to that which a locomotive sometimes makes when blowing off steam. Travellers who have visited Trinidad have been much struck with these unaccountable sounds, and a correspondent who has devoted some attention to the subject refers us to some works in which the matter has been widely discussed, ''but with no definite results.'' In an account of his trip to Monos, an island near Trinidad, Charles Kingsley describes the peculiar sensation caused by an unearthly sound which, like those of the Barisál guns, was from seaward. He writes: ‘Between the howls of the wind I became aware of a strange noise from seaward – a booming, or rather humming. It was faint and distant, but deep and strong enough to set one guessing its cause. The sea beating into caves seemed, at first, the simplest answer. But the water was so still on our side of the island, that I could barely hear the lap of the ripple on the shingle twenty yards off; and the nearest surf was a mile or two away, over a mountain a thousand feet high.’ He then mentions that on bathing the next day during a perfect calm, the same mysterious booming sound was heard, and it was generally ascribed to the drum fish, which we are told is almost as mythical as the Australian bunyip and ‘is answerable for a number of vague and inexplicable submarine phenomena’.”}} | |||
{{Page aside in Lucifer|v=6|n=34|p=290}} | |||
Of course, the interesting fact in all these observations is that the cause of the acoustic phenomenon ''is always a mystery''; it cannot be traced to known physical causes. So that when we take them all into consideration with the Barisál Gun, the theory of the action of elemental spirits is strengthened, while that of physical action is much weakened. Only an Irish Echo could be expected to convert surf-beatings or slumping river banks into the sound of “a thousand Æolian harps”, or that of “a humming similar to that which a locomotive sometimes makes when blowing off steam”. And not even the best echo ever heard by Lady Wilde, Douglas Hyde, or my friend William Yeats, could climb over a hill a thousand feet high, on a clear sunshiny day! | |||
One unanimous conclusion of the Asiatic Society’s Committee is hard to understand: they think, as above stated, that the “guns” may be attributed to the atmosphere “being highly charged with moisture, and the comparatively calm weather which occurs at such times”. But is it not true that reports of gun-fire are sharp and clear under a perfectly clear sky, but indistinct, and attended by a long-continued roll like thunder, when the sky is cloudy? And is not the rumble of thunder due to reflexion from the clouds? Now, since the Barisál Guns are not rumbling noises, but distinct booms as of cannon, what physical basis is there for the acoustic theory the Committee have put forth? It is affirmed as a scientific fact that during a shower of rain or snow sounds are greatly deadened. If the soil of the Gangetic Delta between Barisál and the Bay of Bengal were hard, dry and of a uniform character, and rested upon a continuous stratum of rock, then we might more readily accept the theory that the “guns” under discussion were explicable upon the theory of an echoing, or rather conduction, of the crash of surf-rollers upon the shore of the Bay. But the fact being that the whole vast plain is a deposit of alluvium of great depth, intersected by a network of rivers and rivulets zig-zagging about in every variety of curve, and leaving nowhere even a straight water-course or offering a foot of resonant hard dry ground, that supposition seems in conflict with the known basis of acoustical science. Sir David Brewster tells us, and all other experimentalists confirm him in saying it, that the difference in the audibility of sounds that pass over homogeneous and over mixed media is sometimes so remarkable as to astonish those who witness it. The insuperable difficulty in accepting the theory of echo in this case is that it does not fit in with the facts – atmospheric, geographical or geological. The breaking of surf on a shore is a fixed phenomenon, sure to recur with every repetition of the same conditions of weather in the Bay. If therefore, the “guns” heard at so many widely-separated points in the Delta, were due to the echo of the surf-booming transmitted between the banks of the many mouths of the Ganges, ''they should always be heard at the same places when there was heavy'' ''weather at the head of the Bay;'' and, as the surf-beating lasts as long as the stormy weather, there should be an unbroken succession of “guns” heard {{Page aside in Lucifer|v=6|n=34|p=291}}throughout that spell of weather. But this is not the case: quite the contrary; a single “gun” or a series of a half-dozen, more or less, may be heard at Barisál or some other place, on one or more days in a given year, and ''not again throughout the whole twelvemonth;'' or they may be heard somewhere else and not there at all that year, though they had been in the previous one, or may be in the one following. Nature does not indulge in such vagaries. And what is a very strange and suspicious circumstance, the “guns” may be heard by one person and not by another a few yards off! Does this not go rather to support the hypothesis that the reports of the mysterious artillery are of an elemental spiritual origin, sometimes reaching the inner auditory sense of an individual who is momentarily sensitive to akasic vibrations, and heard only then by him? If not, then where is the fresh physical theory which will not break down under even so imperfectly close a study as we have given to the several tentative hypotheses recorded by the Asiatic Society of Bengal? The Committee place most value upon the report of Mr. Manson, an official who has lived many years in this Delta and heard the guns in August-October, 1875, in the Nokhali District in 1878-79, in the cold-weather season, and at Barisál in 1876, in the latter part of October. Mr. Manson favors the theory that they are echoes of masses of river-bank tumbling into the water or due to other local sound-producing causes. But the objection is, as above noted, that the “guns” come sporadically, in all times of the year, never regularly, never so as to be expected, nor invariably when masses of the river-banks erode – “as usually happens when the ebb is running out”. The tabulated digest of returns from fifteen observations given in the Committee’s Report, shows that the “guns” were heard five times during the ebb-tide, six times during the flood, three times at high tide, and once at half-tide. There appears, then, to be no necessary connexion between the “guns” and an ebbing tide – when the caving of the banks is most common. And so it is but too evident that I was strictly within bounds in saying at the commencement of my present article that, despite the Asiatic Society's best efforts, the mystery of the weird Barisál Guns is as unsolved as it was before this research was begun, and as it has been within the three or four centuries that have slipped by since our present local traditions took their date. | |||
Having thus exhausted the subject on its physical side, I shall in a third and closing chapter discuss the subject in its relations with occult dynamics. | |||
{{Style P-Signature in capitals|1=H. S. Olcott, P.T.S.}} | |||
{{Footnotes}} | {{Footnotes}} | ||