Bots, Editors (Semantic MediaWiki), trusted
12,584
edits
m (Снята искусственная разбивка текста по страницам журнала) |
m (Снята искусственная разбивка текста по страницам журнала) |
||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
Mr. Subba Row in his "Notes on the Bhagavad Gita," p. 301, says: "Now as regards the number of principles and their relation between themselves, this sevenfold classification, which I do not mean to adopt, seems to me to be a very unscientific and misleading one." In "''Five Years of Theosophy''" I find an article by Mr. Subba Row in which he upholds the septenary division of principles in man in this wise (see p. 161): "Now these seven ''entities'', which in their totality constitute man, are as follows. I shall enumerate them in the order adopted in the 'Fragments' as far as the two orders (the Brahmanical and the Tibetan) ''coincide''." Again, he tells us that "the knowledge of ''the occult powers of Nature possessed by the inhabitants of the lost Atlantis was learned by the ancient adepts of India and was appended by them to the esoteric doctrine taught by the residents of the sacred island.''" Again, p.160, "Now according to the adepts of ancient Aryavarta, ''seven principles'' are evolved out of ''three primary entities''. Algebra teaches us that the number of ''combinations'' of ''n'' things taken ''one'' at a time, ''two'' at a time, ''three'' at a time, and so forth, =2''ⁿ''−1. Applying this formula to the present case, the number of entities evolved from different combinations of these three primary causes amounts to 2³−1=8−1=7." Will Mr. Subba Row kindly explain what there is in these, his former statements, which is so "''very unscientific and misleading''?" | Mr. Subba Row in his "Notes on the Bhagavad Gita," p. 301, says: "Now as regards the number of principles and their relation between themselves, this sevenfold classification, which I do not mean to adopt, seems to me to be a very unscientific and misleading one." In "''Five Years of Theosophy''" I find an article by Mr. Subba Row in which he upholds the septenary division of principles in man in this wise (see p. 161): "Now these seven ''entities'', which in their totality constitute man, are as follows. I shall enumerate them in the order adopted in the 'Fragments' as far as the two orders (the Brahmanical and the Tibetan) ''coincide''." Again, he tells us that "the knowledge of ''the occult powers of Nature possessed by the inhabitants of the lost Atlantis was learned by the ancient adepts of India and was appended by them to the esoteric doctrine taught by the residents of the sacred island.''" Again, p.160, "Now according to the adepts of ancient Aryavarta, ''seven principles'' are evolved out of ''three primary entities''. Algebra teaches us that the number of ''combinations'' of ''n'' things taken ''one'' at a time, ''two'' at a time, ''three'' at a time, and so forth, =2''ⁿ''−1. Applying this formula to the present case, the number of entities evolved from different combinations of these three primary causes amounts to 2³−1=8−1=7." Will Mr. Subba Row kindly explain what there is in these, his former statements, which is so "''very unscientific and misleading''?" | ||
Particularly in the following passage he shows the important part which the number ''seven'' plays not only in the Microcosm, but in the Macrocosm, viz.: "I may mention in this connection that our philosophers have associated seven ''occult powers'' with the seven ''principles'' or ''entities'' | Particularly in the following passage he shows the important part which the number ''seven'' plays not only in the Microcosm, but in the Macrocosm, viz.: "I may mention in this connection that our philosophers have associated seven ''occult powers'' with the seven ''principles'' or ''entities'' {{Page aside in Path|v=2|n=1|p=8}}above mentioned. The seven occult powers in the microcosm correspond with, or are the counterparts of, the occult powers in the macrocosm. The mental and spiritual consciousness of the individual becomes the general consciousness of ''Brahman'' when the barrier of individuality is wholly removed, and when the seven powers in the microcosm are placed ''en rapport'' with the seven powers in the macrocosm." | ||
{{Page aside in Path|v=2|n=1|p=8}} | |||
above mentioned. The seven occult powers in the microcosm correspond with, or are the counterparts of, the occult powers in the macrocosm. The mental and spiritual consciousness of the individual becomes the general consciousness of ''Brahman'' when the barrier of individuality is wholly removed, and when the seven powers in the microcosm are placed ''en rapport'' with the seven powers in the macrocosm." | |||
In pondering over these apparent contradictions the only rational conclusion that I can arrive at is that though Mr. Subba Row accepts the septenary classification as being the esoteric and true one, relating as it does to Nature in all its different phases, he finds that for purposes of practical teaching it is preferable for untutored minds to give the condensed fourfold classification as specified in page 161, "''Five Years of Theosophy''," reserving the septenary division for the more advanced students? This is the only way in which I can account for the discrepancies in the teachings, and I find also that he himself says on page 301 (Febrary ''Theosophist'') "and so, for all ''practical purposes''—for the purpose of explaining the doctrines of religious philosophy—I have found it ''far more convenient'' to adhere to the fourfold classification than to adopt the septenary one and multiply principles in a manner more likely to introduce confusion than to throw light upon the subject." | In pondering over these apparent contradictions the only rational conclusion that I can arrive at is that though Mr. Subba Row accepts the septenary classification as being the esoteric and true one, relating as it does to Nature in all its different phases, he finds that for purposes of practical teaching it is preferable for untutored minds to give the condensed fourfold classification as specified in page 161, "''Five Years of Theosophy''," reserving the septenary division for the more advanced students? This is the only way in which I can account for the discrepancies in the teachings, and I find also that he himself says on page 301 (Febrary ''Theosophist'') "and so, for all ''practical purposes''—for the purpose of explaining the doctrines of religious philosophy—I have found it ''far more convenient'' to adhere to the fourfold classification than to adopt the septenary one and multiply principles in a manner more likely to introduce confusion than to throw light upon the subject." | ||