Jump to content

Judge W.Q. - The Impudence of Modern Philosophers: Difference between revisions

m
Add Path-specific page markup (checked against the scan)
m (Add full-chain previous/next navigation per the JCW table of contents)
m (Add Path-specific page markup (checked against the scan))
 
Line 6: Line 6:
  | publication date sortable = 1891-12
  | publication date sortable = 1891-12
  | publication place = ''The Path''
  | publication place = ''The Path''
  | read links = [https://theosophylib.com/wqj/the-impudence-of-modern-philosophers/ TheosophyLib.com]
  | read links = [[Path/Vol6/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]]; [https://theosophylib.com/wqj/the-impudence-of-modern-philosophers/ TheosophyLib.com]
  | publications = ''The Path'', December 1891; ''Echoes of the Orient: The Writings of William Quan Judge'', comp. Dara Eklund, 2nd ed. (Pasadena, California: Theosophical University Press, 2011), vol. I, p. 220
  | publications = [[Path/Vol6/Text|''The Path'', vol. VI, no. 9]], December 1891, pp. 283-284; ''Echoes of the Orient: The Writings of William Quan Judge'', comp. Dara Eklund, 2nd ed. (Pasadena, California: Theosophical University Press, 2011), vol. I, p. 220
  | ctd rus = Джадж У.К. - Наглость современных философов
  | ctd rus = Джадж У.К. - Наглость современных философов
  | previous = [[Judge W.Q. - Hypocrisy or Ignorance|Hypocrisy or Ignorance]]
  | previous = [[Judge W.Q. - Hypocrisy or Ignorance|Hypocrisy or Ignorance]]
  | next = [[Judge W.Q. - Theosophy and Epidemics|Theosophy and Epidemics]]
  | next = [[Judge W.Q. - Theosophy and Epidemics|Theosophy and Epidemics]]
}}
}}
{{Page aside margins}}


{{Page aside in Path|v=6|n=9|p=283}}
In Herbert Spencer’s new book Justice, he defines that principle thus: “Every man is free to do that which he wills, provided he infringes not the equal freedom of any other man,” and then goes on to say in his appendix that for more than thirty years he was the first to recognize this “equal freedom” as the summing up of justice in the abstract. But not till 1883 did this modern philosopher discover that Kant had made the same formula. He does not appear to know or recognize the French method of putting it in the Declaration of the Rights of Man, nor the attempt to insist upon it in the American Revolution, nor, indeed, in the thousands of declarations make long before the birth of Spencer.
In Herbert Spencer’s new book Justice, he defines that principle thus: “Every man is free to do that which he wills, provided he infringes not the equal freedom of any other man,” and then goes on to say in his appendix that for more than thirty years he was the first to recognize this “equal freedom” as the summing up of justice in the abstract. But not till 1883 did this modern philosopher discover that Kant had made the same formula. He does not appear to know or recognize the French method of putting it in the Declaration of the Rights of Man, nor the attempt to insist upon it in the American Revolution, nor, indeed, in the thousands of declarations make long before the birth of Spencer.


{{Page aside in Path|v=6|n=9|p=284}}
We have nothing to say against Mr. Spencer’s motives, but a great deal against the impudence, perhaps of an unconscious kind, of the schools of modern philosophers of which he forms one. Laboriously for years they write books and construct systems of thought called new by themselves, but as old as any Egyptian pyramid. These systems and formulas they make up in the most refreshing ignorance of what the ancients said about the same things, for “surely,” they seem to be saying, “what could the ancients have knows of such deep matters?” The theory that no energy is lost was not for the first time known in the world when our moderns gave it out, nor is Mr. Spencer’s theory of evolution, nor even his statement of it, his invention or discovery. All these were known to the Ancients. They are found in the Bhagavad-Gita and in many another eastern philosophical book.
We have nothing to say against Mr. Spencer’s motives, but a great deal against the impudence, perhaps of an unconscious kind, of the schools of modern philosophers of which he forms one. Laboriously for years they write books and construct systems of thought called new by themselves, but as old as any Egyptian pyramid. These systems and formulas they make up in the most refreshing ignorance of what the ancients said about the same things, for “surely,” they seem to be saying, “what could the ancients have knows of such deep matters?” The theory that no energy is lost was not for the first time known in the world when our moderns gave it out, nor is Mr. Spencer’s theory of evolution, nor even his statement of it, his invention or discovery. All these were known to the Ancients. They are found in the Bhagavad-Gita and in many another eastern philosophical book.