Jump to content

HPB-SB-14-146: Difference between revisions

12,025 bytes added ,  Yesterday at 14:05
Публикация полного текста и источников по скану
(незначительные правки)
(Публикация полного текста и источников по скану)
Line 8: Line 8:
{{Style P-HPB SB. Title continued|A Personal and an Impersonal God.|14-145}}
{{Style P-HPB SB. Title continued|A Personal and an Impersonal God.|14-145}}


...
{{Style P-No indent|themselves, and love him as a veritable “Father who is in Heaven.” But there are others (who cannot accept these conceptions which to them seem derogatory to the Infinite and Absolute) who believe in an Impersonal God. They hold that God is not a mere magnified man; that he has no form or {{Style S-Small capitals|Persona}}, at any rate that we can conceive, that he is a spirit, all-pervading, all-sustaining, neither liable to anger, repentance or change, and hence panic (having always known from all eternity what was right and therefore what he willed), always working through immutable laws. Many of these (but by no means all) hold further that he is not ''conscious'' or ''intelligent'', in {{Style S-Small capitals|our}} sense of the word, because both these terms imply duality, an entity to cognize and a thing to be cognized whereas He is All in All and in Him, we and all things, move and live and have our being, but still that He is ''all'' consciousness and ''all'' intelligence. The believers therefore in an Impersonal God are some of them Theists, some Pantheists, but can by no means truly be designated Atheists.*}}
 
Lastly there are the so-called Atheists, who ''say'' they believe in no God, Personal or Impersonal, who affirm that the universe is an infinite aggregation of substance, in its undifferentiated condition, neither conscious nor intelligent, expanding and contracting by the inherent laws of its own being, and subject in accordance with these to alternate periods of day and night, activity and rest; who maintain that during such periods of activity in accordance still with these inherent laws, all things human and divine, differentiate out of, and are evolved from, this primal all-pervading substance, to disintigrate, once more, into it as the night of rest supervenes.
 
These ''call'' themselves Atheists; and if there ''be'' such, they probably have the best right to assume the title, but I confess that I doubt whether even these are really Atheists.
 
In the first place, when they talk of laws, they overlook, it seems to me, the fact that a law postulates a law-giver—a will at any rate that has impressed a course of action—and so it seems to me that, admitting an inherent law, they cannot logically escape a will that originated that law, and such a will in such a case ''must'' be what mankind understands as God.
 
But in the second place, though they deny this primary will, they do not really deny all Gods. For they say that in accordance with the inherent laws, develop, not only all we see and know, but incredibly and inconceivably higher spiritual beings, who guide and direct all things in the visible universe, and to whose power and love are due all the beauties and wonders of the world that so impress us with a sense of design.
 
So then though they may call these, Dhyan Chohans or Elohim, these exalted spiritual beings are really their Gods, and they are Polytheists rather than Atheists. Only it must be remembered that these, their Gods, are neither infinite nor absolute. They are finite; billions on billions of years as they subsist, they pass into non-''existence'' (but whether into non-''being'' or not the holders of these tenets are not agreed) with the close of the great day, and they are conditioned by the eternal inherent law of the infinite substance one of whose developments they are.
 
''Why'', they have preferred finite and conditioned Gods, to one Infinite and Absolute God, is clear. On the former hypothesis, the origin of evil, the ''existence'' of sin and suffering offer no difficulty; the Gods do their best; but there are laws of opposite polarity, of antagonistic opposites, to which the universe owes its origin, and with it they themselves, which are above them and which they are powerless to ''control'', although they can largely modify their results. They do their best; if there still remain misery and evil, it is because not being omnipotent, they cannot cure without medicine, cannot make light apparent without darkness.
 
Why, too, they deny the primal Will as giving with to the so-called inherent laws is also clear. So long as these are blind laws, self-existing, no one is responsible for all the sin and sorrow and suffering that these laws entail. But admit the Will, then this as (''exhypothese'') Omnipotent becomes responsible for all the evil that evolves from its behests, and could not therefore apparently be perfectly beneficent.* Whichever way we turn, then there are difficulties. No solution of the fundamental problem of the universe that in all these thousands of thousands years the mind of man has been able to evolve is altogether unimpeachable.
 
Let us then each take the solution that best suits our mental and spiritual constitution, and let us leave our neighbours an equal freedom of choice; let us never hesitate to state and defend our own views and oppose those other views that we think wrong, but let us do all this, as we would defend our own and oppose our opponent’s game at chess, with no more feeling against our opponents than we have against an adversary at that noble game.†
 
Above all let us remember that in this present life, the high theoretical questions of Personal, Impersonal, and No-God are of less concern to us than our own every-day life, about the right conduct of which no similar difficulties exist.
 
That we should all try to love our neighbours as ourselves, that we should forgive our enemies, that we should do good to those who do evil to us, that we should value purity of life, truth and goodness far above wealth or place or personal enjoyment,—these are truths admitted ''ubique, semper et ab omnibus'', and surely these furnish a wide enough platform on which we can all, whether Brahmins, Christians, Theosophists, Aryans {{Style S-HPB SB. Archivist note|1=or what not, <u>meet & labour in one universal Bro</u>therhood. H.X.<ref name="editor-hand-ending-146">The last words are handwritten on the mounted clipping, ending with the initials H.X. The writer has not been identified. The comparison printing in The Theosophist includes the word “loving”, which is not inserted here.<!-- HANDWRITING-ATTRIBUTION-RECHECK --></ref>}}
 
{{Style S-HPB SB. Archivist note|1=See Answer {{Style S-Lost|…}} Criticism by {{Style S-Lost|…}} “Aryan Student” {{Style S-Lost|…}} <u>Theosophist</u> <u>{{Style S-Lost|…}} 1883.</u><ref name="editor-blue-note-146">An oblique blue handwritten cross-reference follows the article. The writer has not been identified. Several words, including the month, remain unclear.<!-- HANDWRITING-ATTRIBUTION-RECHECK --></ref>}}
 
{{Footnotes start}}
<nowiki>*</nowiki> Precisely so if all believers in an Impersonal God were to admit this acceptation—{{Style S-Small capitals|Ed.}}
 
<nowiki>*</nowiki> Is not the doctrine of Transmigration of soul a solution of the problem?—{{Style S-Small capitals|Ed.}}
 
† Really to entertain ill feelings against one who disagrees with us is mischievous, and he who does so violates the doctrines of the Vedas—{{Style S-Small capitals|Ed.}}
{{Footnotes end}}


{{HPB-CW-separator}}
{{HPB-CW-separator}}
Line 16: Line 46:
  | page = 146
  | page = 146
  | item = 1
  | item = 1
  | type = fragment
  | type = other
  | status = wanted
  | status = ok
  | continues =
  | continues =
  | title = [Fragment on the worship of power]
  | title = is “splendid,” that which is not…
  | subtitle =
  | subtitle =
  | untitled = yes
  | untitled = yes
Line 25: Line 55:
  | author signed =
  | author signed =
  | source title = Arya, The (Lahore)
  | source title = Arya, The (Lahore)
  | source details = Inlay146.1,right,p.241; concluding fragment above next heading, earlier part/title not present; issue date absent
  | source details =
  | publication date =
  | publication date =
  | original date =
  | original date =
}}
}}


...
{{Style P-No indent|is “splendid,” that which is not, is “humbug!” Hence it is that the worship of Power by the weak is beyond the power of his conception. Nor has the Musalman understood it up to this time, perhaps he never will. Remembering once a year the dark side of his glorious history, he has only learnt the woe-stirring songs of the ''Muhurrum''. How can he form any conception of the nature of the electric currents which flow through the heart of the Bengali at the recollection of the distant past in this pitch-dark present? How can one, the chief event in whose national life is blank despair of grief, understand the overflowing of joy in another? No, to the Musalman this mystery is for ever a sealed book. But why to the Musalman alone? It is as well inscrutable to the speechifying young Bengal of the present day. His chief object in life is to review the straws and twigs that are being thrust aside from the surface of society by the rapid currents of a foreign flood—the mosses that are floating up. How would he understand the mystery of the powers that convulse the society to the bottom?}}
 
A Hindu, a worshipper, a devotee, yet he cannot appreciate the majesty of this national festival—the proud value of this Worship of Power! Were it otherwise we would not have been so miserable.
 
{{HPB-CW-separator}}


{{HPB-SB-item
{{HPB-SB-item
Line 37: Line 71:
  | item = 2
  | item = 2
  | type = letter
  | type = letter
  | status = wanted
  | status = ok
  | continues =
  | continues =
  | title = Is Idolatry Taught in the Yajur Veda?
  | title = Is Idolatry Taught in the Yajur Veda?
| hide = yes
  | subtitle =
  | subtitle =
  | untitled =
  | untitled =
Line 45: Line 80:
  | author signed = G., F.A.S.
  | author signed = G., F.A.S.
  | source title = Arya, The (Lahore)
  | source title = Arya, The (Lahore)
  | source details = To the Editor of the Arya,Lahore; begins146.1 right,p.241,completes146.2,p.242; same physical scrapbook leaf,no fake separate page URL; issue date absent
  | source details =
  | publication date =
  | publication date =
  | original date =
  | original date =
}}
}}


...
{{Style P-Title|IS IDOLATRY TAUGHT IN THE YAJUR VEDA?}}
 
{{Style P-Align center|{{Style S-Small capitals|By G., F.A.S.}}}}
 
{{Style P-Align center|''[To the Editor of the Arya, Lahore.]''}}
 
{{Style P-No indent|It seems to me that the ''Theosophist'' teaching now atheism and then favoring idolatry, struggles hard to defend its position and the position of the Fellows of the Theosophical Society, however indefensible their position may be, as will be seen from its comment upon my enquiry, published in the ''Arya'' for September 1882, where it says that “the correspondent of the ''Arya'' seems to have confounded the two questions about idolatry in the Vedas and in the Shastars.”}}
 
As far as I have thought over the question I believe that Mr. Mathra Das Lowji could not be so unwise and extravagant as to spend a good sum of 5,000 rupees to have idolatry proved from Shasters, which is another name for Smritis and Poorans, and which terribly conflict with one another, composed as they are by men whose opinions on religious matters widely differed from one another. Smritis and Poorans assert a thing in one place and contradict the same in another. But what Mr. Mathra Das Lowji appears really to have meant was idolatry in the Vedas.
 
In the first instance D., the correspondent of the ''Theosophist'', should not have headed “his difficulties to be set right upon” as “Is idolatry taught in the Yajur Veda? But as—Is idolatry taught in Shakha? But he could not help it, as he was in earnest to please idolators by quoting a few words in Sanskrit, and when asked where those words were to be found, he replied that they were from a Shakha (Lecture on the Vedas), but still he did not give the name or page of the Shakha where the extract was to be met.
 
D. presumes to say that “idolatry is supported by the Vedas, and is philosophical, wholesome and beneficial in several ways.” It is many years since various discussions upon the subject have taken place, but no Pandit in any part of India could ever prove that idolatry is sanctioned by the Vedas. D. is referred to the several pamphlets treating of the question in its full length. He should also have observed that as long as the English, the Romans and the Grecians were idolators, they could acquire no civilization and make no scientific and intellectual progress, but were savages and babarians. The same may be said as regards the Hindus. Unless they give up idolatry, they will never rise, or be civilized and improved in their social and intellectual condition, and will by no means acquire the wisdom of which the Aryas, the adorers of one God, were proud. Idolatry is a folly that blunts one’s mind and faculties, and never induces him to make onward and spiritual progress, but tends to contempt and scorn being thrown at the Hindus by Christians and Mohamedans. The number of the former would have been greatly diminished by their conversion to the latter religions had not the great Brahm Rishi, Swami Dayanand Sarswati, and the Arya Samaj, made every possible effort to diffuse the true philosophy of the Vedas. The evils arising from idolatry are too many to be told.
 
Since the four texts of the Vedas are an extraordinary authority, and Brahmans, Upanishads and Shakha an ordinary authority, as long as they do not conflict with the texts of the Vedas,—and D. himself acknowledges the fact of the phrase in question being a portion of Shakha but not the Yajur Veda, although we are not sure whether the phrase is or is not in the Shakha, as no names, chapter or page of it has been quoted by him,—it is evident that idolatry is not taught in the Yajur Veda, but it was a mere delusion in which the public cannot suffer to be thrown before the light of the Arya Samaj, and its Revelation, the Vedas.


{{Bookmark|146.1}}
{{Bookmark|146.1}}