Jump to content

HPB-SB-14-93: Difference between revisions

223 bytes removed ,  Tuesday at 18:42
Убраны несодержательные описания штрихов и полос
(Уточнение библиографии источников)
(Убраны несодержательные описания штрихов и полос)
 
Line 106: Line 106:
{{Style P-Align center|1='''Contributed by “{{Style S-Small capitals|M.A. (Oxon.)}}”'''}}
{{Style P-Align center|1='''Contributed by “{{Style S-Small capitals|M.A. (Oxon.)}}”'''}}
I have fallen on evil days, Madame Blavatsky, accompanied or attended by five chelas, has seen fit to devote no less than three columns of remonstrance and rebuke to me “from an altitude of over 8,000 feet above the sea-level.” I have been indiscreet enough to avow my belief that the Journal of Science, as compared with other journals and reviews of a like nature, is conspicuously fair in its treatment of Spiritualism and the Occult. I thought so in respect of its review of Mr. Sinnett’s book. It does not write from my point of view, and I should except to some of its remarks, but, after reading it again in deference to the rebuke of my critic and her “Chelas, who know their masters,” I am bound to say I think it contrasts honourably and strikingly with the treatment, let me say for example, that Madame Blavatsky met with in the pages of a prominent English Review. As to the chelas, if it be a wise son that knows its own father, no doubt it is a wise chela that knows its own master. But otherwise their wisdom is not apparent in what they write. For my friend, I beg to assure her that I have not consciously written a word that ought to cause her hurt. I am sure she claims and values liberty of thought for herself too much to deny it to me. I must be permitted to do my own thinking, and I regret to find that I cannot always, no doubt from inferior means of information, agree with her and others of my friends. That is all. She imports into my writings a spirit that does not animate them, when she reads in them any sort of personal animus. I will not even discuss the question: but to clear away possible misconception I may make a personal explanation. Since the Secretary of the Parent Society does not think it wrong to break the rules of secrecy which fence in the Theosophical Society, it cannot be wrong for me to say that I ceased to take any active part in the London Society some years since, and have during this year resigned my membership.
I have fallen on evil days, Madame Blavatsky, accompanied or attended by five chelas, has seen fit to devote no less than three columns of remonstrance and rebuke to me “from an altitude of over 8,000 feet above the sea-level.” I have been indiscreet enough to avow my belief that the Journal of Science, as compared with other journals and reviews of a like nature, is conspicuously fair in its treatment of Spiritualism and the Occult. I thought so in respect of its review of Mr. Sinnett’s book. It does not write from my point of view, and I should except to some of its remarks, but, after reading it again in deference to the rebuke of my critic and her “Chelas, who know their masters,” I am bound to say I think it contrasts honourably and strikingly with the treatment, let me say for example, that Madame Blavatsky met with in the pages of a prominent English Review. As to the chelas, if it be a wise son that knows its own father, no doubt it is a wise chela that knows its own master. But otherwise their wisdom is not apparent in what they write. For my friend, I beg to assure her that I have not consciously written a word that ought to cause her hurt. I am sure she claims and values liberty of thought for herself too much to deny it to me. I must be permitted to do my own thinking, and I regret to find that I cannot always, no doubt from inferior means of information, agree with her and others of my friends. That is all. She imports into my writings a spirit that does not animate them, when she reads in them any sort of personal animus. I will not even discuss the question: but to clear away possible misconception I may make a personal explanation. Since the Secretary of the Parent Society does not think it wrong to break the rules of secrecy which fence in the Theosophical Society, it cannot be wrong for me to say that I ceased to take any active part in the London Society some years since, and have during this year resigned my membership.
{{Style S-HPB SB. Archivist note|1=[Blue oblique strokes beside the heading and the end of this paragraph.]<ref name="editor-hand-14-93">The writer has not been identified. <!-- HANDWRITING-ATTRIBUTION-RECHECK --></ref>}}


The attention of educated Spiritualists is being increasingly directed from the mere surface phenomena, and the cut-and-dried explanations of them, to some systematic study of their inter-relations and of the causes which underlie them. One of the chief avenues of knowledge in this direction unquestionably is the relation of mind to mind, with the kindred subjects of transference of thought, or sympathetic impressions, and of the power of influencing certain sensitive and susceptible minds by power of will. Thought-reading attracts just now an amount of practical attention that bids fair to elucidate most of the superficial difficulties that surround it. Mesmerism* has, at all times, attracted students of the Occult; and from the study of it, intelligently made, much light will, I believe, be thrown on the obscure phenomena known as Spiritualistic. Some of these seem to be distinctly referable to the action of an invisible Intelligence using an unknown Force. Others are equally distinctly referable to the action of mind on mind, conceivably using the same Force, but requiring no importation of an external Spirit to explain the facts. What is the Force? Psychic Force is a name good enough. What is the Agent? In the former case, Unembodied Spirit; in the latter, the Human Will; aided or unaided, but at any rate energizing consciously.
The attention of educated Spiritualists is being increasingly directed from the mere surface phenomena, and the cut-and-dried explanations of them, to some systematic study of their inter-relations and of the causes which underlie them. One of the chief avenues of knowledge in this direction unquestionably is the relation of mind to mind, with the kindred subjects of transference of thought, or sympathetic impressions, and of the power of influencing certain sensitive and susceptible minds by power of will. Thought-reading attracts just now an amount of practical attention that bids fair to elucidate most of the superficial difficulties that surround it. Mesmerism* has, at all times, attracted students of the Occult; and from the study of it, intelligently made, much light will, I believe, be thrown on the obscure phenomena known as Spiritualistic. Some of these seem to be distinctly referable to the action of an invisible Intelligence using an unknown Force. Others are equally distinctly referable to the action of mind on mind, conceivably using the same Force, but requiring no importation of an external Spirit to explain the facts. What is the Force? Psychic Force is a name good enough. What is the Agent? In the former case, Unembodied Spirit; in the latter, the Human Will; aided or unaided, but at any rate energizing consciously.