Jump to content

Judge W.Q. - Questions and Answers: Difference between revisions

m
Add the February and March 1896 installments (vol. X, no. 11-12) and update the header
(New page: William Q. Judge's "Questions and Answers" (The Path, vol. X, no. 8-9, November-December 1895))
 
m (Add the February and March 1896 installments (vol. X, no. 11-12) and update the header)
 
Line 2: Line 2:
  | title = Questions and Answers
  | title = Questions and Answers
  | author = Judge, William Quan
  | author = Judge, William Quan
  | description = A recurring Q&A column. The November 1895 installment answers questions on whether the Maha Bodhi Society is a Theosophical body and on Buddhism's prospects in America, on the small true proportion of active Fellows among India's reported branches, and on self-discipline through suppressing the habit of self-assertion. The December 1895 installment answers questions on the exoteric/esoteric distinction in an earlier reply on Buddhism, on the identity of "Chew-Yew-Tsang" (Ernest T. Hargrove), on the propriety of the ''Path'''s remarks on members who bolted after the Boston Convention, on a psychic vision of a distant friend brought on by fatigue, and on the true, much smaller number of active branches in India.
  | description = A recurring Q&A column. The November 1895 installment answers questions on whether the Maha Bodhi Society is a Theosophical body and on Buddhism's prospects in America, on the small true proportion of active Fellows among India's reported branches, and on self-discipline through suppressing the habit of self-assertion. The December 1895 installment answers questions on the exoteric/esoteric distinction in an earlier reply on Buddhism, on the identity of "Chew-Yew-Tsang" (Ernest T. Hargrove), on the propriety of the ''Path'''s remarks on members who bolted after the Boston Convention, on a psychic vision of a distant friend brought on by fatigue, and on the true, much smaller number of active branches in India. The February 1896 installment answers questions on elementals, and on whether one must be conscious of having passed the obstacles tied to a certain date marking the withdrawal of Adept influence. The March 1896 installment answers questions on the happy medium between egoism and the development of inner selfhood, on Henry J. Newton's false claim to have been the Society's first president and that it was founded at his house, on the deeper karmic reasons for parentage beyond merely furnishing a body, on whether branch attendance benefits those unable to lecture or write, on the Society's emblem and other symbols, on the difference between condemned "mental science" healing and legitimate medical healing, and on whether Theosophists have been promised safety from the prophesied crisis.
  | work type = articles
  | work type = articles
  | publication date = November, December 1895
  | publication date = November, December 1895, February, March 1896
  | publication date sortable = 1895-11
  | publication date sortable = 1895-11
  | publication place = ''The Path''
  | publication place = ''The Path''
  | publications = [[Path/Vol10/Text|''The Path'', vol. X, no. 8]], November 1895, pp. 256-258; no. 9, December 1895, pp. 289-291
  | publications = [[Path/Vol10/Text|''The Path'', vol. X, no. 8]], November 1895, pp. 256-258; no. 9, December 1895, pp. 289-291; no. 11, February 1896, p. 353-354; no. 12, March 1896, pp. 385-388
  | read links = [[Path/Vol10/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]]
  | read links = [[Path/Vol10/Text|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]]
  | ctd rus = Джадж У.К. - Вопросы и ответы
  | ctd rus = Джадж У.К. - Вопросы и ответы
Line 81: Line 81:


{{Style P-Signature|W.Q.J.}}
{{Style P-Signature|W.Q.J.}}
{{Vertical space|2em}}
<hr>
{{Page aside in Path|v=10|n=11|p=353}}
{{Style P-Title small caps|level=3|1=Questions and Answers.}}
C.—I have heard some members talking about attracting elementals, and of this or that place being full of elementals. Not seeing these beings myself, and not knowing much about it, I would like to know if the phrases used are correct.
''Ans.''—It is quite probable that these persons never saw an elemental, and know still less, perhaps, than yourself of the subject and of the laws that may govern such entities. So do not be abashed by their assumption of knowledge. It is incorrect to talk of one place being more full of elementals than another place. We might as well say there is more of space in one spot of space than another. Elementals are everywhere, just as animalculæ fill the air; they obey the laws peculiar to themselves, and move in the currents of ether. If now and then they make themselves manifest, it does not hence follow that an additional number have been attracted to the spot, but only that conditions have altered so as to cause some disturbance.
{{Style P-Signature|W.Q.J.}}
T.C. and F.O.R.—In some formerly published articles something is said of a future date marking the withdrawal of certain portions of the influence of the Adepts, and that those who have not gotten past the obstacles before that will have to wait until next incarnation. Is it necessary that one should be aware of having passed sufficiently far; must one be conscious of it? If so, I, for one, am "not in it."
''Ans.''—It is not necessary to be conscious of the progress one has made. Nor is the date in any sense an extinguisher, as some have styled it. In these days we are too prone to wish to know {{Page aside in Path|v=10|n=11|p=354}}everything all at once, especially in relation to ourselves. It may be desirable and encouraging to be thus conscious, but it is not necessary. We make a good deal of progress in our inner, hidden life of which we are not at all conscious. We may not know of it until some later life. So in this case many may be quite beyond the obstacles and not be conscious of it. It is best to go on with duty, and to refrain from this trying to take stock and measuring of progress. All of our progress is in the inner nature, and not in the physical where lives the brain, and from which the present question comes. The apparent physical progress is evanescent. It is ended when the body dies, at which time, if the inner man has not been allowed to guide us, the natural record against us will be a cipher, or "failure." Now, as the great Adepts live in the plane of our inner nature, it must follow that they might be actively helping everyone of us after the date referred to, and we, as physical brain men, not be conscious of it on this plane.
{{Style P-Signature|W.Q.J.}}
{{Vertical space|2em}}
<hr>
{{Style P-Title small caps|level=3|1=Questions and Answers.}}
M.G.T.S.—Will you kindly advise me in question department, how to strike the happy medium between Egoism or Egotism and the development of inner selfhood?
''Ans.''—This question cannot be properly answered, because you have put an indefinite question. It is not clear what you mean by a happy medium between development and the Self or Ego. The happy medium is generally between two courses. If by Egotism you mean the personal lower self, then it is said by all sages that there is continual war between it and the Higher Self until one or the other is the victor. As also what you mean by "Inner Selfhood" is indefinite, no reply based on that term, that would be useful, could be made. But if you want to know how to make a compromise, so to say, between the lower self—for that is what I assume your terms Egoism and Egotism to mean—it can only be pointed out that there can be no such truce: if attempted it would merely mean that the lower self would remain master, and the Higher Self wait for a new and better resolution. This is the state of most people, ever compromising, always allowing the lower self to have the upper hand, forever waiting for some later day when they intend to give the Higher the reins of government,—but that day will never come under such a course.
{{Page aside in Path|v=10|n=12|p=386}}D.—The recent death of Henry J. Newton following close on letters he sent the newspapers about the T.S. arouses the question, Was he ever president of it, and what is there in the assertion he made that the Society was founded at his house?
''Ans.''—He was its early treasurer, but never president. Like the many other spiritualists who joined and resigned quite soon, he departed also. The Society was not founded at his house. He published lately a facsimile of a pledge of secrecy in the Society signed by Mme. Blavatsky, Olcott and others, asserting this to be the beginning. This is a mistake of an old man with a bad memory. The pledge was a special one prepared in anticipation of promised wonderful revelations by a false pretender, and as the whole thing fell through, those papers were left with Newton because nobody cared for them. At the time, H.P.B. said to me that no revelations of any consequence would be made by the person, who was imposing on our spiritualistic members. Among other papers Mr. Newton had the roll, of course, because he was treasurer and used it for sending bills for dues. These documents he kept and refused to give them up to the Society. But the original minutes of organization, and other meetings, are in possession of loyal members in New York, and contradict Mr. Newton's assertion.
J.H.M.—On page 234 of the November issue it is stated that parentage is not merely for bringing an Ego into this life, but for wider and greater reasons. Please say what some of these reasons are.
''Ans.''—If it is held that parentage is only and solely for the purpose of furnishing a body for an Ego, then responsibility of parent to child is at an end, and the child also is relieved of all obligations and responsibilities to the parents. This view is held by some, and, sad to say, by some of those F.T.S. who follow mechanical Theosophy. To my mind it is a monstrous proposition. It would also negative the doctrine of Karma and destroy the vast and wonderful continuity of things and forces relating to the human being. The child has far-reaching karmic relations with the parents, as they also with the child. The discipline and joys that come through children are karmic on both sides. If the child is a wicked one, it is the Karma of the parents also. Again, the incoming Ego requires a certain line of family so as to get the needed sort of body. In many and various ways, then, parentage can be seen to be more than a mere door to this plane.
B.R.C.—I am unable to lecture; I cannot write good papers, and I do not seem to learn much at branch meetings. Is it any use for me to attend them?
''Ans.''—It must largely depend on your motive for attendance {{Page aside in Path|v=10|n=12|p=387}}and on your actual interest. Do you go to learn or to help? If you go to learn, it is written by H.P.B. that half a dozen people meeting regularly and working harmoniously can learn more in six months than a solitary student can in two years. If you go there to help, the answer is different. If you believe in the power of thought, any experienced lecturer will tell you what an immense help it is to have even one intelligent and sympathetic listener; you not only give him ideas but you help also the enquirers present, by your sympathetic thought, to understand what is said. Wherever you are, you are a centre of force, and it is your own fault if you are useless anywhere.
E. E. Knight.—Please inform me where I can find out about the meaning of the Society's emblem, and also about the many other signs and hieroglyphs found in our books.
''Ans.''—In the first volume of ''The Path'' (May, 1886, p. 51) you will find an article on the subject of Theosophical symbolism. But in order to find out all you want it will be necessary to wade through many books, because the subject is so large and difficult. In H.P.B.'s ''Secret Doctrine'' there is a great deal about symbols, and that is one of the best places to look. Your questions cover so many departments of symbolism that they could not be answered here, as proper treatment would mean the writing of a book.
{{Style P-Signature|W.Q.J.}}
R. A. French.—I have heard Theosophists condemn healing, and speak as though it were a crime. If it is true that disease is not to be healed, that physicians are hindering instead of helping the race, I should like to know.
''Ans.''—One invariable rule should be applied in regard to every statement made about "Theosophical teachings." Is this in accord with reason; with known facts? If not, reject it as contrary to real Theosophical teaching. This does not place reason as superior to intuition, but if a statement is made on some Theosophical subject which appears to you unreasonable, then it follows that either the statement is wrong or your understanding is wrong—and in neither case can it be true for you.
Healing is not condemned by Theosophists. It is much sought after by many of them. If your body is diseased you should go to the best physician of your acquaintance and follow his directions. Physicians who actually cure or alleviate disease are helping, not hindering, the evolution of the race. The questioner has perhaps heard a process of healing condemned, known as that of "mental science." That is condemned by some, because of its dangers and the general folly resulting from its practice. It {{Page aside in Path|v=10|n=12|p=388}}undertakes to heal diseases without drugs and without proper physicians. The mind only is used. Disaster results. But that is another matter, and as I have said, healing by proper and legitimate means is highly approved of by all true Theosophists.
{{Style P-Signature|H.}}
R. A. French.—In talking with a Theosophist recently on the great crisis impending, he expressed the belief that all Theosophists would be brought through unharmed for the work of reconstruction. Has any such thing been promised?
''Ans.''—The "Theosophist" in question should read the February "Screen of Time" and the remarks contained therein on those who dote upon "lugubrious prophecies." And he thinks he will be saved "for the work of reconstruction?" Some people would say that he should be the first man demolished. But as regards the question: no such promise has been made, will or could be made. Very erroneous ideas seem to be entertained on the subject of this oft-quoted crisis. Some of the early Christians misinterpreted a prophecy said to have been made by Jesus and expected the end of the world a few years after the death of their teacher. They were disappointed that it did not come. There is no need to imitate such an example and less excuse for doing so. When the crisis comes there will be time enough to study it. When the time for reconstruction comes our "Theosophist" will have his chance of being reconstructed with the rest of Nature—if he is not by then demolished. But to expect a karmic dispensation from all harm in some prophesied crisis, merely because he writes F.T.S. after his name, is a baseless and inexcusable superstition.
{{Style P-Signature|H.}}