Jump to content

HPB-SB-4-17: Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
No edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 52: Line 52:
<center>''To the Editor of the “Spiritual Magazine.”''</center>
<center>''To the Editor of the “Spiritual Magazine.”''</center>


{{Style S-Small capitals|Dear Doctor}},–It is but just now that I have seen in the ''Spiritual Magazine'' (p. 71) a letter from Mr. Home, in which I find the following passage:-
{{Style S-Small capitals|Dear Doctor}},–It is but just now that I have seen in the ''Spiritual Magazine'' (p. 71) a letter from Mr. Home, in which I find the following passage:


“When put to the test, all these rope-tyings are failures. You are aware that my cousin, Mr. Aksakof, has tried it in Russia, and a dead failure has been the result, as I knew it would be.”
“When put to the test, all these rope-tyings are failures. You are aware that my cousin, Mr. Aksakof, has tried it in Russia, and a dead failure has been the result, as I knew it would be.”
Line 58: Line 58:
There is here a grave error. Of what does Mr. Home speak? If he speaks of our experience with Bredif, the rope-tyings were put to the test, and it was not a failure (see the article of Professor Boublerof, in the ''Psy. Studien'' of 1875). If he speaks of our ''seances ''with the Pettys at the Committee, it was a failure; but there was no rope-tying, because the Pettys were seated before the screen, and without being in any way secured.
There is here a grave error. Of what does Mr. Home speak? If he speaks of our experience with Bredif, the rope-tyings were put to the test, and it was not a failure (see the article of Professor Boublerof, in the ''Psy. Studien'' of 1875). If he speaks of our ''seances ''with the Pettys at the Committee, it was a failure; but there was no rope-tying, because the Pettys were seated before the screen, and without being in any way secured.


There is still another passage in this letter which strikes me :
There is still another passage in this letter which strikes me :


“ A book was published lately in America, and pages were devoted to a person who had power over the spirits !  When one knows what the life of this person has been, it is simply monstrous that such ''assertions ''should be made.”
“ A book was published lately in America, and pages were devoted to a person who had power over the spirits !  When one knows what the life of this person has been, it is simply monstrous that such ''assertions ''should be made.”