!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(July 1892)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. VII, no. 4, July 1892, pp. 109-115
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Карр, Томас Э. - Сферы неодушевлённых предметов
DATA
Title for references: Karr TE - The Spheres of Inanimate Objects
Short description: Reports a series of carefully controlled psychometry experiments testing whether inanimate objects c...
109 A moot point with investigators of psychic laws has long been, whether inorganic substances carry an individual sphere of their own or not.
Occultism lays down an axiom that "As is the great so is the small; as above so below"; but to the healthy modern mind occultism is no more an indisputably sacred precinct than the ground covered by other "isms", and in order to hold fast to a thing as good, it must first be proven in strict accordance with many times tested fact, pointing to an undeviating law. The motto of the Theosophical Society, There is no religion higher than truth, might be modified advantageously to an ampler expansion of idea in the further postulate There is no truth save law, or higher than law, for "Conscious Law is King of kings," and what goes towards the discovery of a hidden law is the patient accumulation of painstaking observation, till certainty is rooted and grounded on repeated demonstration. If the demonstrated fact vindicates occultism, well and good; if it fails so to do, let us keep our minds hospitably open towards fresh fields of inquiry, and cease speaking with bated breath and with dogmatic insistance of an occultism which is not up to par with the demands of present-day methods and provings.
Until within a very few years past no systematic exploration of psychic phenomena has been attempted. The literature of psychometry, clairvoyance, and the like, though bristling with marvels and tales of wonder that one reads with the avidity of a child for fairy lore, is too marred by loose statement and inaccurate observation to be of any evidential worth, either from the legal or the scientific viewpoint. The narrators, all aglow under the stimulus of a new experience, seem cut loose, so to say, from their fly-wheel of cool sense and balanced judgment, which, like the equivalent in a mechanical construction, is the controlling and equilibrating force; and with their machine thus out of kelter, they recount ad nauseam utterly trivial details, while some crucial point on which the whole story hinges is left in the dim obscurity of the unrecorded. This constitutes a maddening bafflement of only too frequent recurrence in all systematic endeavor to tread the tangled maze that guards the entrance to the unknown. The few observations here presented are free at least from any rosy tinge of exalted fancy, which, sad to say, will not improbably rob them of all value with the many who care far more for a nursery fiction than for the sober-suited, strait-laced narrative of scientific fact.110
The aim of a certain group of persons with minds wholly free from all preconceptions for or against any particular theory, and intent only on a search for facts, was to determine if possible by careful experiment whether inanimate objects were indeed, or not, suffused with an intrinsic or an extrinsic aura; or, in other words, whether they are impregnated with an influence emanating from within and peculiar to their kind, or merely penetrated with the borrowed sphere of such persons or places as they have chanced to be brought into close contact with. After repeated experiments with different individuals extending over quite a period of time, the latter hypothesis seemed to have become reasonably demonstrated, as presently to be seen in the experiments related in all their details, which will be now submitted to the reader's judgment for decision.
To test how much thought-transference may have to do with all psychometric reading, on one occasion a piece of mosaic pavement from the Palace of the Cæsars was given to a fairly good trance clairvoyant, the person who handed the fragment knowing what it was and whence derived. Thereupon followed a minute description of the past and present appearance of the historic site represented by this scrap of scagliola. To change the spirit of her dream, the clairvoyant was next offered by the same individual a small trinket never yet worn, fresh from the jeweller's case, which educed nothing from the psychometer's mind or vision beyond the commonplace statements that would naturally be suggested by such an object. A further trial was then made — the same individual as agent — with an article that had been long and recently worn by a person unknown to both agent and percipient, when surprising results were obtained, the appearance, characteristics, incidents of life, etc. relating to the owner being minutely and correctly stated. At another time a bit of a column of the Palace of the Cæsars was offered the clairvoyant in trance by an ignorant, but decidedly mediumistic, servant girl, when an amusing contrast was afforded in the frequent false starts and vain gropings after something definite, to the luminous description previously given of that famous locality. Mixed with these feeble attempts at decipherment, wherein no trace could be detected of any recognition by the percipient of the object as identical in association with that of the former trial, was a droll inclination to sense the recent surroundings of the stone, and by this process some correct personal hits were made regarding the individuals who had just before been handling it. The same agent next offered the clairvoyant an ornament saturated with the magnetism of the wearer, who was 111unknown to both alike, and, as on the previous occasion, there flowed forth a stream of accurate description and close analysis that proved the object alive and palpitating with the sphere of its owner.
The following instance, under very stringent conditions, happened with the writer as agent some six months ago, the clairvoyant being a very remarkable one, not, however, accessible to the general public as such. An appointment made through a third person was promptly kept in the early morning of a fresh brisk day, which afforded the very ideal of atmospheric conditions to which all sensitives are so keenly alive. The previous afternoon had been spent in much perplexity as to the ways and means of procuring some desirable objects for trial, it being of the first importance that these should be entirely unknown as to their history, ownership, and associations to the agent, in order that anything approaching thought-transference might be rigorously avoided. Chance favored the experimenter, however, beyond prayer or expectation. Hardly had he trod the length of a city block before he ran amuck with the man of all others in town who could best, and would most willingly, help him in the dilemma. The situation explained, and the pressing want disclosed, this friend, indeed in need, forthwith clapped a triumphant palm on a submissive shoulder and said: "I have the very thing. Mr. —'s office is close by. You do not know him even by hearsay. I will ask him for the loan of some trifle for the purpose required, and tell him to give it me without saying what it is, so that all possibility of conscious thought-transference will be obviated." No sooner said than done, whilst I cooled my heels on the pavement for the space of five minutes, when my friend returned with a little paper packet which he handed me, saying that he knew nothing whatever of its contents. On the evening of the same day a further stroke of luck befell, in the consignment to me of two articles from a person who carefully avoided telling me what they were or to whom they belonged. Needless to say that all three objects were touched as little as possible by me, in order to guard against any chance interfusion of currents, they being left in their boxes and wrappers unexamined, and only drawn from these when in the darkened room at the clairvoyant's house on the following morning.
A friend accompanied me to take verbatim notes, for there was to be no trusting to deceptive memory, elate with a possible partial success, reading retrospective details into a scant revelation, — the bare, bald notes, as dry as the usual short-hand writer's report, offering but little scope for a free fancy to play upon.112
The clairvoyant was soon in self-induced and deep trance, when the object lent by the gentleman above mentioned was taken from its wrapper and handed to her. She held it on her forehead awhile, then with a rapid movement carried it to the top of her head, and as long as it was held in this position the vision of all the owner's life seemed crystal clear, as it passed in dissolving views before her inner sight. The object was a small locket, detached on the moment of request from the wearer's watch-chain, and with this one clue the man's whole life, relations (these often called by name and minutely described), personal appearance, habits, characteristics, mental powers, state of fortune, associations, half-forgotten incidents of travel, etc. revealed themselves in startling array, all of which, when subsequently submitted to him, was checked and verified down to the slightest allusions. What particularly pleased him was the correct rendering of his two Christian names, as also of the names of many of his kith and kin, both living and dead; while a curious feature of an attempt to get his surname (known to me from having once heard it on the previous afternoon) was that only two letters of it were hesitatingly given, though the Christian names, wholly unknown to me, were instantly and with conviction pronounced.
The other articles were then taken from their box. The first, an old-time finger ring with emeralds in a deep gold setting, produced a most painful effect upon the clairvoyant, so distressing, indeed, that she moaned and writhed, while in broken phrases she gave utterance to the scenes it called up before her. These were of a very peculiar and unpleasant nature, involving a breach of money trust and an anguished, dying creature, all implicitly true, and known only to the owner of the object, who from natural feelings of delicacy had never mentioned the actual circumstances outside her own family, until called upon to verify the statement presented in the notes.
The third article was an old-fashioned gold-dial watch, which carried the clairvoyant instantly across the sea to Italy, where it had been bought and worn many years by its original possessor, from whom it had passed to a sister whose eldest child was often indulged with it as a plaything. The history of this child was very curious as disjointedly related by the clairvoyant, and at first it appeared as though she were romancing wide of the mark, but subsequent verification proved her to have seen truly. The child, it seems, had been a very precocious one till the age of three, when by some mischance it was left behind in the alarm and hurry of flight from a burning house, whence rescue came too late 113for anything save bare life, for it never spoke an intelligible word thereafter, and rapidly sank into utter idiocy, which pitiable state has lasted for years, though now the subject is an old woman, not even resident in this country, and the circle of friends about the sister who now wears the watch were ignorant of the sad tale, beyond the mere fact of a crazy relative across the sea. It was with difficulty, requiring time, tact, and patience, that all these details were substantiated, for the sister, horrified at this extent of knowledge of one's personal and private affairs attainable by a process she was disposed to discredit, yielded up the facts reluctantly and only on promise of absolute secrecy as to names, localities, and other means of identification.
What promised to be a rare opportunity for experiment presented itself midwinter this year, when a curious antique fell in my way, whose origin and ownership were but partially known to me. I soon made myself its possessor, and it goes without the saying, that a pamphlet that went with the purchase, descriptive of the discovery of the article, was instantly consigned to a dark drawer until, with the enthusiast's ardor for investigation, it should be needed in corroboration of the clairvoyant's statements. The same very remarkably gifted woman was chosen as percipient, but the agent this time was another than myself, one skilled by long practice in these experiments, and who knew absolutely nothing concerning the object in question, this arrangement making all explanation by thought-transference utterly idle. The result, however, was nil, the clairvoyant declaring that all influence from the article had vanished, and beyond some assertions that could readily have been surmised for facts by any intelligent by-stander, nothing was obtained. No better object for a test could have been desired than the one chosen, for, had the result been successful, irrefragable proof would have been secured of the presence of an intrinsic sphere in an inorganic substance, the article — a relic of a pre-historic race — having been discovered in some excavations undertaken in the province of Chiriqui, Panama. It is a lump of heavy yellow gold about an inch long, rudely shaped in the semblance of what antiquaries pronounce to be a sacred ram, but which to the lay mind has rather more the similitude of a stag, of somewhat mythical and conventional type.
This failure, taken in conjunction with the similar one with the fragment of a column from the Palace of the Cæsars, would seem to afford convincing evidence that material objects do not hold their individual spheres, but merely reflect the spheres of such organic structures whose aura they, so to say, imbibe by intimate 114and prolonged proximity. For instance, it would thus appear that an object might be for years in one's immediate surroundings, looked at constantly, often casually touched, thought about very much perhaps, yet to the inner vision of a natural seer it will reveal no item of its owner's life, habits, or associations; nor will it even reflect by some subtle inherent influence its own place of origin or later surroundings, etc., save as these are known or surmised by the agent, who unconsciously by thought-transference projects his ideas, correct or not, concerning it to the percipient's sensitive organs. But the moment we have an object worn about the person, the conditions are absolutely altered, as we have seen. The thing then becomes vital with a borrowed life, and mirrors the whole of an individual existence down to the minutest details.
To have made the last-mentioned experiment perfect, a second trial should have taken place with the little curio. This will be done at some future time if the same percipient will accord another interview, but with another agent cognizant of the history of the object so far as known, when it will be a singular result if, as in the case with the fragment of pavement from the Roman palace, a perfectly reconstructed building in its appropriate environment as imagined by the agent shall be reflected on the percipient's inner vision, and described as an actual scene of the past.
All these trials, repeated over and again, under various conditions, with different persons as agents and percipients, are necessarily extremely slow of accomplishment, and, whatever the result reached, it is recognized as merely an approximation towards an understanding of the mysterious law we are in pursuit of, that underlies all psychic phenomena. It is the part only of crass ignorance, that on the one hand denies the existence of all psychic power, and on the other that of blind bigotry or impertinent pretension that dares to be dogmatically sure of any, the least thing, in this dark region. So much is this the case among the latter class, it may be accepted for an unfailing rule that whoever speaks with positive assertion regarding the laws of these phenomena 115may be known for one who has had no practical acquaintance therewith, but who none the less gives an unchecked rein to a bounding credulity that requires no proofs, and is hotly resentful of all searching analysis and impartial scrutiny concerning their occurrence and alleged cause. It therefore behooves the psychic investigator, beyond all others, to move cautiously, to experiment untiringly, to accept nothing unproved — or that has not been time and again proved, — to require the most rigid accuracy of observation and of statement, and then, even when rewarded by a limited success that points to some definite conclusion, to remain humbly aware of the little he knows compared with the vast stretches of mystery that lure him ever onward into the dim unknown.
Thomas E. Karr.
Footnotes