Wright CF - Reason and Religion

From Teopedia
Revision as of 06:27, 16 November 2026 by 24pmBot1 (addition | contribs) (New page: Claude Falls Wright's "Reason and Religion" (The Path, vol. VIII, June 1893))
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!

Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Reason and Religion

Claude Falls Wright

(English)

(June 1893)

Warns against two excesses of unchecked "intuition" seen abroad in the Theosophical movement — the denial that evil exists, and unquestioning trust in psychic and clairvoyant claims — arguing that reason (Manas, the discriminating faculty) must check and refine intuition, lest Theosophy fall back into the dogmatism and superstition it was meant to overcome.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Райт, Клод Фоллс - Разум и религия

DATA

Title for references: Wright CF - Reason and Religion
Short description: Warns against two excesses of unchecked "intuition" seen abroad in the Theosophical movement — the d...

Claude Falls Wright

Reason and Religion

Substance of Address at Seventh Annual Convention, New York.

73It has been observed by many persons who are students of nature and observers of the progress of mankind, that all thought seems to pass in waves, or cycles, across the Earth. An idea which awakes in Manchester is to be found in Bombay and San Francisco at almost the same time. So it is that we say, Ideas float in the air. In a lesser degree, but perhaps even more strikingly, the same thing holds in great movements. What Theosophist has not observed the way in which ideas run their cycle in the Theosophical Society?

We had throughout the whole world some time ago an idea that every body was becoming dogmatic; as undoubtedly everybody was. Dogmatism as a whole was promptly crushed by great 74movements against it, particularly, I think, by the Theosophical Society. Then commenced a cycle of materialistic thought, which has likewise been oppressed by thinkers in every land. Now there is a phase of thought sweeping over the Earth which, if carried to excess, as it certainly is going to be, will land us, as we have been landed before, in error, in ignorance, finally occasioning the loss of proper notions concerning human and real thought. It is this: Religion, or the religious idea, has begun to be adopted, to be thought of, to be felt, to be experienced by men, without their use of their faculty of Reason. In two of the cities that I have visited, I have been interrupted in my work by the appearance on the scene of persons who have misrepresented Theosophy. As lovers of justice we should perhaps militate against such misrepresentation, but in this instance the falsity of the ideas brought forward as "Theosophical" deserves even far greater condemnation than even the fact of the misrepresentation itself. These people affirm that knowledge is obtained in some way other than by good honest work and endeavor; by a species of spiritual insight that they are the happy possessors of. It is a new "Salvation by Faith". They say that they know things, that they have "intuitions", that they have experiences about which they will not permit any reasoning because they know. And as a result of this, we have persons all around us and in every city who have often not an inconsiderable number of followers of all kinds, whom they lead most certainly astray because they destroy their individuality and will not permit their reasoning faculties to have any play. This is a fact. It is a most serious thing and deserves our prompt consideration, that we may affirm it not to be a principle of Theosophy.

I have spoken of "Intuition". I have used the word Religion in the title of my address simply because I can find no other word which so satisfactorily combines (a) the idea of dogmatism; (b) creed; (c) intuitions of all kinds. As I use the word in the broadest possible sense, I do not want you to tie your minds too closely by it.

As I said, I shall shorten my speech: so I am only going to refer to two conditions of men in order to give you the drift of my ideas. First of all I shall refer to that type of individual, whose name I will not mention, that is to be found in all your cities, and who will tell you that there is no such thing as "evil"; that all things are good. He, or she, knows this by the religious faculty; by the intuition. There can be no mistake about it. I have read books which tell you that there are no such things as earth-75quakes, no such things as plagues, diseases, fires, wars, or anything which is dangerous or devilish or cruel; that all things are good; there is no evil. Works of 36 to 39 pages, books, brochures, pamphlets, tracts of all kinds, dilating upon this fact in Nature, as it has been called. Surely this must come of insanity, not of intuition! There are such things as earthquakes, plagues, diseases. To say that there are not is to speak falsely, nothing less. And if such persons had any metaphysical ability, or understood anything of logic, they would know also that if they get rid of "evil" in nature, they must also leave "good" out of account, since these are but relative and mutually exclusive terms. Others, wiser in their generation, will tell you that they say these things are not, because if mankind holds the idea long enough, if we constantly assure ourselves that there are no such things as plagues or diseases, we shall eventually rid ourselves of them. That may be a fact; I do not say it is not so. I am not here to consider one side or the other. What I desire to point out is that the mere statement that these do not exist is a falsehood, no matter what it may lead to.

The truth is that the reason of such persons does not come to the aid of their intuitions. Their intuitions tell them that something is wanting in man's life, but they are too lazy to reason it out. They want to have good and to avoid evil; but it is certainly wrong to say that there is no such thing as evil. Avoid it by all means, but do not say it does not exist; otherwise we shall in time lose the discriminating faculty, which is the principal inheritance of man. If Theosophy has any work to do, it has to fight against this. There must be some way of avoiding "evil" other than saying that it does not exist.

The second condition is that of those persons who call themselves psychics, seers, "mediums"; they see clairvoyantly. You are asked to believe that every vision they have, everything they see or say, is true, or they won't associate with you. This is really serious. I have often tried to reason with their followers, and to show that because a clairvoyant has a vision or an impression that happens to turn out correct, it does not follow that all or any succeeding visions or impressions will so turn out. Suppose I see clairvoyantly that my brother is sitting in such and such a room at such and such a time, and I find that my vision has been correct, I say that that does not in the least warrant the assumption that all my possible visions thereafter shall be true ones, or even that I shall ever be correct again, unless the psychic sense is trained, as it is in the East. People have begun to awaken a new 76sense, to see something in nature that they never saw before, and this sense, because untrained, is just as likely to be wrong as right in its perceptions at first. The child sees the moon and cries for it. It thinks the moon quite close to it. That is because the sense of sight is untrained. And those persons who see faces in the Astral Light may be quite as much astray as the child; even more so, because the faculty of astral perception is not yet normal in men, while the physical sense of sight is. And the child will in time come to use the sense of sight properly because he reflects on, or reasons concerning, his perceptions. The psychic will never use his finer senses properly unless he does the same, and brings reflection to aid perception, no matter of what kind. So that if you, or any Theosophists, have such visions, you have to be very careful to use your reason to check your intuition, to analyze, to compare with past perceptions, to make sure that you are correct, and thus train that sense by separating falsehood from error. It is by this checking and comparing process that the chelas in the East are taught. With those psychics who do not reason or reflect it would be far better that they had never been right in their astral perceptions, for, once so, they rush into the belief that they must always be so, which does not follow.

The truth is that each man has a certain perception of nature according to his incarnation. He has also a mind to analyze his perceptions, both those concerning external objects and those concerning his own higher nature. Without the use of the faculty of reason he is certain to fall into error. Manas, the thinker, is the principle which is peculiar to man. It is the analyser, and is the only thing in nature which has this faculty of discrimination of good and evil, and it should be heeded, not shunned. Any man who thinks can analyse his perceptions, as likewise himself. To take a thing for a fact simply because you have an intuition that it is so, or to rest solely upon what you call your emotions, is simply to wreck the whole possibility of your progress: to take a thing for a fact simply because you have seen it in the Astral Light is to do the same thing. And in addition to our having religion we should constantly analyze and think over the things that we have been taught and that our intuitions tell us are correct, to see if they are in accordance with reason and correct principle as well. For we may have deep intuitions, but translate them wrongly. Had this always been done, we should never have had dogmatism in religion, for things should only have been adopted as truths when, in addition to their being founded on "internal evidence", they appealed also to the understanding.

77After all, no matter what we say, each man lives by himself entirely. I am alone, utterly so, and have been so ever since I was born and up to the present time: I suppose I will be so always, or until I have solved the riddle of existence. When I think deeply about life I see that the purpose of my existence is solely to solve that very riddle; to discover what it is that has produced the great panorama of life around me; to discover what my friends are, what I am myself; to know God. So perhaps I shall unveil the mystery in the course of time. But whatever results I obtain will be results based upon reflection or meditation combined with perception, not upon perception alone. True perception or intuition comes only of the contemplation of the soul in nature by the raising of the self higher and higher until it acts in unison with something that is true to its own nature, with a great centre in life; but it cannot so act until it has achieved a separation from things evil or foreign to itself. And we say: Use your intuitions by all means; go as far as you can, for they alone will lead you anywhere; but be sure that you are pure if you would avoid error, and the only way you shall get them pure is by utilizing the analyzing faculties to remove the dross of things which appear to us good and true simply because we have been associated with them so long that we are in a measure hypnotised by them.

All men have many selves. The external is a selfish personality; within there are other selves that act from mixed motives; only deep within us, and often hidden entirely by our other selves, is to be found our true and pure nature, the unselfish self. People constantly do things which they fancy are done from unselfish motive. If they analyzed themselves they would discover that something stands behind them on almost every occasion which makes them act principally with a selfish purpose in view. Men fear to analyze their motives or perceptions, to find out if there is evil in them; they prefer to say—"all is good". I say people who do that are simply disobeying the highest law of nature, which aims at making of man a sage and afterwards a god. An old saying is that there is John as his friends know him, John as he knows himself, and John as God knows him; meaning thereby there is the individual who appears to men evil or good, misjudged always; the individual who lives alone, saturated with selfish motives; and the high, calm, true, theosophical self who waits and stands behind, and with which we aspire to unite ourselves. Let us be honest in this endeavor! Let us fairly try to set ourselves free from those things which affect us from the out-78side, and to which we are chained by the links of selfishness and vanity, which bind the soul! So rare is it for us to perform a truly divine and unselfish act that when one does so, one who has analyzed his every motive, and has absolutely assured himself of his unselfishness—he will be surprised with himself; because he has discovered that mankind is not altogether evil and that every inmate or inhabitant of all the countries is not altogether hollow. When once we find ourselves performing an act out of a purely unselfish motive, our tendency is almost to cry over it for pleasure. For we are nearer to divinity than we ever were before. And such acts are only to be performed after careful analysis of ourselves, so that we may right our motive and clear away those things which separate us from our truest Self.

Many say: We can grow. Yes we can, but we may not force growth. Growth is a law of nature. It is natural and is not to be acquired. But the conditions are not always present. What we have to do is to produce the conditions of growth, to clear away the rocks and to plow the field; and growth is then certain, for it is natural. Our endeavor must be to get rid of error and superstition: we can only do this by using our analyzing or sifting faculty, by reasoning or reflecting, by discrimination of good and evil.

One object of the Theosophical Society is to raise great philosophers, who are true, who are strong of nature, who have their forces under control, who are in no way to be called foolish or childlike, innocent, or too good to live; men who understand other men and the world; above all, men who understand themselves. Sages who, while they have deep and pure intuitions, at the same time have their mental faculties well developed. Some will say that such would be materialistic; since they would not be guided wholly by their so-called intuitions. Not so, if their reflections and reasonings and meditations are concerning their highest internal perceptions and nature as a whole, and not merely with regard to the few objects they see around them. This is the basis of all true metaphysic. To rely on "intuitions" of any kind without reflecting upon them or reasoning about them will lead humanity once again into those paths it has struggled so hard to get away from—the paths of error, superstition, and fanaticism. Cultivate by all means the higher side of your nature! Educate the finer, religious character, the faculties which you venerate and contemplate and adore! Listen to the voice of the Spirit! But while you thus aspire, while you raise the soul and endeavor to be true to your conscience, do not fail to employ also your understanding. Keep your religion, but do not neglect your reason!