Observer - General Pertinent Observations

From Teopedia
Revision as of 00:45, 18 November 2026 by 24pmBot1 (addition | contribs) (Add the January 1896 installment, signed "Two Observers")
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Books • Articles • Stories • Letters • All works
⇐ • ⇒
Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

General Pertinent Observations

William Quan Judge

(December 1895, January 1896)

On why American newspapers' silence on Theosophical doings in the great cities is no cause for complaint, on the comparative freedom and encouragement American Theosophists enjoy over their European brothers, on the Roman Catholic policy of killing Theosophy by ignoring it, on the folly of proposing to hypnotize crime out of criminals, and against the formation of Theosophical retreats or monastic "centres" at this stage of the Society's work. The second installment corrects a proof-reading error in the first ("presentation" for "persecution"), comments on the Christian Endeavorers' prayer test aimed at converting Colonel Robert Ingersoll and on prayer for rain as a form of condemned sorcery, counsels patience and a thorough grounding in Theosophy rather than oratory for members forming new branches, objects strenuously to hiring ex-ministers or other outsiders to preach Theosophy, and criticizes aspirants who want to attach themselves to T.S. headquarters without fitness or willingness to do drudgery.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Наблюдатель - Общие уместные замечания

DATA

Title for references: Observer - General Pertinent Observations
Short description: On why American newspapers' silence on Theosophical doings in the great cities is no cause for compl...

William Quan Judge

General Pertinent Observations

First installment signed "The Observer"; the second (January 1896) signed "Two Observers." Neither pseudonym has been identified.

286

General Pertinent Observations.

Quite a number of Theosophists—I mean members of the Society—have been talking to me of what a shame it is that the great daily newspapers give so much space to such events as a prize fight or the marriage of an American millionaire's daughter to an English duke, and will not put in matter about Theosophy. It is quite true that our doings do not occupy much space in the papers, but what are they for? They 287were not established for our propaganda and we should be satisfied with what they do give us. But it has been found that in outlying states and places, where there is not so much going on, the newspapers are willing to give a great deal of attention to us. I understand that the whole of the Ocean of Theosophy appeared in a newspaper of Fort Wayne, Indiana, before it was published in book-form. The great papers of the principal cities cannot afford to do this because their mass of readers is enormous and varied. The intelligent Theosophist will at once see that it would be hopeless to expect thousands of people who do not care for Theosophy to be daily interested in accounts of it. Then the city newspaper represents the selfish, hurried, superficial, money-grabbing majority, just as much as it does the others in minority. And if we just think for a moment—those of us who have kept up with our history—of the great difference between now and 1875 as to our treatment by newspapers, we must in fact be very thankful.

American members ought to know how difficult is the case of their European brothers. Here we have greater freedom of thought, hence quicker acceptance, and very little persecution. Over there it is not so. Such a thing could hardly occur there as did here the other day. The ministers in a town rose up against our lecturer and tried to prevent his speaking by inducing the landlord to cancel the contract for the hall. Result: many citizens otherwise uninterested, intervened and obtained for us another hall. This could hardly take place, say in a similar small town in England, where the clergyman's fiat would be final. The people over there have not yet wholly escaped from the physical domination of the church. If they had lately so escaped they would themselves be yet too bigoted to give us the hearing or the freedom we get here.

Then, too, look at their newspapers! They either ignore the whole matter or now and then blurt out that Theosophy has been killed dead as a door-nail, never to rise again. All this tends to discourage. But members know Theosophy is not dead. We should not forget the plight of our fellows, and they can gain encouragement from our activity and the freedom we have.

A very significant fact is this: The Roman Catholics ignore Theosophy and all our doings. Of course now and then in their own church newspapers—which we never read—they may use us badly, but otherwise they are silent. We may go to a town and be well advertised, the Episcopalians and the Methodists will 288howl about us, but the Roman Catholics say nothing. This is in accord with the policy of killing a thing by ignoring it. We are therefore pleased, or ought to be, for the abuse the others heap upon us. Why should members groan when now and then we are loudly and unjustifiably abused? Why, that is a good advertisement, and surely we want the world to know of Theosophy.

Hypnotism is once more suggested as a means for doing away with all crime, and the New York Herald in November printed an article thereon. In this the writer proposes to hypnotize crime out of all criminals, and hopes soon to see asylums for the purpose. The case of a kleptomaniacal boy is cited who, the writer said, had been changed into an honest boy, and now has a position of great trust.

This horrible notion, as it seems to me, will of course have believers and helpers. People, like physicians, are empirical and prone to cure the outer sore rather than the poor blood that caused it. But the case of the boy proves nothing because it is not known how long the effect of suggestion will last, nor whether it may not suddenly break down and leave the person again a criminal. Then the people who propose this method do not know Theosophy. They do not see the seeds of crime in the mind, and do not admit that it might be worse to prevent the criminal now for present benefit than to let him work his criminal nature out. For if his criminal thought is now simply stopped for a while it may come out worse in the next life. It would seem as if the story in the Bible of the man having his devils come back worse than before might illustrate this. But even the proposal made so seriously points out how generally theosophical and occult ideas have affected the American public.

Proposals looking to the formation of retreats—some irreverent people would call them monasteries or nunneries—for Theosophists, seem to be unwise. There are not enough members in the entire movement to do its work properly. Why then withdraw them from activity? The duty of every member now is a business duty as well as one purely philosophical, psychical and ethical. Collections of members coming together in one house should be, at this period of our progress, for better and wider work. And that work should be now and not in the future. Hence getting up such centres, in debt, and sure to have to struggle through a long period, is a mistake.

The Observer.


319

General Pertinent Observations.

Last month a mistake was passed by the proof-reader which we must correct. We were made to say that in America we had but little "presentation," instead of "persecution." The Society certainly has much presentation, and if the era of persecution ever existed, it has passed away. We are well presented, not only by ourselves, but when a hiatus occurs in that, the newspapers then suddenly begin again about us. The last occasion was the sudden uprising of a Mr. Newton, who was first treasurer of the T.S. He was a spiritualist, left us quite soon, and retained a paper he had no official right to. This was a pledge of secrecy, given because another person was then promising to show wonderful occult performances that never came off. The paper is signed by H.P.B. among others. All this being spread out at length in a great New York daily, attention was once more turned to the Theosophical movement. Every time anything appears in newspapers about the Society or Theosophy members ought, in our opinion, to take advantage of it for a reply by way of explanation.

The great prayer test with dear Colonel Bob Ingersoll as the example, has been occupying the attention of the whole land during December. The Christian Endeavorers, thousands strong, started the prayers and enlisted other people. They offered up multitudes of appeals to God to change the Colonel; but at last accounts he remains the good man he always was, and not converted. Of course the whole thing is ridiculous, but it once more emphasizes the assertion that the civilized world has not escaped from superstition. The massacres of Armenians in Turkish 320dominions, and the protection of missionaries, would seem to be better subjects for prayer than is Ingersoll. But those affairs in Asia require cannon, soldiers and war ships—prayers won't do. Meanwhile, as we have found in our travels, the people in the country districts in America go on praying for rain or against it, as they may elect, and the rain dispenser laughs in his sleeve. We met one minister who said he had almost blundered into prayer for rain that week, but fortunately happened to hear that one of his parishioners wanted to get in his crops first. So the rain-screw was not turned till later. There was no response. These numerous failures are always overlooked.

But there are weak and sensitive persons who can be affected, through the astral and mental planes, by the prayers of many others if directed at them. This is a practice condemned by the Old Testament, for it is a species of sorcery (so called). We have no right to try to impose our will and opinions on others against their wish. Even this prayer test has helped the T.S., as theosophical opinions were asked for by newspapers and published.

On our journeys we have found it to be true, as once was stated in the Path, that no city in the country is unfit for Theosophy, or is too materialistic, or too full of some "ism" or other to allow of good work. Members often complain in that way. But they are wrong. When they form a branch they are full of enthusiasm, expecting to make a strong impression in the place. But they forget that this is not naturally possible. They also forget that there must be defections in their ranks, and be willing to have reactions. If the workers have patience and work on they will find at last the right result. Some of them think they must be orators, and not being so, they perceive no hope. Oratory is not indispensable. What they need is to have a clear, well defined and well thought out comprehension of as much Theosophy as they can grasp—and that will include all the important doctrines—so as to be able to give it out to others in a simple way. This would do more for the work than all the oratory in the world.

The unconsidered and hastily made proposition was brought before us of hiring some ex-minister to go about and preach Theosophy. This we would strenuously object to, regarding such a policy as pernicious, very hurtful to the movement. No man 321should be put to work for us who does not fulfil certain requirements. (a) Should be a proved member of the Society, who came in for the sake of Theosophy. (b) Must be ready to take what is called "pot luck," to have nothing whatever in the world. (c) Must be known to be earnest, zealous, devoted. (d) Should have been several years a member. (e) Must thoroughly know and believe in Theosophy, brotherhood, and the need for basing ethics on Theosophy. In fact, the objections to hiring ministers, or mere talkers, or new members, are so numerous as to be overwhelming. We at least hope that no branch will ever waste money in that way.

The desire to be at and about any of our headquarters, say in New York or Boston, Chicago or San Francisco, is probably a natural one. But it would seem that upon that desire should just as naturally follow self-questioning as to one's competency, what fitness one has, what acquirements we can offer, and what such headquarters ought to have. Yet we have met those who wanted to be taken by a T.S. headquarters without being able to offer a single thing in return; in fact, sometimes the candidate is lacking in elementary education. Some conversation resulted in discovering not only that the needful education for doing the best work was absent, but the notion was held that T.S. headquarters required only mediocre talent. What a monstrous idea! The very best talent, the finest education, should be devoted to such centres. But no, these aspirants want to sit around, and by talking with working Theosophists imagine they are doing great things, while they feel an excitement which they mistake for work. Then they are not willing to do drudgery, such as the work of the offices really is. They would be editors and authors at a rush, occultists indeed. No tedious addressing of envelopes or slaving at lists for them. Oh, for more willing drudges and less captains!

Two Observers.