Lockwood DW - The Problem of the Pyramid

From Teopedia
Revision as of 06:44, 19 November 2026 by 24pmBot1 (addition | contribs) (New article page: Theosophy vol. XII, no. 4, July 1897, pp. 140-148)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Books • Articles • Stories • Letters • All works
⇐ • ⇒
Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

The Problem of the Pyramid

William Quan Judge

(July 1897)

Argues, against the modern scientific dismissal of "pyramidology" as mere dreaming, that the Great Pyramid of Gizeh embodies a definite geometrical design relating the cube, the sphere and a "Perfect Pyramid" (one in which the ratio of height to base side matches the ratio of a circle's radius to a quarter of its circumference), developing a series of proportions between their volumes, areas and lines, and concluding that π functions as a universal measure linking these figures; derives, from the hypothesis that the Great Pyramid was built on the 30th parallel of north latitude (crediting Dr. J. D. Buck with this key), figures for its original base side, height and base angle, checked against Col. Howard Vyse's and Napoleon's engineers' measurements, and closes relating the pyramid's geometry to the Ansated Cross, Masonic symbols, and the Descending and Ascending Passages, and suggesting it was designed for "universal monumentation."

Publications:

Read:

DATA

Title for references: Lockwood DW - The Problem of the Pyramid
Short description: Argues, against the modern scientific dismissal of "pyramidology" as mere dreaming, that the Great P...

William Quan Judge

The Problem of the Pyramid

Signed in the byline "By Major D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A." and closing "D. W. Lockwood." No author card for D. W. Lockwood currently exists on this wiki. Transcription note (important): this article's mathematical content (fractions, exponents, radicals, the angle symbol, and especially the Greek letter π and the radical √) is very heavily corrupted by OCR, to a degree well beyond ordinary scanno noise. Two accompanying geometrical plates ("Plate 1" referenced on p. 142 and "Plate 2" on p. 144) are diagrams not reproduced here; p. 141 of the scan is occupied entirely by such a diagram, with no OCR-readable body text at all. Where the intended symbol is unambiguous from context (the OCR's "n", "it", or "tt" for the incommensurable circle-ratio π; combinations such as "V 3", "I 3", "l 3", "1-'3" for the radical √3), it has been normalized here as π and √3 respectively. Beyond this, the equations are transcribed essentially as scanned — including apparent fraction layouts, superscripts and exponents that could not be reliably reconstructed, and in a few spots what may be OCR-duplicated fragments of adjacent lines — rather than algebraically "corrected" or reconstructed from mathematical knowledge of what the author probably meant, since no facsimile check was possible. A reader wanting the actual mathematical content should consult the original scan/plates directly; this transcription should not be relied on for the formulas.

140

The Problem of the Pyramid.


By Major D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.

That something curiously different from ordinary geometrical methods, is somehow connected with the Problem of the Pyramid, has existed as a tradition for many years. In what this difference consists may be surmised from the fact that "Cubing the Sphere" and "Quadrating and Rectifying the Circle" are regarded as connected with the problem, although just how or in what way, has never been made plain, so far as I know. That the Great Pyramid was ever anything more than an unmeaning pile of rocks, except to the people of the so-called pagan times in which it was constructed, modern scientists are not disposed to admit, and little consideration is shown advocates of the affirmative. Circle-squaring and Perpetual Motion are classed as kindred subjects. Mathematicians readily accept the algebraical statement that πD=C; D being a diameter and C a circumference. Why not C/π = D? Since π is incommensurable, why one rather than the other? It is simply a matter of custom and convenience so-called. In the one case we construct an incommensurable circumference by describing a circle with a given or commensurable radius; in the other we construct an incommensurable radius for a given or commensurable circumference, by means of a pyramid or a pyramid triangle.

It is simply a case of inversion of methods. The lines in either case are equally geometrical.

A perfect pyramid, in the problem, is a right pyramid, in which the relation between the height and base side is the same as that existing between the radius of a circle and one-fourth of the circle described with it. Take any isosceles triangle, the relation between its height and base may be expressed as follows, b being the base and h the height, 2b/h = X, from which h = 2b/X. The height is also equal to one half the base by the tangent of the angle at the base, or calling this angle a, h = b/2 · tang a. Equating these values of h, there results h = 4 cotang a. This being a general expression is true for any value of X and is therefore true for X = π. Call the angle at the base of the triangle when X = π, a', then we shall have π = 4 cotang a'. The triangle is now a section of a perfect pyramid by a plane through its axis and perpendicular to a face.

141 [Plate I; the page is occupied entirely by a geometrical diagram, with no OCR-readable body text.]

142To develop the relation between the perfect pyramid, the cube and sphere: The cosine of 30° is equal to ½√3, so that in a sphere whose radius is R, the diameter of the circle of 30° is equal to R√3, and since this is the long diagonal of the cube with R as an edge, it appears that if a second sphere be constructed whose diameter equals the diameter of the circle of 30° of the first sphere, it will circumscribe the cube of the radius of the first sphere.

Plate I.—In the figure, let ZATL be the face of the cube whose edge PL equals R. With Q, the middle point of the base as a centre, and QC equal to PL equal to R, as a radius, describe a circle. Lay off OQ equal to D/— and draw BC parallel to PL.

Then the line BC equals R√3. On BC construct the isosceles triangle ABC. Then calling the angle at the base a we shall have X = 4 cotang a, when X = 2BC/AO, or AO = 2R√3/X or 2R√3/π.

Draw BZ and CZ perpendicular to AB and AC respectively. Then since the angle OBZ is the complement of ABO, the tangent of the former equals the cotangent a, and OZ = R√3/2 · cotang a or R√3/2 · X. Construct the large square STUV on BC as middle line, its area is 3R². There are now two pyramids having a common base equal to 3R²; the height of the erect one being AO = 2R√3/X · tang a. The inverted pyramid has a height OZ equal to R√3/2 · cotang a = R√3/2 · X.

In the triangle ABZ right-angled at B, we have BO² = AO · OZ = 2R√3/X · (R√3/2 · X) [transcription uncertain from this point for several lines; the OCR text is severely garbled].

Multiply both members of the equation by R² and the resulting expression may be put in the form [equation not legible in the scan]

that of the erect pyramid. Putting the above equation in the form of a proportion we may write

(1) ... R³ : R³ :: R³ : R³ ... or translated:

A cube is a mean proportional between — the volume of the in143verted pyramid and that of the erect, the pyramid base side being equal to the diagonal of the cube, or the pyramid base being a square equal in area to three times the base of the cube.

If in proportion (1) we make X = π, then the first term becomes equal to one-third the volume of the sphere whose diameter is R√3, the fourth term becomes the volume of a Perfect Pyramid, and the relation between the cube, sphere and perfect pyramid may be written as follows:

(2) ⅔πR³ : R³ :: R³ : 2√3 R³, or translated:

A cube is a mean proportional between one third the volume of the sphere circumscribing it, and a Perfect Pyramid whose base side equals the diameter of the circumscribing sphere, the long diagonal of the cube. It will be noted that when X becomes equal to π, the volume of the inverted pyramid becomes equal to one-fourth that of a sphere whose diameter is equal to the pyramid base side. By dividing the proportions, (1) or (2), through by R or R³ the resulting proportions will apply to surfaces and lines respectively.

Substituting for X its value 4 cotang a in proportion (1) there [text continues; a line or more is missing or unreadable in the scan at this point]

Draw MR perpendicular to BC, and lay off OG equal to OZ; prolong BZ to M and draw BR through G. Then RM is equal to 2R√3 cotang a, or four times the height of the inverted pyramid.

The circumference of a circle whose diameter is R√3 is πR√3 or 4R√3 cotang a', its semi-circumference will therefore be 2R√3 cotang a', so that when X becomes equal to π, MR becomes equal to 2R√3 cotang a', or the semi-circumference of a circle whose diameter is R√3. The volume of the sphere whose diameter is BC equal to R√3, is then equal to a rectangular prism whose base is equal to the face of the inscribed cube and whose height is equal to 2R√3 cotang a', or the semi-circumference of a great circle, or generally: the volume of a sphere is equal to a rectangular prism whose base is that of the inscribed cube and whose height is equal to the length of the semi-circumference of a great circle. If the base of the prism is taken as the square of the radius, then the height of the resulting prism is (2√3 cotang a') or 240° of the arc of a great circle. If the base of the prism is the square of the diameter, then the height of the resulting prism will be the length of the arc of 60° of a great circle.

The volume of the Perfect Pyramid is equal to that of a prism whose base is R³, the face of the inscribed cube, and whose height equals one half the diameter of a circle whose circumference is 1444R√3, while the volume of the inverted pyramid is equal to that of a prism whose base is R² and whose height is R√3/2 · cotang a' or the length of 45° of the arc of the circle whose radius is R√3/2.

As stated above when X = π, RM is equal to the length of the semi-circumference of the circle whose radius is OC equal to R√3/2, or π · R√3/2. In the triangle BRM we then have RM its base equal to π R√3 and BC its height equal to R√3. The area of the triangle is therefore equal to ½(RM·BC), which is the area of the circle whose radius is OC equal to R√3/2. Equal areas with the above are also the rectangles whose bases are MC or CR or ZG and whose common height is BC, or the rectangle whose base is MR and whose height is OC.

All that is needed to effect the above solutions practically is the angle a' at the base of the Perfect Pyramid.

If when X = π, a circle be described with O as a centre and OA as a radius, the latter then being the height of the Perfect Pyramid, the length of the circumference will be equal to the perimeter of the square STUV, the base of the Perfect Pyramid, and the square will be circled.

Plate 2.—This discussion could be made, using Plate 1, by turning it so as to make MR horizontal, but to avoid confusion about lines a separate plate is used.

Let ABD be a right vertical section of a pyramid, whose height is AC equal to h; with C as a centre and AC = h as a radius describe a circle; complete the diameter AT; draw XL, perpendicular to it and prolong AB and AD to X and L respectively; join H and F, intersections with the circle, and draw CV and CW parallel to AX and AL respectively. Since the discussion is general for any value of X we may write π for X, and treat the triangle AXL as a vertical section of a Perfect Pyramid by a plane perpendicular to a face. In the triangle CVT we then have VT equal to h cotang a', equal to one fourth of XL or the latter line is then equal to 4h cotang a' = πh, the semi-circumference of the circle. The area of the triangle AXL is then equal to πh².

If a rectangle be constructed on VT equal to h as a base, and a height AT equal to 2h, its area will be equal to πh². So with the rectangle whose height is CT and whose base is XL.

There are then a circle, a triangle and two rectangles of equal 145area, and if we multiply each of these areas by h, there will result a cylinder, two rectangular prisms and a triangular prism of equal volume, πh³. πh is the semi-circumference of a circle or a straight line, 4h cotang a', so that in the foregoing expressions πh, πh², πh³, the last of which is three fourths the volume of a sphere whose radius is h, if we make h equal to 1, a unit, as 1 foot, π becomes a universal unit of measure for lines, surfaces and volumes of the Cube, Sphere and Perfect Pyramid.

π is therefore a universal element, function or measure for these figures and derivatives from them.

Join the points H and T and F and T. The triangle AHT being right-angled at H, we have HE² = AE·ET, in which [the next few lines of this derivation are too badly garbled in the scan to transcribe with confidence] ... From the pyramid relation therefore, we have AE equal to [uncertain]. If for it we substitute its value 4 cotang a', this last expression for the new height AE, becomes 2h sin² a' and the distance ET becomes 2h cos² a'; the line HF being equal to [uncertain] becomes 4h cos a' sin a'. In short if a square be constructed on HF as middle line it will be a trigonometrical base, and the height will be trigonometrical also. The sum of the volumes of the erect and inverted pyramids will be 32h³/π³ · sin³ a' cos³ a' [exponents uncertain].

If on VW a square be constructed, its perimeter will be equal to 2πh, or the circumference of the circle whose radius is h, and if it be constructed on BD as middle line, it will be symmetrically disposed with reference to the circle, as ZYMJ.

If CT, equal to h, be made the diameter of a circle, the area of the latter will be equal to πh³/4 [exponent uncertain] or any one of the small rectangles equal to CDWT, and its circumference will be equal to the perimeter of the small square CDMO etc., or if AT be made the radius of a new circle and a large pyramid section be constructed, the π relation will still hold true, in all cases the base of the resulting triangle will be equal to the semi-circumference of the circle, and its area equal to that of the circle, the limits being a point at T and a circle with an infinite radius.

If for h we write R√3/—, to preserve the same nomenclature used with Plate 1, then HF becomes equal to π · [uncertain]/8 or 2R√3 sin a'

146cos a', and AE and ET become respectively R√3 sin² a' and R√3 cos² a', while the sum of the volumes of the erect and inverted pyramids becomes 4R³√3 sin² a' cos² a' or (2R√3)³ sin² a' cos² a' [exponents uncertain throughout this passage].

The discussion is general for any value of h.

Many more curious relations could be developed, but my object in this paper is mainly to show that there was a definite geometrical design in the pyramid figure, and also to indicate something concerning the reason for evolving such a figure bearing the relation already given, to the cube and sphere.

A Perfect Pyramid as will be seen from this discussion is therefore such a figure, that any section by a plane parallel to its base, i. e., perpendicular to its axis, is a square whose perimeter is equal to the circumference of a circle described with the pyramid height above the section, as a radius. A vertical section by a plane through its axis and perpendicular to a face, is a triangle, such that its area is equal to that of a circle whose diameter is the height of the triangle, while its base is equal to the semi-circumference of the circle. It would therefore appear that a Perfect Pyramid is of the nature of a cube and a sphere, or it may be regarded as a cube and a sphere, illustrating geometrically the idea of At-one-ment, as of Man, The Earth and The Universe,—The Pyramid, Cube and Sphere.

What is the object of evolving such a figure? My theory is that it was designed for universal monumentation. By its use the relations between circular and spherical elements may be expressed by employing the elements of a cube.

I am aware that the conclusions I have stated regarding π, are somewhat different from those generally held concerning that function, but they seem warranted. In the geometrical conception of the Wisdom Religion of the Ancients, π symbolized the Divine, or Divine Spirit, and the demonstration proving its universality, shows the presence of the Divine in everything from a geometrical point, an atom, to a sphere whose radius is infinite—Omnipresence.

In the Encyclopedia Britannica, under the head of "Squaring the Circle," an article written by Thomas Muir, LL.D., it is stated that "In 1873 Hermite proved that the base e of the Naperian Logarithms cannot be a root of a rational algebraical equation of any degree. To prove the same proposition regarding π is to prove that a Euclidian construction for circle-quadrature is impossible. * * * Hermite did not succeed in his attempt on π; but in 1882 Lindemann following exactly in Hermite's steps, accomplished the desired result."

The article also states that "the interest attaching to them (pseudo circle-squarers) is more psychological than mathematical."

147I quote the above to show the present accepted mathematical conclusions concerning such problems as "circle-squaring," and the standing of those interested in the subject; it would appear, however, that given the angle at the base of the Perfect Pyramid a Euclidian construction for Cubing the Sphere, Quadrating and Rectifying the Circle is possible and that these problems are elementary. In time when the Problem of the Pyramid is still further developed, it may dawn on many who are doubters now, that such men as Prof. Piazzi Smyth, Col. Ralston Skinner and many others, who have suffered for their faith in the Great Pyramid, are entitled to some other designation than "mere dreamers," and that the references to that Great Structure in the Secret Doctrine were based on knowledge.

Proportion (1) was derived from a study of the Great Pyramid of Gizeh, on the theory that its latitude at the time of its construction was 30° North. Dr. J. D. Buck of Cincinnati has always been an advocate of the theory that this was the key to the solution of the mystery.

Why, it may be asked, should the Builders go to the 30th parallel to build a pyramid? For two reasons, 1st, to obtain geometrically the pyramid cubit, √3, and 2d, because nowhere else on the Earth can an Earth pyramid, i. e., one whose base side is the diameter of a sphere circumscribing the cube of the Earth's radius, be constructed geometrically, and be erect, than on the parallel of 30° North latitude. This would imply that a certain relation exists between the elements of the pyramid and those of the Earth.

Granting for the present that the Great Pyramid was built on the 30th parallel of latitude, the position of the polar diameter of the Earth at that date can be determined, by a re-determination of the latitude, and the azimuth of a base side or better still, that of the centre line of the descending passage.

The original elements of the pyramid before the casing was removed by the Caliphs of Egypt, about the year 1000 A. D., were as follows, according to the results I have reached.

Length of base side, 441 cubits or 441√3 feet; height, 486.2025 feet; π = 800√3/441 = 4·200√3/200 [transcription of this equation uncertain] = 3.142042-; a = 51° 51'; height of inverted pyramid, 300 feet; the cotang a equals 200√3/4 [uncertain], which makes the angle at the base exactly 51° 51'.

Col. Howard Vyse, who discovered two of the casing stones in place along the North base side in 1837, made the above angle 51° 50', by measuring the angle which the sloping face of the stones made with the horizon. The engineers and scientists who accompanied Napoleon in his invasion of Egypt in 1799, measured the 148North base side, having discovered the hollow sockets cut in the rock to mark the N.E. and N.W. corners; they made the distance 763.62 feet. Col. Howard Vyse measured this same base side in 1837 making it 764 feet. The mean of these two measurements is 763.81 feet. My determinations make this distance 763.814+ feet [last digits uncertain].

The British foot appears to have been the standard unit of measure for length, and the pyramid or builders' cubit derived from it was √3 feet or 1.7320508+ feet in length.

The geometry of the pyramid shows the origin of many ancient symbols. Circumscribing a cube by a sphere and then unfolding the cube, gives the Ansated Cross. The triangle in a circle, a Masonic Symbol, is itself a circle, its area being equal to that of a circle whose diameter equals the height of the triangle. The inverted pyramid section is the flap on the Masonic Apron, and when worn point down should be in token of humility; it is a complete inversion of the erect pyramid even to the angles. The Descending Passage is a geometrical line, and so is the Ascending Passage, but appears to have been modified somewhat in its general location, for structural reasons, as theoretically the King's Chamber and Antechamber should occupy a certain point. A definite distance appears to be indicated between the foot of the step at the entrance to the Antechamber and the Portcullis near the Descending Passage. The geometry connected with the Coffer is very comprehensive and suggestive, and abounds in ancient symbols.

So far my investigations tend to indicate that the Great Pyramid was constructed according to a carefully conceived geometrical design, and that its records, when read aright as they will be some day, will be of vast interest. If my theory is correct, that it was designed for universal monumentation, the whole story may not be evolved for a long time, but the records are safe even if the entire structure were destroyed, thanks to the efforts of practical pyramid enthusiasts, who have carefully measured the different parts.

D. W. Lockwood.

God always plays the geometer.

Plato. See Plutarch's Symposiacs.