Buck JD - Speak Little Judge Not Love Much and Work

From Teopedia

!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!

Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Speak Little; Judge Not: Love Much; and Work

Jirah Dewey Buck

(English)

(April 1890)

Argues that true self-possession comes through renunciation, not withdrawal from the world, and contrasts the silent "transformer," who works by noble example, with the censorious "reformer" who judges and condemns; extends the same principle to the relation of man and woman, and points to H. P. Blavatsky's selfless labor for the Theosophical Society as the example of one for whom "the reward is in the work."

Publications:

Read:

DATA

Title for references: Buck JD - Speak Little Judge Not Love Much and Work
Short description: Argues that true self-possession comes through renunciation, not withdrawal from the world, and cont...

Jirah Dewey Buck

Speak Little; Judge Not: Love Much; and Work

10 Notwithstanding all that has been written on the subject, a good deal of both obscurity and confusion still remains even among professed theosophists regarding the ethics of theosophy and the objects of the T. S.

This was, indeed, to have been expected, both on account of the extent of the subject, the immeasurable ground covered, and from the fact that each individual, whether student or disciple, must not only have in himself "the beginnings of theosophy," but from first to last is himself the measure of his own understanding and progress.

The mistake is indeed very common to suppose that when once the whole truth is clearly stated, the work is virtually accomplished. But the "instructive tongue" must find an echo in the "faithful breast" ere we reach the beginnings of wisdom. The end of wisdom, viz., understanding, is again but the beginning of knowledge and power.

Power is thus a thing of slow growth. It is never reached at a bound. It is often imagined that when one has really renounced the world, the whole work is accomplished. So long as one is in the world, and has not renounced it, his reward is in the world. Having renounced the world, one is apt to look for his reward, or to expect some adequate compensation, thus mistaking the beginning for the end. In truth, however, one does not really begin to work in the world till he has renounced the world. Henceforth his work is in the world, not away from it. This is the paradox that so few seem able to understand. Renunciation in the sense in which it is ordinarily understood is substantially suicide. To have found the world distasteful, and life on the ordinary plane a failure, and hence to renounce it; to turn from the disappointments of life because they seem to equal its successes, and so to give it all up as not worth the candle, is to make life a failure indeed.

If this were the mission of theosophy, the short cut by way of suicide is more logical and sensible.

In response to the hackneyed query, "Is life worth living?", Theosophy replies, That depends on the Life and the Living.

So long as one is involved in the life of the world, he is subject to circumstance and never master even of himself. Renunciation does not take man out of the world; it but fits him to work in the world by changing his entire attitude to it.

The first result of this change of attitude is the removal of fret and 11friction. The result is equipoise and self-possession. Not that conceit of shallow minds that springs from egotism, complaisant self-satisfaction, the sign-manual of ignorance. This often, indeed, passes for self-possession, when it is only greed for possessing others. That cool, calculating attitude of the man of the world when seeking the best advantage, with the eye always on the main chance, is even nearer defeat and final catastrophe than almost any other condition that can be imagined. Self-complaisancy is superficial, and beneath this mask lurks fear of the inevitable final catastrophe. This is far removed from that self-possession that follows renunciation. It is, in fact, its opposite. The first is inspired by egotism; the second by a truism; the first seeks to gain; the second to give. The first does indeed gain a temporary power over the world, only to fall afterwards into nothingness and despair. The second gains power over self, leads upward to the everlasting, triumphs, and endures.

This is the meaning of the "vow of silence" in ancient initiations. Apollonius did not relinquish his journey or relax his labors during his five years of silence. When one stops to consider how much of speech is ill-timed and useless, if not actually pernicious, golden silence begins to be appreciated. Our judgments and condemnations of others are at best but embryonic till we give them life through speech. In thus limiting speech we improve judgment and mature thought. Nor does this limitation of speech by any means destroy conversation or hinder human intercourse. A good listener is often as welcome and as greatly admired as a good talker, provided he listens intelligently. When the time for conversation arises, well-chosen words, expressing clear ideas, inspired by noble sentiments, are all that is in any way desirable in conversation.

A silent example is always more potent than words. Argument is useless and criticism of persons pernicious. One who has this self-possession, who refrains from judging or condemning others, is ready and able to engage in labors of love. He is not a reformer, but a transformer. It has often been said that reformers are men of one idea, and there is a good deal of truth in the statement. The motto of William Lloyd Garrison was, "Immediate and unconditional emancipation of the slave." No compromise, no colonization schemes, no subterfuges; and presently the nation heard and trembled. The transformation of society is by slow methods, like a broad, shallow stream flowing over vast territories, permeating everywhere. It is an evolution. The reformation of society is like a mountain torrent dashing down precipitous descents, and is often accomplished by revolution. A reformer must not see too much; a transformer cannot see too much. The weakness of the one is the strength of the other. A reformer seeks by criticising and condemning evils in others to put down abuses in the world: a transformer seeks by the power of a noble example and rooting 12out the evil in his own nature, to bring out the latent good in all through the all-redeeming power of love and charity. It makes all the difference in the world as to how we take our levels, whether we level up or level down. Say to the fond mother that she should love other children as her own, and she replies that she cannot, and she brings strong arguments against it. Shall she level down the love she bears to her own child, "her own flesh and blood," to the level of that common love and sympathy that she already bears toward the homeless, and yet that satisfies itself with giving the broken food and the cast-off garment to the needy? Or, on the other hand, shall she level up this indifferent charity to the plane of real mother-love, and so realize not only the human but the Divine Motherhood. Suppose all the mothers in any community were to go to work together to level up their charity to the plane of human motherhood, would not their own children reap the first fruits of the diviner motherhood? It is true that no single mother can reform the motherhood of the world, but she can transform her own motherhood and make it really divine in its beneficence; and that is what the motherhood of the world is really accomplishing, in spite of the fatherhood of man, that continually ignores personal responsibility and multiplies orphanage and bastardy! The work that one noble, loving woman can accomplish in any community is seldom even dreamed of, much less realized. In relation to woman man should begin as a reformer. In relation to woman the average man of the world is indeed—"a man of one idea." This idea is anchored in "sex" and bounded by "self." Let him declare "immediate and unconditional emancipation" of woman. No colonization, no compromise, no subterfuge. Let him replace the sham of generosity by the reality of justice. Let motherhood be a free choice with full partnership in the subsidy. Love in its truest and best sense is impossible without Liberty. The real love-labor of man and woman begins only where slavery leaves off. Here is precisely the partition wall between love and lust. The one thrives only in freedom, giving that which is its own: the other is the degradation of slavery, the tyranny of egotism, despoiling another and taking that which is not its own. The reformation of man must go back to the year one of the "Christian Era," and begin with the first chapter of Genesis. Man began by stealing the "Godhead"; let him relinquish this ill-gotten, ill-used authority over woman, and a real Christian era will begin. The Roman Catholic Church, always "wise in its day and generation," colonized the God-head, and by instituting Mary Queen of Heaven managed to keep possession of woman in the present world with an apparent sanction of both logic and justice. This is precisely what Constantine did when he married Catholicity to temporal power, making the man of sorrows an incomprehensible mystery, and putting creed in the place of Christos.

13 Let the critic judge as he will of the writings of Madame Blavatsky, her work stands as an everlasting memorial to every member of the Theosophical Society. What occurs during the eight hours from 10 p. m. to 6 a. m., no witness has ventured to declare. The other sixteen hours are amply testified to by a cloud of witnesses. The most constant and uncomplaining labor for the Society and its work, regardless of heavy burdens that would daunt the stoutest heart. Ill-health, poverty, and abuse have been her reward as men count gain. Whatever motive her calumniators may find for such labors under such adverse circumstances concerns us very little, only so far as it really impedes her work. It has been so far powerless to arrest it, however it may misinterpret and misrepresent. Only they will understand her labors who have already within themselves the germ of that for which she toils, and whenever all of these have received the message her work is done. The monuments which the tardy justice of her detractors and obstructers may rear to posterity will no more atone for present injustice than the monument offered to the memory of Bruno in Rome can bring him back to life or justify his murder. Her present example, however, cannot fail of its significant lesson to everyone in any way deserving the name of Theosophist.

Ask Madame Blavatsky—"Is life worth the living," and she will tell us, from all personal considerations, a thousand times—No! Yet how many who love life for its rewards and emoluments work as she? Relinquishing every personal gain, all worldly advantage, her labors are such as no worldly ambition ever excites and no love of personal gain ever inspires. A thoroughly sick woman at the age of sixty can demand little of the world, and cares little for future fame in the face of unfailing abuse. At that age ambition usually cools and enthusiasm is dead, and yet through all she works and loves, and loves her work.

"My doctrine is not mine, but his that sent me."

The theosophist who thirsts for knowledge and longs for power, who imagines that he has renounced the world, and who pretends to despise the "flesh and the devil," and is looking anxiously for Mahatmas, or listening for "astral bells," may learn a lesson in work, not only from Madame Blavatsky, but from Col. Olcott and Mr. Judge as well. Whether to these workers life be worth the living or not, they are working to make it more desirable to others. St. Hilaire may see only the motive of selfishness in Buddhism, while the professed Christian practically apotheosises selfishness. Yet he who knows what renunciation really means will see that work for the world inspired by love of man is neither confined to Christ or Buddha, nor to the followers of either. Man can transform the world only as he reforms himself; and man can elevate himself only through his efforts to help humanity.

The reward is in the work. To serve the truth for the truth's own sake 14is to give truth a lodgment in one's own soul. All falsehood will thus disappear as clouds and darkness vanish before the rising sun. Thence come peace and rest.

Rest is not fitting
The busy career:
Rest is the fitting
Of self to one's sphere.

'Tis the brook's motion
Clear without strife,
Fleeting to ocean
After this life.

'Tis loving and serving
The highest and best:
'Tis onward unswerving,
And this is true rest.

J. D. Buck.