!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(August 1894)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. IX, no. 5, August 1894, pp. 137-143
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Коннелли Дж.Х. - Долг человека к его братьям-животным
DATA
Title for references: Connelly JH - Mans Duty to his Brother Brutes
Short description: Argues from Karma, rather than sentiment, against cruelty to animals, tracing how the malefic astral...
137Confounding the individuality of man with his personality, and the according of an undue importance to the latter, which is a basic error in modern Christian belief, are in various ways much to be regretted, as affording false premises from which many wrong and injurious conclusions are naturally drawn. The fundamental injury done by it is through a tendency to cultivate in a man a sense of separateness from both the Divine Source of his immortal being and the phenomenal universe of which his transient personality is a part. In point of fact, he is separate from neither, being in his essence a portion of the former—with potentiality of conscious reunion—and indissolubly connected with the latter, so long as he retains corporeal form, by his subjection to laws governing all matter.
A rather rare old book, The Chronicles of Nuremberg, printed in 1492, contains a picture of the Lord, in voluminous robes and with a crown on his head, molding Adam out of a mass of clay; and another picture represents the Lord, costumed as before, pulling Eve—a little female figure, out of an oval hole in the side of the sleeping Adam. Those pictures were published under the censorship and with the approval of the church. To one who can believe that version of the creation of man, faith in almost any138thing else must come easy, and such robust credulity is demanded of him who would be an orthodox Christian. He must not doubt God's concentrating his attention upon man; that God made the sun to give man light by day, and the moon to give man light by night, and the stars and planets to decorate the firmament for man's delectation, and the comets to amuse man or perhaps to stimulate his curiosity: that God invented the seas and rivers for man to sail upon and drink, and iron for man to use in fashioning implements and weapons, and gold for man to use as a medium of exchange or standard of value, and the flora and fauna of every land for man to amuse or decorate himself with or devour, and so on, the general purpose and all the details being—everything for man. Theosophy does not accord such importance to the corporeal man, but regards him as simply a creature who has attained a certain advanced stage in the endless course of evolution through which all the manifested universe is moving, and affirms that it is impossible for him to evade by any assumption of superiority or inherent right of selfishness his full share of Karmic responsibility for his acts toward all other beings in the evolutionary chain, however low they may still seem to be. This is one of the serious differences between that philosophy and Christianity, which less than any other form of religion largely professed in so-called civilized countries inculcates as a moral duty human kindness to the lower orders of animal life. And, indeed, it was not enjoined by the founder of that creed. So far as we may judge from what his followers have chosen to retain of his teachings, Christ, while full of tenderness for the sons of men, gave no particular consideration to the rights of animals. It is true that he did upon one occasion mention the duty of rescuing a domestic animal from a pit into which it had fallen, as justifying a violation of the strict Sabbatical law, but even in that, whether higher regard was paid to the feelings of the animal or to its owner's acute appreciation of its property value—which he knew was strong in his people—is open to question. At all events, there is no record of Christ's having ever uttered any such eloquently compassionate appeal on behalf of the helpless dumb brutes as Gautama Buddha's protest against blood sacrifice.
Possibly a reflection stirring humanity's self-interest would be more potent than one based upon sentiment or justice to-day as much as in Christ's time, and, taking this point of view, men will do well to consider whether gravely evil consequences are not likely to grow from the seeds of wrong and cruelty our race is sowing in its treatment of the animals. A prominent newspaper, 139one which frequently manifests intelligence in its editorial columns, recently published the following:
From London and from San Francisco simultaneously come accounts of human beings mortally affected with glanders. Man domesticates an animal, uses or houses him ill, and presently nature develops in him a disease by means of which she avenges the outrage done on herself. The better opinion of to-day is that this is the origin and genesis of that supreme scourge of the human race, the disease of consumption. Recent investigation has brought to man's knowledge a number of human diseases produced by parasites originally developed in the lower animals and communicated from them to man. It begins to appear that the Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals may yet receive their most effectual aid from the studies showing how the effects of such evil doing work out their own revenges on the higher race responsible for them. In time, systematic study may even trace the operation of nature's same law of inexorable revenge from the practice of cruelty upon children. Should this ever be made palpable to the plain understanding, the societies combatting this evil will have gained the most effectual ally their cause is capable of attracting. No evil is ever eradicated until it is shown to be a fruit of ignorance, containing within itself, for that reason, elements of a retribution inevitable under the operation of natural law.
With all the good sense its business interests cannot quite suppress, the paper making that utterance is still too timid, too much afraid of shocking its orthodox advertisers, to venture calling that "natural law" by its right name—Karma, for the doctrine of absolute justice, the affirmation of inevitable responsibility, is unwelcome to those trained to hope evasion, through the vicarious atonement, of what they know they deserve.
Karmic justice is an essential element of evolutionary development. It is not confined to the ethical field, rewarding good and punishing evil, but is operative upon every plane of being, for it is the law by which causes are inevitably productive of effects. The blooming of a flower from a planted seed, the blasting of a rock by an explosive force, and the blighting of a soul by a career of vice and crime, are all Karmic outcomes, and either is but one link in an endless chain of indissolubly related incidents. Nothing exists, or can be imagined by the mind of man, which is not at once a consequence and potentially a cause for other consequences. Hence man in his every thought, word, and deed sows seed which must produce harvest, in kind and degree exactly proportioned to it. And this harvest is in no wise dependent upon the vigilance of any "recording angel", or the humor of any anthropomorphic God, or the interposition of influence by any superhuman being more merciful than just.
The Karma made by human beings is not simply individual, but collective as well, and a family, a class, a nation, or a race 140may by joint participation in or condonation of wrong bring upon itself retributive consequences which will be deeply afflictive, or even destructive, to it as a whole; individual deserts at the same time receiving their exact measure of award. It may seem to purblind human wisdom that in such comprehensive afflictions the innocent suffer with the guilty, but such is not the case. The unerring law of Karma determines the measure of individual responsibility, and is alone capable of prescribing who are the innocent.
Cruelties to animals generally dealt with by organized human societies, or taken cognizance of by law, are of four classes,—those perpetrated through ignorance or parsimony, as the ill-keeping or feeding of domestic animals; the savage punishment of beasts of burden and "pets" by persons of ungovernably violent tempers; such brutal sports as dog-fighting and cock-fighting; and, unhappily, a certain small proportion in which unbalanced minds seem to derive a morbid gratification from the infliction of pain. These are, of course, very bad; but it is open to question if all together make for the race so heavy a debt of evil Karma as must come from two other classes, for which the burden of direct responsibility rests upon those who assume to represent the highest civilization, culture, and scientific progress of the age. One of these is the practice of vivisection—the torture of living animals—nominally "in the interest of science" but actually for the gratification of a profitless and morbid curiosity as to the intensity of physical agony a creature can endure yet live and be conscious of its excruciating pain, or how it will act in the demonstration of emotions under such horrible conditions. As illustrations of this may be cited Prof. Bracket's experiments on dogs, to test their affections. He dug out a dog's eyes, destroyed its organs of hearing, inflicted upon it the most agonizing tortures in various diabolically ingenious ways, to find, if he could, the limit of its attachment, and still, until merciful death came to its relief, the poor animal licked his hands. A female dog with young was cut open and her puppies extracted, with the object of seeing if in her dying agonies she would recognize them as her offspring and exhibit maternal affection. Another, taken from her young, had her breasts cut off and was put down, so mutilated, bleeding, and dying, among her hungry little ones, to see what she would do when she could not feed them. She offered them her gaping wounds, caressingly licked them in her last agonies, and died. The law recognizes the right of so-called scientists to practice such infernal and utterly inexcusable atrocities, and licenses them, and the guilt of their perpetration consequently rests not only upon 141the individual perpetrators, but upon the community which does not punish such deeds and make them infamous.
The other enormous wrong referred to is the wanton slaughter of birds that their plumage may be employed for the decoration of women's hats and dresses and in certain specialties of "art-work". In a single week in 1888 there were sold at auction in London the skins of 400,000 North and South American birds, a large proportion of them those of humming birds. At one sale 12,000 humming birds' skins were sold. And that is but one of the numerous markets in which this trade goes on constantly in Europe and America. So great is it that it has almost made extinct some of the most brilliant varieties. Of the superb "ruby and topaz" humming-bird, 3,000 skins were sent in one shipment from Rio de Janeiro. Of many varieties of birds, women only care to adorn themselves with certain portions, the wings, breast, or tail, and, as it is believed that the feathers keep their brilliant colors longer if taken before the bird dies, hunters of birds for fashion's use make a practice of twisting off the wings, tearing out the tail feathers, or deftly ripping off the entire skin of the breast, from the still living creature, then indifferently casting aside the palpitating, agonized, mangled little victim, to die at its leisure.
Can anyone who realizes the scope of moral responsibility involved in the operations of Karmic law for a moment imagine that the reaction from that cruelty will fall only upon the ignorant and brutal hunters—who are often savages—and that the men who employ them, the merchants who trade in their spoils, the fair women who adorn themselves with the blood-stained trophies, and the complacent friends who approve their fostering of the merciless traffic, will not all have to bear their share of the account?
Among various kindly peoples whom good Christian vivisectors, bird-wing wearers, and preachers of the vicarious atonement stigmatize as "heathen", it is believed that one who is guilty of wanton cruelty to a dumb, helpless beast will, after death in mortal form, reincarnate consciously as a beast, of the kind he has injured, and suffer at the hands of some other cruel man such suffering as he inflicted. Taken literally, it might be said that arrangement would be very fair and likely to keep up the supply of beasts and the practice of cruelties; but the real meaning of that exoteric teaching, as understood by the wiser, is not that there will be actual retrogression to animal form, since that would be a violation of the general law of evolution, but that the wantonly cruel deed certainly involves such Karmic retribution 142as will bring pain equal to that inflicted. Sooner or later the punishment will certainly come. "Though a man die, yet shall he live again", and the Karmic debt he incurs never is outlawed, but must eventually be paid.
One retributive effect, the causing of human diseases, has already been noted. Another is heard of in the wail of the agriculturist that his harvests suffer from the attacks of insect myriads no longer held in check by the little feathered songsters he has helped to send away for the adornment of women's hats. But it is not solely in such material phenomena that the Karmic recompense is meted out. It touches the minds and souls of men as well as their lives and pockets, even of those who deem themselves free from all responsibility in the matter, for there is no such thing as separateness possible in all our great family.
The astral condition of matter, in which the atoms are just a little too refined for perception by our senses, pervades the denser molecules of the material plane and, interblended with yet more tenuous atoms constituting other planes, fills all space, at least within our world, to the uttermost confines of its gaseous envelope. All material forms have in them their astral bodies, or models, upon which are molded the material molecules which make them objective to our senses. The dense atoms of the gross molecules, the astral atoms mingled with them, and the more rarefied atoms of yet subtler conditions of matter are all together in ceaseless vibratory motion, interactive, reciprocal, and productive of phenomena. All sentient things impel modifications of those vibrations, in kind and degree proportioned to their sensations, from their astral principles in which such sensations are perceived to the general ocean of astral atoms in which all are submerged, and these vibrations not only leave there their impressions, a record of all that which has been, but are causative of vibrations affecting other organisms through their responsive astral principles. Thus, when the astral ocean is made to pulsate with vibrations caused by pain and wrong, it attains a malefic influence which is as really poisonous in its effects upon men's minds and souls as an atmosphere charged with some deadly gas would be to the lives of those inhaling it. Dulled sense of moral responsibility, debasement of thought and feeling, inhuman indifference to the misfortunes of others, increase of selfishness and abandonment to sensuality are all products of such vibrational influences, unconsciously sensed on the astral plane and thence transferred to the higher and yet more potent rate of vibrations belonging to the mentality of man.
143Not until we deal more humanely with what we are pleased to call the lower orders of creation will we cease to require constant enlargement of our prisons, alms-houses, insane asylums, and hospitals.
J. H. C.