Fullerton A - East and West

From Teopedia
Books • Articles • Stories • Letters • All works
⇐ • ⇒
Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

East and West

William Quan Judge

(March 1895)

Argues, by analogy with the masculine and feminine temperaments, that the practical, scientific West and the spiritual, contemplative East are complementary rather than antagonistic, and that the Theosophical Society's work is to unite their respective excellences into a single, richer civilization.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Фуллертон А. - Восток и Запад

DATA

Title for references: Fullerton A - East and West
Short description: Argues, by analogy with the masculine and feminine temperaments, that the practical, scientific West...

William Quan Judge

East and West

375

East and West.

The contrast between East and West is much like that between a woman and a man,—not an antagonism but a complement. In the man we find the restless, pushing, aggressive, venturesome, hard-headed, practical, calculating, rationalistic, virile spirit; in the woman, the quiescent, retiring, peaceful, timid, sentimental, poetic, trustful, intuitive, feminine. These qualities are less the reverse of each other than the converse; not arrayed for mutual extermination but for mutual support. And as in any ideal household perfection comes through the conjunction of the strong traits in each mate with the weak ones in the other, so in the Theosophic household growth and pro-376gress come when to the vigor of the Occidental temper is united the spiritual insight of the Oriental.

Social philosophers have moralized long over the internal characteristics of the sexes, puzzling, sometimes worrying, themselves why the ordinary man is spiritually obtuse and the ordinary woman materially unpractical. They do not marvel at the male incapacity to nurse an infant, nor the female to ship before the mast: physiological limitations are patent enough. But when there is question as to why mental and moral distinctions are normally as marked, the perplexity begins. Yet it is abundantly obvious that the body is but the external manifestation of the soul, that the sex peculiarities are expressed in both; and equally obvious, one would say, that the duality which pervades Nature has its highest and most explicit exhibition in Man.

So with nations. As in families the male and the female display the universal duality and find true domesticity in combination; as in communities the antithetical energies seek appropriate spheres in unlike employments; so nations differentiate into those expressing the outward virility of action and those expressing the genius of contemplation and inner grace. And with nations, as with families and communities, the richest results are not from jealous contrasts or embittered antagonisms, but from a union in which the deficiencies of one are complemented by the exhuberance of another.

What is true of commerce, manufactures, and agricultural products is true of mental and spiritual endowments. Every advanced people has something to contribute to the world's store of valuables, and the contribution must be of that which is its own special output. No nation can expect to evolve from itself all the minerals, crops, and craft-work which are required for complete national well-being, but wisely develops itself in those excellences which its local furnishings suggest, profitably exchanging the product for the differing products wherein other nations excel; and the reasonable dictate of allowing national genius full course and of both giving and receiving wealth through interchange of the best holds equally of ideas and aspirations. To expect national genius to be all-comprehensive, supplying the highest fruits of thought and devotion in all departments, is equivalent to expecting that one zone should produce the chestnut and the pine-apple, the arctic fur and the tropical cocoa-fibre; and to refuse exchange of mental treasures from pride or exclusiveness is as childish and suicidal as any scheme of "protection" in political economy.

Unguarded addiction to dominant traits produces one-sidedness 377and evil. A man without feminine check becomes rough, tyrannical, coarse; a woman without masculine tonic becomes weak, silly, dependent. A nation uninfluenced by foreign experiences cannot perceive its own deficiencies and naturally exaggerates its own specialty, becoming aggressive if of virile disposition, subservient if the reverse. Its literature and religion express the prevalent temper, dealing in bombast and wars when of the former type, with superstition and sentiment when of the latter. And so it is that deliberate isolation hypertrophies a national trait till it becomes diseased, and the only sure cure is infusion of imported thought. Dominatingness may be assuaged by spirituality, folly by practical wisdom.

These somewhat commonplace truths have wholesome bearing on that comparison between East and West which is so frequently asserted in Theosophical quarters, sometimes intelligently, sometimes otherwise. Speaking generally, one may say that the West displays the masculine type, the East the feminine. In our hemisphere the prominent quality is practical enterprise. The conquest of exterior nature, the betterment of material conditions, the utilization of all opportunities for business advance,—these are the aims which so brace energy and stimulate endeavor that success in them is the grand marvel of the age. The Western world seems like one great man, vigorous, herculean of strength, sure to bend all materials to his will. He has not always fine sense of right or much perception of supersensual things, but he certainly is open-eyed to practical affairs and keen to invent appliances. On the other hand, the Orient is sentimental, dreamy, averse from action, little given to leaving home, indifferent to material progress, eminently conservative, close in touch with truths in the unseen, more alive to the other world than to this, gladly subordinate, unready to combine against aggression, even willing for it if it guarantees protection. The type is not virile but feminine, and its intuitive sense of what is grander than force and finer than materialism brings Divinity into humanity.

This distinction exhibits itself in the contrasted tastes, habits, social organization, pursuits, ambitions, interests, books, art, and religion. Of course inherent constitution moulds every outward manifestation. More than anywhere else do we see in men and women the sex element in religion, rationalizing and independence and self-assertion characterizing the men, faith and compliance and submission to authority the women. A masculine race and a feminine race contrast in the same way, and therefore Western religion is a record of revolts, reforms, the application 378of reason to Theology, a defective sense of reality in the unseen; while Eastern religion changes little, is ever reverent to tradition, cares little for the canons of practicality, and profoundly feels the immanence of Deity.

And in races as in sexes, the exclusive development of one type results in disproportion and mischief. Our Western hemisphere has become so plunged in thought of physical interests that it has lost delicate sensitiveness to interests above matter, and even doubts if such exist. Materialism has atrophied its soul. The hemisphere of the East has become so immersed in thought of superphysical interests that it has lost perception of reasonable considerations and practical claims, stolidly bends before traditional myths, is superstitious and fanciful and trembling at change. Its beautiful insight into the world beyond matter and forms keeps it too indifferent to the conditions of actual life and to the methods those conditions exact.

Clear-sighted observers, viewing impartially these racial peculiarities and evils, have detected the true treatment for both and instinctively exclaim "Marry this woman to this man!" For nature and experience alike affirm that in the union of opposites there is health. Let the dreamy Oriental feel the touch of a virile energy, the sense-bound Occidental be warmed by a spiritual emotion long unsensed. In the free intercourse of affection and thought, lacking traits will receive their complement, old mistakes will be corrected by glad concession, partial truth find its missing half, depleted energies mutually refilled. As the association makes each conscious of the better endowments of the other, there will be eagerness to secure them, and so in generous partaking there will come more symmetry of character without a loss of distinctive trait. Mutual respect will heighten self-respect, and the fruit of such happy combination ripen rapidly in beauty and luxuriance.

In this cordial, generous appreciation of unlike gifts is the clue to inter-racial as to domestic perfection. Husband and wife do not expand in healthy character if unfavorably comparing each other's traits. Similarly the united East and West would never flourish if, instead of noting and valuing the excellences of each other, the one should be ever lamenting the sordid interests of her mate, and the mate be declaiming against the childish babble of her Sacred Books, the petty ceremonies and paltry observances which make life a tedious round of forms, none the better because baptized "religious". It is not by emphasizing faults that the faults become distasteful. Sordid interests and religious 379puerilities disappear only as they are dislodged by the worthier contents introduced voluntarily under the gentle pressure of example. And in such a marriage such would ensue.

A curious contrast may but solidify the union. In general, the world is at its oldest now, and therefore at its best. But the East was better in its youth, and the West is better in its age. No one looks to barbaric, or even to classic, times as the apex of Occidental civilization; no one to the modern Orient as the Golden Era of its religion. The best of the one is in the present, the best of the other in the past. Yet this is only another of those complemental distinctions which, rightly treated, conduce to peace.

He does a service to truth, to human welfare, to the loftiest spiritual interests of men, who helps to mate these opposite hemispheres of the earth into a loving and perpetual union. There is no force so potent as religion, none so priceless. Let it, with all its concomitant treasures of truth as to human origin, evolution, and destiny, suffuse the Western races, as it may if once again it pours from its ancient home in the Orient, and the great transforming energy will make for them a new era, wherein dwelleth righteousness. The teaching of long-gone sages and prophets and Theodidaktoi will sweep through the vacant souls of the twentieth century, and cause upturned eyes and hearts to transcend the glories of physics and of mind. Even these will be enhanced, for no longer only of the earth, earthy, they will shine brighter from their celestial contact. And for such blessings will there be no return? Surely it will come in a broadened sympathy with all truth, a deeper sense of the oneness of humanity, a keener appreciation of each advance in human condition, a larger knowledge of the earthly side of man's evolution, a better perception of the difference between the speculative and the real, a stronger impulse to energetic use of life, an abandonment of pride and selfishness and spiritual isolation and belittling forms. Mind and heart, strength and tenderness, energy and devotion, genius and religion, will then be united. And men, seeing the East and the West hand-in-hand indissolubly, will exclaim with satisfaction, "Those whom God hath joined together, let not man put asunder".

Alexander Fullerton, F.T.S.