(April, June, July, August, September 1896)
Publications:
- Theosophy, vol. XI, no. 1, April 1896, pp. 26-27
- no. 3, June 1896, pp. 88-90
- no. 4, July 1896, pp. 120-122
- no. 5, August 1896, pp. 154-156
- no. 6, September 1896, pp. 188-189
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Хэргроув, Эрнест Темпл - Вопросы и ответы
DATA
Title for references: Hargrove ET - Questions and Answers
Short description: A recurring Q&A column. The April 1896 installment answers questions on the superstition that "advan...
Answered principally by E. T. Hargrove, signed "E. T. H."; one answer in the June installment signed "S. G. P. Coryn."; the July and August installments signed "J. H. F."
26
Questions and Answers.
R. McG.—A very prominent lady member of the then existing Theosophical Society told me two or three years ago, when she was in America, that the reason so many advanced Theosophists smoked tobacco was to "keep off bad influences." These "bad influences" were further defined as elementals. She said that if the Masters were to come and work publicly in the world they "would have to smoke cigars, even though they were with certain Theosophists at the time." I should much like to have Theosophy's opinion in regard to this.
Ans.—Whether this statement should be taken as an evidence of ignorance or of superstitious stupidity, or both, I do not know. It may have been due to something as bad, if not worse: the desire to excuse supposed bad habits, either in oneself or others, by bolstering them up on occult grounds. This is a detestable form of dishonesty, as it degrades that which should be sacred, and true occultism is a sacred thing. If someone happens to be late for a business engagement and in excuse for this pleads that occultism is opposed to "forms" and therefore to punctuality—"tell them they lie." If such a person looks mysterious and implies that he was meditating and was possibly in Samadhi when he should have been keeping his engagements—know that he wasn't. Such tricks cannot be too severely condemned.
When hearing of the above question a scoffing friend inquired as to what hierarchy of celestial beings would be reduced to hookahs, since "advanced Theosophists" apparently monopolized the cigarettes, and "Masters" had to fall back on cigars! All such excuses for smoking are baseless and absurd. The occultist needs no such shams to protect himself from evil influences. Both his sword and his shield are within himself. Think of a "Master" at the mercy of elementals because, forsooth, he had left his cigar-case at home! Such a conception of Masters is simply staggering. People who smoke do so because they like it, be they "advanced Theosophists" or newsboys.
E. T. H.
New Zealand.—Students of Theosophy are constantly urged to study the literature, but are told at the same time that Truth is not to be found in books but only within themselves. If the latter statement be true, what is the good of reading books?
Ans.—Both statements are compatible. Books on Theosophy should be read as an aid to the discovery of truth within oneself. This is not often done, and that is why reading frequently does more harm than good. The secret of helpful reading lies, in my opinion, in right method. A rapid survey of a 27book is helpful as a preliminary, but the real reading only begins when every statement is held in the mind and the mental question is put, "What in my experience tells for or against this statement?" Experience here covers both the inner and the outer life. This method helps to focus all the knowledge previously obtained; gives rise to fresh ideas; classifies thought; explains past events, and prevents a blind acceptance of other peoples' conclusions. In other words, it draws out from the reader some of the truth that is latent in him. Otherwise he learns by rote, and forever remains ignorant of the "heart doctrine," which is the doctrine of experience.
E. T. H.
88 F. A. S.—Is the "E. S. T." any part of the Theosophical Society in America, and does any officer of the "E. S. T." have authority in the management of the exoteric Society?
Ans.—The E. S. T., or so-called Inner Circle, is an organization entirely separate from the T. S. A. There is no official connection whatsoever between the two bodies. Many members of the E. S. T. reside in Europe and are members of the Theosophical Society in Europe. Others are in India and Australasia. No officer of the E. S. T. has any voice in the control of the exoteric Society, merely because he holds such office. The T. S. A. is a self-governing and autonomous body, whose officers are elected at stated intervals by the votes of the Branches represented by their delegates in Convention assembled.
E. T. H.
F. A. S.—What is the E. S. T.; who manages it, and how can I join it?
Ans.—The E. S. T. is a school for the purpose of studying Theosophy in some of its deeper aspects. Its members receive teachings that are not contained in the exoteric writings. But its prime object is to help its members to work for humanity and to teach them to love that work. The E. S. T. is managed by an Outer Head and Council. The present Outer Head is Mrs. K. A. Tingley of New York. Mr. W. Q. Judge preceded her in this office, down to the time of his death. The School was originally founded by Mme. H. P. Blavatsky, who controlled its work during her life though she gave Mr. Judge full authority to act on her behalf in America. If you desire to join it you should address "The Secretary, E. S. T., 144 Madison Avenue, New York City."
E. T. H.
T. R.—What is the exact connection between Freemasonry and the Theosophical Society?
Ans.—There is absolutely no connection between the two, outwardly at least. In order to find the real connection one would have to go far back in history. In the last century, for instance, St. Germain and Cagl89iostro, as messengers from the great Brotherhood, carried on by far the greater part of their work among the Freemasons. They were both members of that fraternity and did much to reform its practices, which at that time had lost their original purity and meaning. That there is a very close link between the Theosophical and Masonic movements is certain, because the object of each is the same—brotherhood. Further, the Freemasons have done much to preserve the symbolism of the ancient Mysteries, though they have not been able to retain the key to their interpretation. In thus preserving the symbols they have indirectly helped forward the second object of the Theosophical Society: to study and investigate modern and ancient religions, philosophies and sciences. I well know the deep but quiet interest that Mr. Judge took in the Freemasons, and also know that he did not act from any sentimental motive, but with a full appreciation of the fact that Masons might, if they would, do much to help forward the Brotherhood of man. Any one who knows a Mason, who is leading a true Masonic life, and who has felt a sufficient interest in the subject to take a high degree, will be aware that such a Mason is a seeker after truth and is well on the way to its attainment.
E. T. H.
P. O. A.—Can one who has been an investigator of Spiritualism and a seeker after truth in other directions, become an Adept in this life?
Ans.—A consideration of the laws which govern adeptship so far as they are known to us should supply a sufficient answer to the question. Adeptship is the result of evolution, of the gradual and toilsome acquirement of experience, and never of sudden creation. We may usefully remember that H. P. B. was at one time an ardent member of the Greek Church and William Q. Judge of the Methodist denomination, and that they were both of them investigators of Spiritualism. It is the love of truth and the unceasing pursuit of truth which hasten evolution and in no way the temporary form which such exertion may assume. Experience must be acquired, not in one direction alone, but in all directions, and where the love of truth is constant and sincere it will not regard any direction as barren or fruitless; it will not be withheld from any investigation, nor will it fear to step from the old ground on to the new as the light ahead grows stronger and brighter. Not the action which is seen, but the motive which is unseen, is ever the help or the hindrance.
S. G. P. Coryn.
Ans.—Confusion arises over such a matter as the above, owing to lack of realization of the difference between brain and soul. The Adept is at no time the brain or body, and it may take the Adept-Ego many years to gain control over his instrument. In the meantime that instrument is trained under the guidance of the inner self by means of the 90outer experiences through which it passes. It may take long to make the wheels and cogs and other parts of a machine, but once in place it only takes a Master's touch to set them all in motion.
E. T. H.
120 I. E.—Will Theosophy please explain more fully the necessity for the Crusade?
Ans.—The necessity for the Crusade is the same as was the necessity for the Theosophical Movement in 1875, and as is the necessity for its continuance to-day. It is the need of humanity; the need for Brotherhood, not only between individuals but between nations; the need for light and hope and some explanation of, and a way to escape from, the awful suffering and degradation existing in this so-called age of enlightenment and civilization. These make the necessity for the Crusade as they made necessary the Theosophical Movement.
The Theosophical Society in America has accomplished much on this continent, so that Theosophy is gaining a hearing on all sides and among all classes. The seed which was planted here by H. P. Blavatsky and W. Q. Judge has sprung up and is bearing fruit. And Theosophy having taken deep root in America, there lies this injunction on us who are 121members of the T. S. A.—not an injunction from any person or body of persons, but from Nature—"Freely ye have received, freely give!"
This year the T. S. A. has attained its majority and has entered upon a new cycle of work and new responsibilities. The attainment of majority, after twenty-one years of life, is not an epoch chosen arbitrarily by man, but marks the beginning of a new cycle in which new forces begin to act and new duties and new relations are entered upon. What is true of an individual is true also of an organized body, and the T. S. A. has now the wider responsibilities and also the greater opportunities that arise from its coming of age. But besides this important epoch in the life and work of the T. S., we are approaching a greater and more important epoch in the life of humanity.
All students of Theosophy know what an important time the end of this century is, and no observer of human events can be unaware of the great tension existing all over the world and of the uncertainty and unrest felt by all nations. Men ask again and again what will be the outcome of it all, when will relief come? There is to-day no Brotherhood between nations, there is indeed very little between individuals. Surely, never was the message of Theosophy more needed in the world than it is to-day.
In America the future of Theosophy and the Theosophical Movement is assured, and the work already accomplished here has made possible this wider undertaking. Humanity needs help, needs light, needs Brotherhood; Theosophy alone can give these, and to the T. S. A. has been given the opportunity and the privilege of carrying the message of Theosophy around the world.
J. H. F.
W. T. P.—I have very little time for study and when I do have time to spare my brain and body are generally so tired that I cannot study effectively, so that it seems impossible to make any progress. What can I do? I want to help others but cannot.
Ans.—Unfortunately the case of the questioner is a very common one. Very few members of the T. S. have time, not merely to study books, but for quiet thought and meditation. It is one of the greatest drawbacks of this age. All is hurry and bustle, everywhere there is the struggle on the one hand for existence and on the other for pleasure and between the two there seems no time left for the deeper, truer life of the soul. This is a general statement of our civilization as a whole, but it should not be forgotten that it is not necessarily true for individuals. Thank heaven it is not, and some of these individuals are to be found among those who have hard work to provide themselves and maybe others with the necessaries of life. If there be such who can live the life of the soul while seemingly in the whirl of the XIXth century, then surely we may be encouraged to at least make the attempt to do likewise.
122 But does the inner life require study, is study necessary if progress is to be made? I should answer, yes! but not necessarily study of books. I do not think that progress is to be attained by the study of books, though such study may be useful and of value. Many are debarred from the study of books but no one is debarred from the study of self. In the early days of the T. S. this advice was given to one of the members:—"Put away your books and think" and certainly not many of us would be losers if we did more thinking and less reading.
The most important study is the study of one's own nature and true progress cannot come save through knowledge of self. We could learn much if we would carefully observe our emotions, tendencies of thought, and personal habits. If, for instance, we would watch our tendencies to anger or to provoke anger in others, watch how a mere word will often excite feelings of vanity or jealousy, we might learn how much depends upon our inner attitude and how much we can help others if we act from the standpoint of brotherliness and kind feeling.
Everyone, no matter what his occupation, can begin this study of himself and can accentuate his personal responsibility and by this means take the first step of true progress. All this too, if done from the right motive will help others. It is not so much in the big things as in the little things that we can help others. A great opportunity lies in the little things of life and the "Parable of the Talents" gives a true picture of the way that Nature rewards those who help others in the little things of life. "Because thou hast been faithful in a few things, I will make thee ruler over many things."
J. H. F.
154 S. F. M.—In Questions and Answers in the July number of Theosophy, mention is made of the end of this century as a very important time. In what respect is this the case?
Ans.—I think this question can best be answered by referring to what H. P. Blavatsky and W. Q. Judge have said on the subject. In one of H. P. B.'s articles, "The Esoteric Character of the Gospels,"[1] occurs the following note:
There are several remarkable cycles that come to a close at the end of this century. First the 5000 years of the Kaliyug Cycle; again the Messianic cycle of the Samaritan (also Kabalistic) Jews of the man connected with Pisces (Ichthys or 'Fishman' Dag). It is a cycle, historic and not very long, but very occult, lasting about 2155 solar years, but having a true significance only when computed by lunar months. It occurred 2410 and 255 B.C., or when the equinox entered into the sign of the Ram, and again into that of Pisces. When it enters, in a few years, the sign of Aquarius, psychologists will have some extra work to do, and the psychic idiosyncrasies of humanity will enter on a great change.
One of the most interesting articles on this subject is "Cycles," by W. Q. Judge.[2] A quotation is there made from the Wisdom of the Egyptians by Synesius, part of which is as follows:
Yet you must not think that the gods are without employment, or that their descent to this earth is perpetual. For they descend according to orderly periods of time, for the purpose of imparting a beneficent impulse in the republics of mankind. But this happens when they harmonize a kingdom and send to this earth for that purpose souls who are allied to themselves. For this providence is divine and most ample, which frequently through one man pays attention to and affects countless multitudes of men.
For there is indeed in the terrestrial abode the sacred tribe of heroes who pay attention to mankind, and who are able to give them assistance even in the smallest concerns. . . . This heroic tribe is, as it were, a colony from the gods established here in order that this terrene abode may not be left destitute of a better nature. But when matter excites her own proper blossoms to war against the soul, the resistance made by these heroic tribes is small when the gods are absent; for everything is strong only in its appropriate place and time. . . . But when the harmony adapted in the beginning by the gods to all terrene things becomes old, they descend again to earth that they may call the harmony forth, ener155gize and resuscitate it when it is as it were expiring. . . . When, however, the whole order of mundane things, greatest and least, is corrupted, then it is necessary that the gods should descend for the purpose of imparting another orderly distribution of things.
Mr. Judge then goes on to say:
These 'heroes' are none other than Nirmanakayas—Adepts of this or previous Manwantaras—who remain here in various states or conditions. Some are not using bodies at all, but keep spirituality alive among men in all parts of the world; and others are actually using bodies in the world. . . .
It is thought by many that the present is a time when preparation is being made by the most advanced of the 'sacred tribe of heroes' for a new cycle in which the assistance of a greater number of progressed souls from other spheres may be gained for mankind. Indeed, in Isis Unveiled, this is plainly stated.
Writing in 1878, Madame Blavatsky says in Vol. I of Isis:
"Unless we mistake the signs, the day is approaching when the world will receive the proofs that only ancient religions were in harmony with nature, and ancient science embraced all that can be known. Secrets long-kept may be revealed; books long-forgotten and arts long-time-lost may be brought out to light again; papyri and parchments of inestimable importance will turn up in the hands of men who pretend to have unrolled them from mummies or stumbled upon them in buried crypts; tablets and pillars, whose sculptured revelations will stagger theologians and confound scientists, may yet be excavated and interpreted. Who knows the possibilities of the future? An era of disenchantment and rebuilding will soon begin—nay, has already begun. The cycle has almost run its course; a new one is about to begin, and the future pages of history may contain full proof that—
'If ancestry can be in aught believed,
Descending spirits have conversed with man,
And told him secrets of the world unknown.'"
Mr. Judge further says:
Why not, then, call one of our present cycles the cycle of the Theosophical Society? It began in 1875, and, aided by other cycles then beginning to run, it has attained some force. Whether it will revolve for any greater length of time depends upon its earnest members. . . .
To my mind the mere fact that we were organized with a definite platform in that year is strong evidence that the 'heroic tribe of heroes' had a hand in our formation. Let us, then, not resist the cycle, nor, complaining of the task, sit down to rest. There is no time for rest. 156The weak, the despairing, and the doubting may have to wait, but men and women of action cannot stand still in the face of such an opportunity. . . .
I would suggest that the questioner read the whole of Mr. Judge's article referred to. Nearly seven years have passed since it was written, and new evidences are continually arising of the truth of what is there stated. In my opinion we have now an opportunity that humanity has not had for centuries, let us "take the current when it serves,"—and that is, Now.
J. H. F.
188 B. R. D.—In a newspaper cutting from England I see that a prominent official of the T. S. in A. has expressed himself on a political question in a way with which I absolutely disagree. As a member of the Society and as one who is trying to be a Theosophist, I should like to know what course I should follow under these circumstances.
Ans.—A brief reply to this question would perhaps be sufficient: go on with your work and do not bother about the matter, one way or the other. The T. S. in America is too strong to be compromised by any or all of its officers. The work of its individual members is what counts in the long run.
A vital principle is, however, involved in this apparently innocent question. It could be pointed out that (a) no newspaper report should be blindly accepted, (b) no officer of the T. S. in A. would be likely to commit himself on matters political; it could be added (c) that no officer has done so or proposes to do so. But the principle strikes deeper. It is the same principle as that for which W. Q. Judge fought and on behalf of which he won so great a victory. He fought for the freedom of our platform, claiming that every member of the Society, from the newest to the oldest, and from the most inactive to the most prominent and possibly hard-working officials, had an equal right to express any opinion on any subject, so long as that opinion was not opposed to universal Brotherhood and was expressed tolerantly. He constantly expressed a belief in the elder Brothers of the race and in the wisdom of H. P. Blavatsky, speaking as a member and not as an officer, and in no way compromised the Society which he so honorably represented. Other members were free to agree or disagree with him as they chose.
On the same principle it would be perfectly legitimate for an officer of the Society to avow himself an Anarchist, Socialist, Democrat or Republican, so long as he did not attempt to involve the Society in such beliefs. He could label himself to any extent, as Christian or Buddhist, anti-vivisector, Second Adventist and so forth, always on the understanding that in these capacities he was acting unofficially and as a private member.
The remedy would be to vote for some one else when his term of office expired, if in your opinion his "label" interfered with the performance of his official duties; and in the meantime to go on serenely and energetically spreading an understanding of true Theosophy.
E. T. H.
189 P. W. S.—I have been asked to write an article for a Theosophical magazine. Can you give me any assistance or advice as to how I should proceed?
Ans.—You will have to adapt yourself to the magazine to which you have been asked to contribute. Some require longer articles than others. But generally speaking brevity should be your first aim. Select some subject that naturally interests you; look up references to it in our literature and in any other books within your reach until your mind becomes thoroughly familiar with the different aspects of the matter.
Having done this, lay aside all your books and meditate on the ideas brought out by your reading, comparing them with those you originally entertained. Then without further reference to books proceed to write your article. Before sending it in, cut out every unnecessary paragraph, sentence and word, and remember that unless you want the editor to rewrite it for you, your "copy" should be fit to pass directly into the hands of the printer—that is to say it should be properly paragraphed, punctuated and so forth.
Avoid long quotations, especially those that are well known; avoid foreign terms, repetition and all conclusions not independently arrived at by yourself. Try to be clear, concise and helpful to at least some one person. You should then write a good article.
E. T. H.
Footnotes