(March 1896)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. X, no. 12, March 1896, pp. 372-379
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Хэргроув, Эрнест Темпл - Искусство быть братом
DATA
Title for references: Hargrove ET - The Art of Being Brotherly
Short description: Argues that brotherhood is an art requiring long, patient study and practice, not a matter of emotio...
"To be continued."
The Art of Being Brotherly.
What have we here: The art of being brotherly—as if true brotherhood could coexist with art. So some may comment, but let us first pause. Could not art be defined as the expression of a mental conception or ideal in concrete form? If that be the case, he who has permitted brotherhood to remain as conception in the world of mind without expressing it concretely would do well to study this greatest of all the arts. It may be said that only an artist should write about art, for as Ruskin wrote, "In art, you must not talk before you do." And few of us indeed can claim to be artists in this respect. But it will be remembered that he added, "In literature, you must not talk before you think;" so here at least we have an opening, since most of us must have given this great conception of Brotherhood thoughts without number. But right thought? That is the question. Have we merely considered how we could most attractively talk about this art, or have we considered how we ourselves may best become artists and practitioners?
The first real step in the study of any art lies in realizing its 374difficulties. A young musician would fain begin with some dashing movement far beyond his power of expression, and only by degrees does he discover that years of labor and of failure, of constant practice both of mind and body, will be required of him before he can become a Maestro. To sit down and "feel musical" might soften his brain in time, but would produce no other evident result. Yet there are still some who appear to believe that it is all-sufficient to "feel brotherly," and that this is the doctrine of the heart. Ye Sages and Adepts and Warrior Kings—did you attain to greatness, did ye become Masters in the art of Brotherhood through "creeping up the spine" and sighs and the gush of maudlin emotion? Did you slobber over each other and hug to yourselves the thought that this was brotherhood indeed, so moving, so uplifting, so genuinely heartfelt? Heaven forbid, for then you were but poor slaves of mud and other matter, and history has lied. "To do the deed and abide it," to worship, not Pan with his hoofs in the air, but that red planet:
The star of the unconquered will,
That rises in thy breast,
Serene, and resolute, and still,
And calm, and self-possessed,
this surely was nearer thy method of practice than that other!
Of little use is history if it does not teach us as the record of our own experiences in the past. Even aside from the doctrine of rebirth it should be clear that man changes but imperceptibly in the race of centuries and that history repeats itself always; heroism, love and hate, ambition,—none of these died when Rome died. They live in our very midst to-day. See then what history can teach us as to this exciting thrill of brotherly feeling; see if it is sufficient in itself; if it is of any permanent value. Go back to France some hundred years ago and behold men echoing the gospel of friend Rousseau's Contrat Social and many other kindred gospels (some of gush), each theorizing as to how each man could mend the whole world's wickedness—his own was another matter; each talking glibly of Theories and Names, especially of this theory and name of Brotherhood. Believe me, lectures were given and many parlor-talks; pamphlets were circulated to such extent that with rich and poor this charming theory bordered on the fashionable. (It is about the time that certain Tea found an unexpected resting place in Boston harbor.) Later on, some people getting hungry, they storm and take the Bastile with much noise and clamour. A mere riot it is thought, though heads are paraded on pikes. This is the July of 1789.
375But theories of brotherhood continue to spread, till they force themselves on the King, a good man, though lacking in martial qualities. Despotism must give way to constitution-building: in a new Constitution we may find salvation and a perfect expression of brotherhood. Behold we swear it, the entire nation swears it, the King swears it. Do not mothers swear their children, and cities, from Etoile onwards, their inhabitants? Such a swearing was never seen: an oath of universal Federation with all brothers, irrespective of race or creed, to King (Restorer of French liberty), to Law, to Nation. And did not every man, woman and child in Paris help erect this huge amphitheatre in the Champ-de-Mars, where the central swearing of all was consummated in face of many difficulties? Here at last we have the golden age and brotherhood made real! Louis said afterwards that this day was the brightest of his life; did not all men feel to the marrow of their bones the thrill of brotherhood? Giant Mirabeau, with an eye to the future and a knowledge of man, may not have felt so sure, but what of him when all France swears? And Mirabeau is soon to die.
So the first Feast of Pikes becomes history, and July the 14th, 1790, becomes a memory of the past. For the sun will not stand still; nor any part of nature, and man the least of all. There comes inevitable reaction: the inspiring sentiment of brotherhood turns to sentiment of another kind, and a year and three days later we see volley after volley being fired by swearer Mayor Bailly and his swearing troops on thousands of other swearers, gathered together on this same Champ-de-Mars to sign a petition for the deposition of Chief-swearer, the Restorer of French liberty, Louis the King. Then in July, 1792, arrive the 600 Marseillese "who know how to die:" in August we witness the sack of the Tuileries: in September the massacre of imprisoned Royalists, and in January, 1793, the guillotining of Louis. Now is Brotherhood bawled through the streets and sisterhood shrieked. Next the protests of a certain Twenty-two and their guillotining in October as too moderate in their brotherhood: then others by hundreds travel the same road, so that in April, 1794, even strong man Danton becomes a danger to brotherhood and must die with the rest, staunch revolutionist that he is—though not "brotherly" enough since the "sea green Incorruptible" and unutterable Robespierre has become the High Priest of Reason.
At last comes further reaction; November brings Robespierre's day of doom, but the whole nation, weltering in blood, racked with hunger, imprisoned by foreign foes, forms itself into 376a "Committee of Mercy"—for some days. Revolutionists have yet to be punished; reactionary "Companies of Jesus" must assassinate these unruly Jacobins (who did the work); Madame Tallien must air herself in transparent drapery as the fair efflorescence of the Revolution: until Napoleon, the man of destiny, appears upon the scene to show what one man can do with millions.
Mirabeau, Louis, Danton, Robespierre, each in turn hailed as the Saviours of France, and within three years each one of them, living or dead, execrated and with one exception guillotined by an infuriated nation—all in the sacred cause of Brotherhood. The history of an emotion, with some consequences and conclusions; an emotion that originated in a drawing-room theory, in parlor-talks, and in the circulation of polite pamphlets. But the art of being brotherly had not been mastered.
And the moral? Have I held my Feast of Pikes; have I taken part in an uprising of September; have I ever rushed from a brotherhood of gush to a brotherhood of fear and hate; have I ever turned on those whom I once clasped to my bosom to feel inexpressible guillotines against them within a year or so?—let each one answer these questions within himself, where no ear may hear, and whatever answer may be given at that judgment bar, let us leave it with the deep conviction that emotion is not sufficient, nor a blind expression of that emotion, but that here we have an art that must be studied with profoundest thought and utmost patient practice if we would avoid the fate of him who so ardently "feels musical" and gets softening of the brain. We have seen men swear a solemn oath of Brotherhood, in all sincerity, but, poor human beings, what right had they to swear when they could not control themselves in the swearing? Yet they too had their ideal; they too strove to make it real—and were themselves sufficient wall of stone against the end they had in view. You write this man as "Beloved Brother," feeling that all you write is a statement of changeless sentiment; you write some other friend as "Beloved Sister" (and by God's light call that spade by its name if thou claimest the title of man and wouldst not stick thy head in a sandy desert of death)—you call her this and that and feel so brotherly that clearly you must be verging on at least the fringe of adeptship in this noble art; but if you should change, or they should slander you or be unfair, or favor some other more, what then? You would probably become the plaything of your own reaction then, for an iron will, a penetrating understanding of the human mind and heart (your own 377especially), and a mighty purpose, have all to be obtained before brotherhood can be rightly felt and properly preserved.
Now as to the foundations of the path to be made and traversed. Our philosophy teaches us that unity underlies all things; that mankind is essentially one. There is no separateness anywhere in nature. Studying man on the outer and most differentiated plane of matter, physiology states that we exchange the atoms of our bodies, so that a king may absorb them from a pauper's hunger-worn carcase. Theosophy takes us many steps further, showing that humanity interchanges magnetism and thought. In the rage or rejoicing of a nation, become one for a time in thrill of sentiment, you will learn again that average man is but an echo of his fellows; that there is no separateness anywhere. Then in considering reincarnation we find that all men journey on the same pilgrimage, through virtue and vice, sorrow and joy, hope and despair. This fact of essential unity has been forgotten, however, for at the beginning of this period of evolution diversity sprang from unity, giving birth to space and time and all other differences as it passed from the simple to the more and more complex. Differentiation was necessary; not for ever, because following that outbreathing of the one into the many there comes a turning-point when reaction sets in and the many slowly journey homewards. Throughout it all that great unity has remained in itself unchanged and unchangeable, except in appearance—an appearance which is real enough to the beholder.
The human race has passed the turning-point in its career and should now be wending towards the place from which it came, towards Unity. This journey, called by some the process of involution, is made by gradual self-realization, or the realization in consciousness (complete and therefore manifest in action) that the self of all is One.
The first and most necessary step in mastering the art of being brotherly consists in an understanding of this philosophy. Only thus can we realize in consciousness and so express in harmony of action the unity of all things. But what is there, it may be asked, to prevent our instant realization of this fact, if it be a fact? It is matter in the widest sense of the term; that matter in and through which consciousness has manifested for æons, by which it is confined when manifesting. And matter exists in countless invisible states as well as in those we call solid, liquid, vaporous, gaseous, and etheric. This matter, especially in its denser states, can now manifest through itself scarce any other 378idea but one of separateness, as the result of long processes of differentiation. As all that has been said in regard to mankind as a whole applies equally to the individual, we shall begin to understand why it is that a clear realization of unity, with corresponding recognition in action, is so difficult to achieve. The innermost man knows that the only reality is Unity; the outermost man does not believe it and refuses to recognize it; the midmost man may believe it without knowing it and is ready to feel at one with whatever attracts him, but is equally ready to feel separate from whatever repels. Our midmost man is as material in his way as is the outermost. He indulges freely in maudlin brotherhood, rejoicing to be so wise. But he lives in lower nature where the "pairs of opposites" reign supreme. He moves by attraction and repulsion; he is the creature of extremes. He will perhaps so bubble over with "spirituality" that he must instantly rush out to save this sinful world, though a wife and family be left behind to starve. He was the loudest swearer at our Feast of Pikes. It was he who dropped the less fraternal vous for the more familiar tu; he it was who forgot the words Monsieur and Madame and replaced them with citoyen and citoyenne: particularly anxious was he later on to call Louis XVI "Citoyen Capet." Was it not he who bellowed himself hoarse with delight at the victory gained for brotherhood when Citoyen Capet's head had fallen? Our midmost man is the plaything of reaction.
Newton's third law of motion is that "action and reaction are always equal and contrary;" we know this to be true in all departments of nature, and emotion is no exception to the rule. It is a scientific statement of the doctrine of the pairs of opposites. But must every effort towards brotherhood be followed by reaction? Inevitably, except on one condition; a difficult condition which cannot be fulfilled without long study and practice. This condition is that we cease to identify ourselves with either the action or reaction. The innermost man is superior to either mode of force. He is that apex of the triangle of life which is equally removed from either extreme of the base. We are that innermost man, who is elsewhere called Wisdom. It is possible for us to become one with him in consciousness, but before that is attained we may realize that both action and reaction are taking place in the lower energies (gunas) of nature, and that in essence we remain unmoved. There are some who seem to imagine they can cut loose from reaction, while still tenaciously identifying themselves with the original movement. They refuse to think that these fine sentiments do not in some way reflect honor on 379themselves; for the midmost man is tenacious of the spoils of war. Are they not sacrificing themselves; do they not deserve some self-congratulation—failing congratulation from others? And these efforts: surely they are making them, surely these whirlpools of brotherly love cannot arise from lower nature! But it is so, and only by recognizing that both the action and reaction take place in material nature, which includes the midmost man, and by removing the sense of identity to the innermost man who is superior to either pole of activity, can we become true artists in true brotherliness. This reversal of ordinary methods of thought cannot be accomplished in a day. Time is needed, and meanwhile there are many aids to practice, certain rules and laws to be observed: which will be considered in the continuation of this study.
E. T. Hargrove.
(To be continued.)