(July 1896)
Publications:
- Theosophy, vol. XI, no. 4, July 1896, pp. 116-120
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Джонстон, Вера Владимировна - Доброта - чёрная магия?
DATA
Title for references: Johnston V - Kindness Black Magic
Short description: Argues, from the saying that "kindness to preferred men is one form of black magic," that habit and ...
116
Kindness—Black Magic?
"The Great Ones," I recently read in an article by a valued friend, "say that kindness to preferred men is one form of black magic." No doubt it is so. Moreover, the same can be said in regard to countries, creeds, and races; and we only too often overlook the fact.
Habit, unreasoned custom, crystallization of any sort, are black magic. For all these tie down the activities of our mind to this place, or to that form of thought, to this family, or that school of science, blinding us to the true aspects of everything and everybody else. Theosophists especially ought constantly to be on the look out for this danger, otherwise they might only exchange string for wire, in their endeavors to free their minds from the fetters which have belittled their life of thought and feeling only too long.
For, indeed, what black magic could be more fatal and pernicious than that by which our soul's life is prevented from seeking its own level in the regions above petty—petty when seen from this height—divisions into nations, communities, and religions, in the regions whence the only true "brotherhood of humanity" takes its source and vitality.
Mark Twain, in insisting that it is "much better to say 'doncher,' instead of 'don't you,'" offers a very good illustration of the case. "In what way is it better, and is it better at all? Why, certainly! Don't you know that the one is American and the other English?" However, being what he really is, and what I, for one, always maintain him to be, that is, a true philosopher in disguise, the great American laughter-manufacturer is not taken in by his own argument. But in this world there exist crowds of people who are; in fact, who spend their lifetimes under the dominion of arguments of about the same force and justice, and are proud of it.
Instead of trying to get round and, finally, to get rid of, the sharp angles of our national and tribal bringing up, we always are only too ready to accentuate the difference, being in most cases quite sincere in our belief that our ways of doing our hair or using our knives and forks are "much better" than our neighbours.
117 Have we not all known French people, who were born, have lived, and are going to die, under the delusion that, "thirty miles from Paris—the end of the world, my dear!"
Have I not quite recently met a most kindhearted English lady, who said: "Mary is going out to Russia as governess, poor girl. Never to see any fresh English faces; always those Russians around her. Horrible! Is it not?"
Has not a Russian author, a high-minded and large-hearted man otherwise, written in perfect good faith: "English stomachs and English hearts are tinned inside. Any man would have staggered under this blow, but Mr. X. was English." As if that made all the difference in the world.
Millions and millions of Russians think that "Germans are born sort of silly," and take great pride in speaking of the rest of Europe as "that putrid West." But then, as a sort of compensation, there never as yet lived a German, whether Austrian or Prussian, who was not profoundly, sacredly convinced that Russians, every single man of them, are a thievish, lazy, lying, drunken, good-for-nothing lot, and that, were Kaiser Wilhelm to turn his watchful eye away from them, they would soon enough reduce to utter ruin and desolation the flourishing industries and thriving cities of the only real civilized Uebermensch, who certainly is not French, nor English, either, but German.
Americans look down on Europeans, Europeans look down on Americans. And so is kept up the balance of the world's politics, the world's peace and the world's good-will.
All these are instances of national vanity, prejudice and narrow mindedness and as such certainly are manifestations of the only truly formidable black magic, the name of which, harmless enough at first sight, is—crystallization of the human mind.
Kindness to preferred men and objects only, when manifested in individuals, is still more of a partiality,—from pars, division, otherwise allied the heresy of separateness—and is still more dangerous to the health of the soul. Individual character and gifts, individual work and effort, can change the course of the great half blind power, which theosophical slang is in the habit of calling, national Karma, whereas national Karma acts on the individual but indirectly and weakly.
All the small children in Russia know and take a roguish delight in the story of the sly step-mother. This step-mother baked two cakes and gave one to each of her two step-sons, remarking: "See how I love you; my own little girl has no cake at all. But if you are good boys, each of you will give her half a cake." In spite of its apparent frivolity, this story goes well to show what black magic, real practical working black magic can do, and does every day of our lives in our own families and 118hearts. And let it be remembered that this sort of black magic wants no magic circles, no blood of black hens and goats, and is only the more active for it.
But here we must stop and point out that all the above written, though true, is only relatively so. The absolutely true and the absolutely false do not exist in this world of ours; and people who think that they do always run the risk of destroying their future bread by pulling too zealously at the weeds.
Kindness to preferred persons is so very near affection for certain persons only. And the term affection, in its turn, infringes almost on the term love. The differences between the three really are so gradual as to be almost imperceptible. And so the disapproval that one of the Great Ones has shown towards "kindness for preferred persons only,"—that is condemnable partiality,—may possibly be mistaken for approval of the false, quasi-ascetic theory about the road to salvation lying through freedom from earthly ties, such as weakness, affection or even duty towards any of our fellow mortals.
We knew a man, and a very good man to all visible purposes, who was an enthusiastic lover of everything good and true, who generously and readily spent lots of money on theosophy and theosophists, who was to become a Chela—it was some time ago and the word was not tending as yet to become obsolete—and who, in short, to find Truth would willingly travel to Thibet and to many other places besides, if need be. However, after a few years' absence, with true sadness, I must own, for he was one of the preferred men on whom we were wont to work our black magic, we found him lost to our friendship. He had found out "things" about H. P. B. and was spreading the news freely and even zealously, outside; inside he was turned to bitterness and wrath. The small latent germ of sour leaven, we had always been aware of in his nature, had begun to work and soon all his stock of "the milk of human kindness" was embittered to the entire change of his tastes, habits and inclinations. And commenting on this particular sleight of hand trick of the great magician and juggler, "Self-Righteousness," I often think that it all was owing to the mistaken notion he had about Buddha preaching the doctrine of the righteous man walking alone in this world like the rhinoceros. I italicise these words, as they were the last I ever heard from this lost friend.
Patriotism and asceticism are both high sounding words, and what is more, they actually are high virtues, as indispensable to the interior economy of national and social life as cement and carbolic acid are indispensable in every well-regulated household. But as soon as they are practiced, the one to the extent of continual disharmony with the genius of every other nation, and the other to the extent of shrinking from the 119bondage of every human feeling, they stop being virtues and become vices, though still bearing the high sounding names of patriotism and asceticism, and still making us proud to be their virtuous possessors and practicers.
And yet when they reach that stage, both patriotism and asceticism ought to be translated self-love. Self-love makes us hate going outside the enchanted circle of a host of people, who all have our defects, who all, more or less, reflect our own ridicules and prejudices, who all cook their eggs and do their hair in just the same way as ourselves. It is self-love, again, that forces a man to shrink from affection, which is only another word for duty and responsibility. One can easily see that it must be unpleasant for an ascetic, with high ideals and purposes, to see the weakness of his own mind made manifest by his too readily complying with the views of an erring friend, or his giving way to the whims and fancies of a sick wife.
Better not have any friends at all, than risk the discovery that you can't hold your own against them. Alas, lack of gentle firmness and perseverance is to be met with even amongst rhinoceroses, though they do walk alone, if we are to believe Buddha.
Seriously, I am very sorry to say, that, to my certain knowledge, the lost friend referred to above is not the only one to hold very erroneous views on asceticism. And a shock it really was, when I was given to understand the other day, that the words of one of the Great Ones about kindness to preferred men implied the doctrine of the "solitary-walking rhinoceros." However, I now recognize my mistake and know that His words mean nothing of the kind. But it took me some time to see that the fault was entirely my own, most of which time was spent sleeplessly in the small hours of the night. Hence this article.
Let my example remain solitary in this particular instance. Let all just men and women forever abstain from this insult to the wisdom and kindness of the truly Great Ones. Even merely mortal people when "firmly set on seeking the Eternal," know that our truth and our virtues are only relative, that even our truest love is doomed, for long ages as yet, to contain a certain percentage at least of sometimes criminal weakness and partiality.
But, all the same, God is still love. And whether we call it the Supreme, the Eternal, or the Unknowable, this Great Abyss of light, truth and bliss will always be attainable to human beings striving to understand it in four different ways: Philosophy, when met with the discursive part of our reasoning; Mysticism, when conceived of with the help of our imaginations; Faith, when arrived at through the intuitional capacity of our minds; and, Love, the greatest of all, when won with its own weapon, the very spirit of our spiritual natures, the 120mysterious inner voice which speaks to us of the original and final oneness of all.
But "the truth we see is relative," and so is our love. Expanding from one life's experience into another, growing in scope and quality, it expands also our personal natures, making us truer and giving us more light. And life shall never stop its ministerings until there truly is but one flock and one shepherd, until we love all things and all men with a purer and firmer fervor, than that we, at present, can give only to our clearest and nearest.
This time is still far from being reached. Partial lights are our lot as yet, partial truth, and partial love.
But all the same, the mother who is ever ready to give her life for only her own children, or the soldier who is always prepared to die for only his own country, sets a great power working. The name of this power is love, and it is woven of light, truth and future bliss, although it as yet so often resembles torture.
Our love for preferred men or even only for the ideas we have formed of these men, however erroneous the ideas might be, is right and good if we love self-forgetfully, if this love helps us to dispel the "black magic of self."
And, I suppose, true love is the only kind of "white magic" we are capable of practicing, so far.
Vera Johnston.