Neresheimer EA - Theosophy and Modern Social Problems

From Teopedia
Books • Articles • Stories • Letters • All works
⇐ • ⇒
Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Theosophy and Modern Social Problems

William Quan Judge

(January 1896)

Surveys the age's unsolved social problems — the inequality of wealth, the failure of labor-saving machinery to lighten toil, the insecurity of commercial institutions, and the one-sidedness of Christianity, Socialism, Anarchism and Nationalism as remedies — and argues that only Theosophy's teaching of the universality of law and of karma, applied through a scientific basis for ethics, can carry social reform to its root.

Publications:

Read:

CTD entry in Russian: Нересхаймер, Э. Август - Теософия и современные общественные проблемы

DATA

Title for references: Neresheimer EA - Theosophy and Modern Social Problems
Short description: Surveys the age's unsolved social problems — the inequality of wealth, the failure of labor-saving m...

William Quan Judge

Theosophy and Modern Social Problems

Read before the Aryan T.S., April 1894.

307

Theosophy and Modern Social Problems.

[1]

We are in an age of industrialism and individual self-assertiveness, and many are the problems that confront us for solution. Questions of Religion, Philosophy, Politics, Capital, Property, Labor, Marriage, Administration of human-308made law, social life, all these are subjects of interest in the interchange between man and man, which might engage the attention of the thoughtful; but in the contest of emulation and in the absence of willingness to submit individual interests to the social body, serious consideration is not given to these important matters.

The question most difficult of solution appears to be that relating to the inequalities of possessions. Wealth and poverty are the crudest of opposites we meet with in our social life; they press forward most unrelentingly, hence they claim so much of our attention. In the active rush for personal advantage it is hardly ever considered that there is no need for such maddening display of energy, for mother nature provides abundantly for all; no want of food or clothing needs to exist, but for proper interchange of effort, the artificial desires that have grown out of the tendencies in our civilization and the waste which is consequent thereupon prevent a large number of people from enjoying their proper share of the natural gifts.

Those who have the advantage by way of intellect and energy over others not so endowed are largely addicted to and use their efforts for self-interest, without consideration for others.

Much pleasure may be gotten from efforts used in this wise, but less satisfaction is derived from it than is generally supposed. No sooner than material prosperity is obtained, that is, when the point is reached which was supposed at the start to completely fill one's horizon of wants, the point will be found to have travelled onward in the ratio of one's acquisitions or faster; the bountiful possession, once so coveted, is considered a small possession, too much to starve but too little to live, more is wanted. I have seen men reach out with great strides for wealth, have seen them get it after expenditure of unremitting effort worthy of a better object, and after they had it, they wanted either more or something else, fame, society, culture, anything that was supposed to give them satisfaction. Wealth never gave it them in the measure that they expected. They found after all that it did not increase their inner worth or self-respect, nor did it make them one whit happier or wiser.

The contest for possessions is general and very fierce, but few succeed, and the proportion of those who do not succeed is alarming. The distribution of wealth in this country according to a recent account is about as follows: 31,000 men are reputed to possess one half of the wealth upon which sixty-five millions of persons depend for existence, and the greater part of the other 309half is owned by a small additional fraction of the population, leaving the vast numerical majority of the nation without any considerable stake in the country. This proportion of accumulation into few hands will grow more from year to year, owing to the ways now in vogue and the great success of organized capital, trusts and corporations. Needless to say that this will produce dissatisfaction among the less favored majority.

Another feature in this age of material industrial development is the progress that has been made in inventions which produced the labor-saving machines. Much was expected from this progress: it was supposed that in course of time it would result in making life easy, comfortable and happy, but this has not so happened. Through the great number of machines now in use a much larger quantity of goods is produced than could have been made by hand; but with all the improvements they have not reduced the work of men, on the contrary, we all have to work more now than ever, the merchant, agriculturist, artisan, mechanic and laborer. Our wants have increased with the cheapening of products far beyond the producing and cheapening capacity of the machines. The hours for daily labor have been reduced somewhat, compelled by strikes and workingmen's agitations, but now in place of that the undivided attention of every worker is required feeding the machines; he has to slave and scrape worse than ever to eke out an existence for himself. This state of things has not yet reached its climax, and ere the folly of such endeavor is seen it has to grow much worse.

An examination into the affairs of commercial and financial institutions gives us neither a very high estimate of real progress and stability in that direction. Disturbances like the panic of 1893 which overtake us every once in a while remind us forcibly of the insecurity of even these attractive and respectable looking ventures. Recently within a period of eight months one sixth of the entire railroad enterprise of this country went into bankruptcy, involving the sum of $1,750,000,000. Bank failures aggregated in the amount of $500,000,000. The whole commercial community was shaken to the core, the flimsiness of foundation of our industrial concerns was disclosed; the most widespread distress prevailed among the working classes, 6,000,000 of workmen, in round numbers, were out of work. This large number of unemployed represents one tenth of the entire population of the U.S. and a much larger proportion among the working classes themselves. When such disasters as these can take place over night it is quite certain that our civilization is not founded upon 310a very secure basis: in cold fact, the present methods do not afford the happiness to human beings all around that might be expected from so much expenditure of energy. Even in the very best of times (so called) there is always discontent, particularly among the lower classes, always a chronic state of the want of employment, strikes and strife, suicides, murder, immorality, cheating and criminality.

Comparison of the prevalence of crime among western people and the natives in a country which has not yet been totally devoured by the monster of our sham civilization, shows very unfavorably for the Westerns. Statistics furnished by a Roman Catholic organ in 1888 regarding the proportions of criminality of the several classes in India states these facts:

Europeans register one criminal in every 274 persons.

Eurasians           509 persons.

Native Christians         799 persons.

Mohametans           856 persons.

Hindoos           1361 persons.

Buddhists           3787 persons.

The last item is a magnificent tribute to Buddhism, and it shows furthermore that a simpler mode of life is productive among the people of obedience to law and social regulations.

Now as to the remedies that have been suggested by various systems and reform organizations for the alleviation of social evils, what do we see? Much well-meaning efforts, but only small results. Christianity and Socialism, Anarchism, Nationalism and many other societies and corporations; most all of them have some practical value and succeed in ameliorating and palliating evils to some extent, but not one of them appears to reach to the root.

Christianity, whose ethics are matchless for beauty and truth, can never succeed to stay the tendencies of perverse human nature. Its ethics alone without a basis for them in philosophy do not touch the intellect. Man's moral nature is not yet sufficiently developed so that he could rely on his ethical impulses solely—this age being moreover an intellectual one—the system of Christianity does not reach around to encompass the human being in its entirety.

In one way or another some one-sidedness or insufficiency of philosophical basis is the shortcoming of most all reformatory movements except Theosophy, whose doctrines take cognizance alike of all the composite qualities and states of man, latent or active, from the spiritual down through the psychic, the mental, the moral, the intellectual, to the physical.

311Socialism is a theory of reform whose ethics are nearly identical with those of Christianity, and it contemplates an entire reconstruction of society by a more equitable and just distribution of property and labor. But this is merely mechanical. The incipient lofty concept of Socialism however has already deteriorated to revolutionary materialism; some of its advocates, under the guise of high moral doctrine, have more in view the equal distribution of wealth than the equal distribution of labor, and through its vulgar exponents the intention has been sounded that reforms may be accomplished by violence. This latter however can never be, that is, reform would not be established in that way. No sooner than riot and revolution would have levelled present conditions to an equality, and things began to assume to right themselves on a new basis, those who were possessed of the greater energy and intelligence would, by reason of their unchanged nature and abilities, go on as they did before; they would soon usurp the mastery again, and during the loose state of law administration then ensuing, they would have more power than before. On the other hand, if those who had never had a chance before did succeed, they would also use their power as much as they could for their own ends. Human nature is selfish at this present time. There is no use denying it, and so long as man is known not to be content without desiring his neighbor's possessions, the time for equal distribution of property has not come. Any reform therefore to be far reaching and lasting must take cognizance of man's composite qualities and then elect a way to change them, out of which may grow a desirable change of conditions. This, socialism, as at present outlined, does not do.

Anarchism is another one-sided device which promises the ideal perfection by simply turning things upside down. The pure doctrine of anarchy, that men may rule themselves without restrictions of law or organized government—though true and a state of existence very much to be desired—presupposes again a condition of human advancement in toto, which is unthinkable without complete transformation of our moral nature. Nationalism, the latest society-regenerating invention, proposes to provide happiness for all human beings by the administration by government of our industrial enterprises, without taking into account the questions and problems of unfit human nature. These makeshifts do not go to the bottom of the trouble, as we can readily see. What conclusions do we reach then by applying theosophical concepts with a view to a solution of social problems?

312We have to ask first, have we anything new to teach? The answer is no! Our teachings and lessons are derived from the book of nature. While we recognize that this civilization has furnished us with the greatest amount of material comfort, which in the estimation of many people is quite worth the having, it is also certain that it has not furnished us with the desired advancement and happiness for all, and that the expenditure of energy in the direction of industrialism alone must be abandoned, but—what is to be substituted? The innate activity of the human mind compels something equally fascinating; nothing short of an ideal that fills man's nature to the full may be expected to have any degree of success whatsoever. If a return to a life of greater simplicity is to be accomplished, it must be enriched with nobler aspirations, with opportunities for the display of energy for a more desirable purpose. An ideal other than wealth and material comfort even greater than arts and sciences must be furnished to attract the human mind, and this will be found in nothing short of the knowledge of man's intimate connection with the whole cosmos, the capability of realization of the possibility of infinite unfoldment of his own spiritual nature. In this particular the Theosophical movement has a definite mission by the promulgation of the ideas and tenets of the Esoteric Philosophy, which ideas go to the very root of life-problems.

The fundamental tenet of Theosophy, that unity underlies all manifestation, that harmony and equilibrium may be obtained by making the unit subservient to the whole, is founded on natural law and brings home once again the ideal of Brotherhood to humanity, this time accompanied by elucidations of facts and data from the elder Brothers of the race who are far in advance of us on the Path towards its realization. Within the ranks of the Theosophical movement is to be formed the nucleus for such union on the human plane, no matter how small, following the steps indicated by the elder Brothers; the philosophy of service and renunciation is to be learned following but nature's own laws. All organization and cooperation means giving up of individual interests. The proper comprehension of this principle and its universal application will provide a scientific basis for ethics, giving impulse to useful action, recognition and performance of one's own proper duties; that accomplished, problems solve themselves.

All nature thrills with the impulse of unfoldment to higher type, beauty and perfection, and so does man. With the awakening of self-consciousness man naturally falls to imitations, selects his model from what to him is his present ideal.

313Observe the serving class, how they try to ape their masters, the merchant to attain to unimpeachable integrity, the soldier, the statesman to exercise valor, diplomacy, prowess and heroism, the professional man, the philosopher to realize the sublime, dwell in abstract thought and flights of metaphysics; always the same aspirations towards an ideal state.

Each serves again in turn as model for those below him. From the highest in point of intellect emanate the influences that touch class after class down to the very last. In this way the doctors of materialism have swayed the thoughts of the masses for the last fifty years. Even the eastern countries have not escaped the fascinating glitter of intellectualism, obscuring for the time being the sublimer tendencies of these people. Through intellectualism we have gradually broken away from the science of duty and humanitarianism.

If the influence of the example of those in high station percolates down into such wide ramifications, how important then is the line of conduct of everyone who occupies a position superior to another.

The imaginary standard of our notion of justice is also largely responsible for social evils; the policy of resistance is entirely out of accord with the ideal conception of cosmos and universality of law.

The policy of non-resistance inculcated by the doctrine of anarchism is much to be desired. In this respect it is like that of Theosophy, but presupposes a much greater state of perfection of humanity and a belief in a law of justice, retribution and karma. Society assumes a duty by exercising authority for punishment which is not strictly its own.

It is either a truth or an untruth that rigid justice rules the world, and if it be a truth, what need then of human agency for administering punishment? Let us have our minds at ease about this, every offender will find his limits soon enough, no one can disturb the harmony by the slightest wrong doing, but he will get ample pay from the law, though this law even be not of human make.

So far this race is gaining by experience slowly. By hard knocks it has to find the limits of this law; through pain and suffering all along the wearisome journey it will learn that which much more quickly the race might acquire through philosophy.

A general acceptance of the doctrine of karma, which is after all only natural law, will bring humanity to the state where it will recognize its own best interests. Neither talk nor promises, 314negation nor even religions with purest ethics, nor isolated benevolent institutions will avail so long as they are not founded on philosophy which teaches the unity of man with the cosmos.

Theosophical doctrine insists on a scientific basis of the practice of ethics. Incontrovertible evidence is adduced from the laboratory of nature to show the ideal foundations of cosmos and man, the universality of law, the absolute necessity for the cooperation of particles without which no organization could be sustained, and the deductions from these premises are the remedies sought to be applied for the solution of all problems, individual as well as social. The lesson to be learned from the small lives, the microbes in our body, is directly applicable. Each cell has its particular function, on the practice of altruism by these lives depend our health, our growth, our life. As long as the cooperation goes on in unison, harmony is maintained; when they run riot against their appointed work there is disturbance. It is the same with the great body of humanity, in which each man is a unit; and in the exercise of his will, whether he functions for good or for ill, so will he establish harmony or the reverse in the sphere in which he lives. If we look for further connection of units in the book of nature we find it even in gross matter. It is well known that matter in its essence is indestructible; the whole mass is in a constant state of transformation. From this it follows that the stuff that has been used by our forefathers is now used by us and will again be used by our descendants, the whole of it being incessantly worked over and over again, bearing its impress of the last experience on its journey through its evolution. There is thus a substantial communion, in which every individual has a share, and for which Universal Brotherhood is but another name. Man is born to a high station. In the plan of the universe is outlined for him a great mission. The whole range of evolution below is influenced by him.

The ideals of Brotherhood are only the beginning of man's awakening to a natural fact. Bye and bye in the sweep of cycles no doubt the whole body of humanity will reach that point of knowledge where a perfect realization of these facts will have become possible. It may take æons of time; meanwhile the duty devolves upon those who are beginning to feel a budding interest in such problems, to live a life, the example of which may be worth imitating, and point out the way to those below, however dimly and lost among the host, as does the evening star to those who tread their path in darkness. Says the Voice of the Silence further, "Give light and comfort to the 315toiling pilgrim, and seek out him who knows still less than thou; who in his wretched desolation sits starving for the bread of Wisdom and the bread which feeds the shadow, without a Teacher, hope or consolation, and—let him hear the Law."


Footnotes


  1. ↑ Read before the Aryan T.S., April, 1894, by E. Aug. Neresheimer.