!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(December 1893)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. VIII, no. 9, December 1893, pp. 274-279 (No. I)
- no. 12, March 1894, pp. 380-384 (No. II)
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Прайс, Джон Морган - Безмерная древность Америки
DATA
Title for references: Pryse J.M. - Immense Antiquity of America
Short description: Marshals the conclusions of recognized authorities on American antiquities against the notion that t...
No. I-II
274Since some Theosophists have taken for granted that authorities agree as to the derivation of the aborigines of America from ancient India,[1] perhaps it would be well to place together as closely as possible the conclusions of an opposite character arrived at by some of the recognized authorities upon American antiquities. This is here attempted, not in a spirit of controversy, but to substantiate the statements of the Secret Doctrine, which has not taught that India was the cradle of the human family.
It will be evident from what follows that central Asia is deemed the starting-point for the races of the Old World only (although this is disputed by many[2]), while the origin of the first tribes of the Western hemisphere is — agreeably to all but a few fanciful writers who have no facts at their disposal to support absurd conclusions — wrapped in profound darkness. Parenthetically it could be added that they have had but little success in tracing other races than the Aryan — as, for example, the Ethiopian — to an original home in central Asia, and this is in agreement with the Secret Doctrine, which places them as one of the direct offshoots of the Atlanteans. The negro had the same physiognomy 3000 and 5000 years ago (as shown by Egyptian bas-reliefs) that he has to-day.
M. le Marquis G. de Saporta indicates the regions of the North Pole as the first home of the human family,[3] and in this he agrees with the Secret Doctrine, for it is the "First Continent", hundreds of millions of years old. He also said:[4]
The spread of man throughout Europe and Asia does not offer very great difficulties. . . . The difficulties are, however, formidable when we come to America, which we find occupied from one end to the other by races whose unity has struck the best observers. Not only, moreover, did the American man inaugurate on the soil of the New World an original and relatively advanced civilization, but he has left, chiefly to the north, indisputable traces of his presence in the most remote ages. Palæolithic implements have been found in the valley of the Delaware, at Trenton, New Jersey, and near Guanajuato in Mexico, so clearly characterized that they cannot be mistaken. . . . We are thus in the presence of the problem, always coming up before us and always escaping us, of the origin of the American man.
275Alex. Winchell, a leading geologist of America, places "Lemuria as the probable cradle of humanity"[5]; and since he also advocates the theory of the lost Atlantis, (vide Pre-Adamites, chap. xxiii), his theories are in remarkable agreement with the statements of the Secret Doctrine. To quote from his book:
From the pre-Australian trunk diverged probably in Western Lemuria a sturdy and prolific stem which was destined to cover Asia and the Malayan regions with dense populations, and to send its streams of migrations over all the New World. . . . It is the great stock from which the straight-haired peoples of all parts of the world have been derived. (p. 369.)
American ethnology is beset with perplexities which have baffled the best skill of investigators. . . . Respecting the origin of the American peoples, the diversity of opinion is almost ludicrous. Polygenists have been ready to regard them as autochthonous. This view is most ably defended by L. Agassiz and J. C. Nott.[6] It is maintained by D. F. von Hellwald,[7] who sharply denies the dispersion of mankind from some original abode in Central Asia. Hon. L. H. Morgan regards the valley of the Columbia river in Oregon as the primitive Eden of America, "the seedland of the Ganowanian family",[8] and he leaves the impression that he considers them autochthonous. Galindo transferred the primitive residence of the human race to America. Very recently Dr. Rudolf Falb is reported to have announced the discovery that the relation of the Quicha and Aymara languages to the Aryan and Semitic tongues is such as to justify the opinion that the primitive seat of the human species was either in Peru or Bolivia. Of those who held to the population of America by immigration, some maintained that the American Indians are descendants of Jews, some that they are the posterity of the "lost tribes" of Israel. (p. 384-385.)
These last prejudiced conclusions are unworthy of serious consideration, since Christians have endeavored to find traces in America of the ten mythical tribes merely because no part of the Old World shows their whereabouts, and profane history is silent on the subject. With such writers Bering's Strait as a route for tropical people is a favorite theme. Many have been the fan276tastic theories evolved by minds destitute of fact upon the subject. There, for example, is Ranking, who among other things tried to make out that the giants eighteen feet high, spoken of in the ancient traditions of the Incas and Aztecs, were elephants, in the endeavor to prove that "the first Inca of Peru was a son of the Grand Khan Kublai". (See his Historical Researches on the Conquest of Peru etc. by the Moguls.) Even among more reliable writers we are given a pleasing variety. M'Causland contends that the original American stock came from the Hyksos, or "Shepherd Kings"; Squier from the Polynesians,[9] Georgius Hornius and Gaffarel from the Phœnicians, Catlin from the Welsh, Barber from the Egyptians, Charnay from the Javans, Rink and others from the Eskimo, while others mention the Norsemen, Irish Kelts, Cyprians, etc., as their probable ancestors. It shows that where fact is absent hypothesis reigns supreme. After reviewing the evidence Winchell, although a believer in the Old Testament, is compelled to admit:[10]
The weight of opinion, after all, tends to regard the American civilization as indigenous, and this view seems most consonant with the general tenor of the evidence. Common characteristics must be expected to germinate from the common nature of man.
Epitomizing all that has been written on the subject, Chambers' Cyclopædia says:
As to the aboriginal ages there arises a question, too interesting to be overlooked and yet too doubtful to be solved, as to the origin of the native tribes and peoples of America. It appears highly probable that they did not all spring from one and the same primeval band of adventurers. . . . Whence came the successive shoals of invaders? To this question no direct answer can be given. We can only scan the various routes by which, previously to what we call the discovery of America, the Old World was most likely to people the American continent. To begin with the natural routes on the side of the Pacific — Bering's Strait, the Aleutian Islands, and the Polynesian archipelagoes — we can hardly conceive anything but barbarism having been conducted to America by any one of them. The country which stretches backwards from Bering's strait to the Kolyma may be asserted to be, without exception, the most inhospitable portion even of Siberia; and, moreover, the Strait itself has more probably been a channel of migration from America than from Asia, the Tchuktchi of the latter regarding themselves rather as a branch than as a stem of the Tchuktchi of the former. With respect, again, both to the Aleutian isles and the Polynesian archipelagos, the successive stepping-stones in either series, instead of being presumed to have been so many halts for Asiatic Columbuses and Magellans, must rather be viewed as each a mother-country to a new colony, as each a point of depart277ure for a fresh swarm. Thus would the ever-aggravating blight of isolation — exemplified even in the Old World among the Laplanders, the Kamtchadales, and the Hottentots — prepare at each remove a deeper and deeper barbarism to land at last on the western shore of America.
These difficulties, however, do not prevent second-rate writers, having in view the biblical theory, from speaking glibly about these routes being means for the peopling of the New World; but since wisdom gives birth to discretion, we do not find high authorities as to American archæology making statements so confidently. For example, at the eighth International Congress of Americanists, held in Paris in 1890,[11]
The Marquis de Nadaillac presented and read an extended review of the evidence on the subject of "The Earliest American". His origin he confesses to be entirely unknown; but he is of the opinion that he occupied the continent of America during the glacial, if not during the pre-glacial period, and that he passed through two periods of cold.
"It was an original civilization", said Baldwin, after carefully weighing the evidence for immigration. He then continues:[12]
It has been said very justly by one explorer of the Mexican and Central American ruins that the American monuments are different from those of any other known people, of a new order, and entirely and absolutely anomalous; they stand alone. The more we study them the more we find it necessary to believe that the civilization they represent was originated in America and probably in the region where they were found. It did not come from the Old World; it was the work of some remarkably gifted branch of the race found on the southern part of this continent when it was discovered in 1492. Undoubtedly it was very old. Its original beginnings may have been as old as Egypt, or even farther back in the past than the ages to which Atlantis must be referred;[13] and it may have been later than the beginning of Egypt. Who can tell its age? Whether earlier or later, it was original. . . .
The decorations and also the writing are wholly original. There is no imitation of the work of any people ever known in Asia, Africa, or Europe. . . . The culture and the work were wholly original, wholly American. . . .
I find myself more and more inclined to the opinion that the aboriginal South Americans are the oldest people on the continent; that they are distinct in race, and that the wild Indians of the North came originally from Asia.
It is thus shown that to attribute to India the distinction of having been the birth-place of the races of the New World is but to set up an hypothesis with nothing to support it. That real authorities upon American antiquities have not done this, is seen from the foregoing quotations, taken from among many similar ones. And this is what is admirable in writers who may be classed 278as authorities on American archæology, that they readily admit they do not know, and do not try to bolster up preconceived opinions with hypotheses which do not follow from known data. From one who, on account of his being a devout Roman Catholic, we would not look for such scrupulous fairness in matters touching upon "heathen" religions, is Bandelier, now in central South America on a three years' search after antiquities, and from whom much may be expected upon his return. He never allows his own opinions to warp his judgment in such matters. If a new fact comes to his notice, he puts it down just as he obtained it, even though it may seem to destroy some cherished theory of his own. If they all had pursued the stratagems of, say, the Egyptologists, who, because the Jews were said in the Bible to have been held in bondage in ancient Egypt, have never lost an opportunity to distort anything available to bear out such theory, there would be nothing relating to American antiquities worthy of serious study. But happily American antiquarians have not done this, for they frankly admit they do not know whence these people came. For example, Prescott, after scanning all existing authority to prepare his Conquest of Peru, was compelled to admit:[14]
Whence this remarkable race came and what was its early history are among those mysteries that meet us so frequently in the annals of the New World, and which time and the antiquary have as yet done little to explain.
And Squier, an authority on Peruvian antiquities, remarking[15] that "those mysterious records of the past are generally superior in development in proportion as they are anterior in age", thus speaks about the ruins of Tiahuanaco, conceded to be the most ancient in South America:[16]
Unique, yet perfect in type and harmonious in style, they appear to be the work of a people who were thorough masters of an architecture which had no infancy, passed through no period of growth, and of which we find no other examples. Tradition, which mumbles more or less intelligibly of the origin of many other American monuments, is dumb concerning these. The wondering Indians told the first Spaniards that "they existed before the sun shone in the heavens", that they were raised by giants, [etc.]
Now the Theosophist, unlike the orthodox Christian, should feel under no necessity of showing the human race as springing from one type. Monogenists, in the interests of biblical myths, have strained themselves in this direction, but the student of Theosophy, adhering to the reliableness of the documents of the Brotherhood, believes that seven primal races of men, each of a 279distinct color, were placed on earth simultaneously, each on a separate zone; and that most continents have risen and disappeared since then, the few survivors serving as seed for the different races in widely-separated portions of the earth's surface.
That Atlantis was the origin of both the Egyptians and the races of the new world so closely resembling them will be demonstrated in due course of time. Such was the contention of many noted writers, whose statements corroborate the Secret Doctrine, as will be shown in Paper No. III.
John M. Pryse.
Footnotes
- ↑ Vide Path for October, p. 222.
- ↑ Dr. Fligier argues in Kosmos that the theory of the Asiatic origin of the Aryan race is not yet as firmly settled as has been supposed. Latham disputes it on geographical grounds in his Native Races of the Russian Empire. Pictet believes, on the evidence of the names of animals and plants that were known to them, that they originated farther north than the Asiatic theory supposes, and fixes their birthplace in southern Russia. Benfey and Prof. Thomaschek of Gratz agree with him, and indicate the region of the southern Volga as their primary home, [etc.] ... Dr. Fligier believes that the results of linguistic, anthropological, and archæological researches indicate that the [East] Indians and the Iranians lived near each other for a long time in eastern Europe or northwestern Asia, and that the Indians followed the Iranians into Asia. — "The Original Home of the Aryans", Popular Science Monthly, vol. xxi, p. 571.
- ↑ It will be seen that we are inclined to remove to the circumpolar regions of the North the probable cradle of primitive humanity. From there only could it have radiated as from a center to spread to several continents at once. This theory agrees best with the presumed course of the human races.... The general laws of geology favor this hypothesis in a remarkable manner. — "How the Earth was Peopled", Popular Science Monthly, vol. xxiii, p. 678.
- ↑ "How the Earth was Peopled", Popular Science Monthly, vol. xxiii, p. 673.
- ↑ Pre-Adamites, p. 361.
- ↑ See especially Agassiz, Essay on Nott; and Gliddon's Types of Mankind.
- ↑ "The American Migration", Smithsonian Report, 1866, p. 348.
- ↑ North American Review, vol. cix, p. 407; Ancient Society, pp. 108-110.
- ↑ "If civilization took the route of these monuments, it certainly spread 'laterally' past the Pacific Islands to America, or — vice versa." — Squier, Primeval Monuments of Peru, p. 14.
- ↑ Pre-Adamites, p. 387.
- ↑ Vide American Naturalist, August, 1893, p. 757.
- ↑ Ancient America, pp. 184-185.
- ↑ An attempt will be made in the next paper to show that this is the correct theory, supported both by the Secret Doctrine and what exoteric proofs are at our disposal.
- ↑ Vol. I, p. 39.
- ↑ Primeval Monuments of Peru.
- ↑ Peru, p. 274.
380
There were, scattered over the three Americas, remnants of departed civilizations, about which the natives discovered by Europeans knew little or nothing. Some of these monuments betoken an extreme age. Concerning those in Central America Baldwin said:[1]
No well-considered theory of these ruins can avoid the conclusion that most of them are very ancient, and that, to find the origin of the civilization they represent, we must go far back into the "deeps of antiquity". . . .
I refer to it (Catlin's Lifted and Subsided Rocks of America) on account of the very great antiquity it claims for the ancient American civilization. It represents that the advanced human development whose crumbling monuments are studied at Copan, Mitla, and Palenque antedate everything else in the human period of our globe, excepting, perhaps, an earlier time of barbarism and pastoral simplicity; that its history goes back through all the misty ages of prehistoric time to an unknown date previous to the beginning of such civilization in any part of the Old World. It is hardly possible to make it more ancient.
From this it would seem that America, rather than India, furnished the cradle. The traditions of the people go back quite a ways. According to l'Abbé Brasseur de Bourbourg:[2]
These traditions, traces of which are also to be met with in Mexico, Central America, Peru, and Bolivia, point to the conclusion that man existed in these various countries at the time of the upheaval of the Cordilleras, and that the memory of that upheaval has been preserved.
That such an event must have taken place in a remote age is best understood by the geologist. Nadaillac was willing to admit that "Undoubtedly America bears witness to a venerable past", "without", he said:[3]
Admitting the claims of some recent authors, who are of the opinion that when Europe was inhabited by wandering savages, whose only weapons were roughly-hewn stone, America was peopled by men who built cities, raised monuments, and had attained to a high degree of culture.
Turning now to recognized geology, we find man given place in America in the Pliocene — perhaps the Miocene — age, as great an antiquity as he is assigned in the Old World. In California, a portion of which, according to the Secret Doctrine,[4] belonged to Atlantis, numerous discoveries have been made which show man 381to have lived in that region in the most remote times. A fossil skull was found deep under the base of Table Mountain in Calaveras county, the whole mountain having been formed since the man to whom it belonged died. This is, as said by Prof. Winchell:[5]
By far the best authenticated instance of Pliocene man which has been brought to light. There is only a presumption which weighs against it; the skull is not inferior to that of existing races.
But as he acknowledged, presumption must not be arrayed against fact. Prof. Whitney, who made this discovery to become so well known, said in an address at Cambridge, Mass., April 27, 1878:
So far as human and geological evidence can go, there is no question but the skull was found under Table Mountain, and is of Pliocene age.
In 1872 he had written:[6]
Evidence is now accumulated to such extent that I feel no hesitation in saying that we have now unequivocal proofs of the existence of man on the Pacific Coast prior to the glacial period, prior to the period of the mastodon and the elephant, at a time when animal and vegetable life were entirely different from what they are now, and since which a vertical erosion has taken place. . . . Rest assured that the Calaveras county skull is not an isolated fact, but that I have a whole series of well-authenticated cases of the finding, in the same geological position, of either human remains or objects of human workmanship.
In a lecture delivered at Manchester, in June, 1879, Mr. H. A. Allbutt, Honorary Member of the Royal Anthropological Society, stated the following:
Near New Orleans, in one part of the modern delta, in excavating for gas-works, a series of beds, almost wholly made up of vegetable matter, were dug through. In the excavation, at a depth of sixteen feet from the upper surface, and beneath four buried forests, one on top of the other, the laborers discovered some charcoal and the skeleton of a man, the cranium of which was reported to be that of the type of the aboriginal Red Indian race. To this skeleton Dr. Dowler ascribed an antiquity of some 50,000 years.
He afterwards reduced the figure to 12,000; but on the other hand, Lyell believes the Mississippi to have flowed along its present course for more than a hundred thousand years,[7] so the former estimate may yet be demonstrated as the more correct. Says Prehistoric America:[8]
382
Amongst the most ancient human relics discovered on American soil may be ranked a skull brought to light by the works of a railway near Denver. . . . Everything points to the conclusion that this skull dates from the same [paleolithic] period. . . . This man lived in the midst of glaciers.
One of the most interesting discoveries — to the Theosophist, at least — was that of the gigantic footprints found during an excavation at Carson, Nevada, mentioned in Secret Doctrine, vol. ii, p. 755. Two of them, besides a facsimile of the whole, were on exhibition in the Anthropological Building at the World's Fair, and are undoubtedly human footprints, as any candid observer will admit. Someone assigned to them an antiquity of over 750,000 years, which is a much greater age than ever before assigned by our geologists to any human relic. B. B. Redding said:
If it is ever proven they are human relics, they will actually upset all the scientific theories as to the age of man upon the earth.
They will upset such theories as to the size of that prehistoric man as well, and vindicate the Secret Doctrine, for the footprints are 18 inches long by 8 inches in width, representing proportionately twice the size of the man of to-day. The only conceivable reason why they have not been frankly judged human footprints is on account of their size. Thus it is but a matter of prejudice, for had they been only nine inches long, no such doubt would have arisen. However, if a giant, his stride was seemingly not much longer than that of the man of to-day, but it is possible that he was only strolling along. The pressure of the foot is too plain to give rise to the supposition that he had on large footgear. About a half-dozen such tracks going in one direction, with the right- and left-footedness plainly marked, ought to be convincing. Nor is it possible to say that he (or she) was walking on a surface that caved in, thus making the appearance of large feet, for there are hyena foot-tracks alongside which are not thus enlarged. There are also tracks of an elephant, about which Prof. H. W. Harkness said:
There can be no doubt about their character.
Nor should there have been any about the human footprints; and since on the fifteenth of last August over a dozen more admittedly-human footprints — though smaller ones — have been found in the same excavation, it puts this point out of discussion.
Turning to Central America, we have Dr. Brinton saying:[9]
The discovery of human footprints in volcanic rocks near the shore of Lake Managua, Nicaragua, in circumstances which seemed to assign to them a remote antiquity, has been announced for several years.
383The discoverer, Dr. E. Flint, by means of a diagram shows a vertical section of the quarry in which they were found, and gives his decision that:
The eruptions covering the southwest slope, and the disturbance caused by one along the ocean beach, elevating the coast range, afford us indisputable evidence of Pliocene man.
Brinton adds that "there can be no doubt of these being genuine footprints"; and that, since they indicate the use of sandals or moccasins, they "cannot be assigned to the earliest stages of human culture".
South America furnished some excellent evidences of the great antiquity of the "New" World aborigine. Under the guano (sea-fowl deposits) on the Peruvian islands at a depth of thirty to sixty feet were found idols, water-pots, mummies, gold and silver ornaments, vases, etc., while, as estimated, "the accumulation of the preceeding three hundred years since the conquest had formed only a few lines in thickness".[10] Commenting on this, H. P. B. said:[11]
If we confine ourselves to a strictly arithmetical calculation, then, allowing twelve lines to an inch and twelve inches to a foot, and allowing one line to every century, we are forced to believe that the people who made these precious gold vases lived 864,000 years ago! Leave an ample margin for errors, and give two lines to a century — say an inch to every hundred years — and we will yet have 72,000 years back, a civilization which — if we judge by its public works, the durability of its constructions, and the grandeur of its buildings — equalled, and in some things certainly surpassed, our own.
The subject of one of the most ancient human relics found in South America was discussed at the Eighth International Congress of Americanists, held in Paris in 1890:[12]
Dr. J. Villanova described a fossil man found by M. Carlos in the valley of the river de la Plata, associated with or near to a skeleton of a megatherium. . . . Dr. Villanova has studied the question of fossil man in times of high antiquity as probably no other Spaniard and but few others in all the world have ever done.
The Secret Doctrine agrees with Prof. Orton in his decision that:[13]
Geology and archaeology are combining to prove that Sorata and Chimborazo have looked down upon a civilization far more ancient than that of the Incas, and perhaps coeval with the flint-flakes of Cornwall and the shell-mounds of Denmark. On the shores of Lake Titicaca are extensive ruins 384which antedate the advent of Manco Capac, and may be as venerable as the lake-dwellers of Geneva. Wilson has traced six terraces in going up from the sea through the province of Esmeraldas toward Quito, and underneath the living forest, which is older than the Spanish Conquest, many gold, copper, and stone vestiges of a lost population were found. In all cases these relics are situated below the high-tide mark, in a bed of marine sediment, from which he infers that this part of the country formerly stood higher than the sea. If this be true, vast indeed must be the antiquity of these remains, for the upheaval and subsidence of the coast are exceedingly slow.
As explained more fully by Baldwin:[14]
This refers to the discoveries made on the coast of Ecuador in 1860, by James S. Wilson, Esq. At various points along this coast he found "ancient or fossil pottery, vessels, images", and other manufactured articles, all finely wrought. Some of these articles were made of gold. The most remarkable fact connected with them is that they were taken from a "stratum of ancient surface earth", which was covered with a marine deposit six feet thick. The geological formation where these remains were found is reported to be "as old as the drift strata of Europe" and "identical with that of Guayaquil in which bones of the mastodon are met with". The ancient surface-earth or vegetable mould, with its pottery, gold-work, and other relics of civilized life, was therefore below the sea, where the marine deposit was spread over it. This land, after being occupied by men, had subsided and settled below the ocean, remained there long enough to accumulate the marine deposit, and again been elevated to its former position above the sea-level. Since this elevation, forests have been established over it which are older than the Spanish Conquest, and now it is once more subsiding.
Assuming the facts to be as Mr. Wilson reports (and they have not been called in question), it follows that there was human civilization to a certain extent in South America at the time of the older stone age of Western Europe. . . . The fact that may be considered in connection with another mentioned . . . , namely, that the most ancient fauna on this continent, man probably included, is that of South America.
Thus the voice of geology proclaims it impossible (granting man's age on earth no greater than the accepted theory) to show that the first American people came from India. It is quite plain to the Theosophist that the only theory which will extricate our archæologists from their difficulties, when dealing with the problem of the peopling of the New World, is that of the sunken Atlantis, which H. P. B. took up so much room in the Secret Doctrine to prove.[15]
John M. Pryse.
Footnotes
- ↑ Ancient America, p. 118.
- ↑ Arch. de l'Exp. Scientifique du Mexique, vol. i, p. 95.
- ↑ Prehistoric America, p. 13.
- ↑ Vol. ii, p. 38.
- ↑ Pre-Adamites, p. 118.
- ↑ Revue d'Anthropologie, 1872, p. 760.
- ↑ Second Visit to the United States, vol. ii, p. 188.
- ↑ P. 477.
- ↑ Proc. Amer. Philosophical Society, vol. xxiv, No. 126, p. 437.
- ↑ Ibid, p. 443.
- ↑ Dr. Heath: Kansas City Review of Science and Industry, Nov., 1878.
- ↑ Theosophist, vol. i, p. 161.
- ↑ American Naturalist, Aug. 1893, p. 758.
- ↑ The Andes and the Amazon, p. 109.
- ↑ Ancient America, pp. 274-275.