(September 1897)
Publications:
- Theosophy, vol. XII, no. 6, September 1897, pp. 273-277
Read:
DATA
Title for references: Solon - The Sokratic Club
Short description: A first-person frame narrative introducing "the Professor" and the Sokratic Club, a (claimed-real, u...
Signed only "Solon." at the close, marked "(To be continued.)"; no further instalment of this series has yet been located in this transcription project. "Solon" appears to be a pseudonym (in the classical-pen-name style of this magazine, cf. "Cavé," "Medicus") rather than an identified author, and no card for it has been found; kept as a standalone page on the strength of its own printed title and closing signature, per the project's three-feature test (own title and signature; no identified author). Two footnoted asides are printed inline in the original with the footnote text run on the same page rather than collected at the foot of the article as elsewhere in this magazine; both are rendered here as Template:Tag notes under
Footnotes
. The first forestalls the reader's natural guess that the "Sokratic Club" is the Theosophical Society itself, insisting (without further proof offered) that the Club has "an actual existence" under some name. The second notes that the Indian prince, "Mr. Rama," did not appear publicly in New York in connection with the 1893 World's Fair, or at any other time, during his stay in America — consistent with the narrator's statement that he was "travelling incognito." Dr. Roberts is introduced in the text itself as "an optimistic materialist."
273
The Sokratic Club.
It is now several years since I met the Professor and I have often thought that the conversations which I had with him might not be unworthy of record. Some of these, and I refer also to conversations and discussions at which I was a listener, as well as those in which I took part, occurred some years ago and others are of more recent date. However, time and place are not of so much importance as the ideas which I gleaned from my association with the Professor. The way I came to meet him was this. On a trip to the west in the year 1890 I ran across a certain man with whom I made a travelling acquaintanceship as so often is the case among fellow-travellers, and being of the same profession, he very kindly gave me letters to a friend of his in a city which I intended to visit. Through this friend I made acquaintance with a member of the Sokratic Club and received a cordial invitation to visit the Club when I should next be in New York or Chicago, at both of which places it had quarters.
I had not previously heard of this club, but on being informed of its character and aims and also of the distinguished scientific and literary men belonging to it, my interest was at once aroused. The club had been founded some few years previously, the Professor being one of those instrumental in its organization.[1] The name of the club, I learned, had been chosen to express in some measure its character and the purpose for which it was founded. It was chosen for three reasons:—1st, because of the high esteem for the Sokratic philosophy held by the founders of the club; 2d, because the Sokratic method was considered to be the one best calculated to lead to the elucidation, as far as may be, of the problems of life; and 3d, and most important, because it was held that the Sokratic philosophy formed a basis for ethics and true living. The motto of the club: "Plain living and high thinking, unselfishness and toleration towards all," suited my fancy exactly and I applied for membership and was duly admitted. Naturally, however, I found
members of very varying character in the club. Not all conformed or even made any serious effort to conform to the club's motto and purpose. Some had sought admission because it pleased them to think they were helping to solve the riddles of the Universe and
274 they desired to be considered patrons of the advanced thought of the day. Others had joined because they were fond of argument and some simply out of curiosity and for the novelty of the thing. However, quite a number were really in earnest and of these the club proper consisted, though no one was refused admission who desired it and could fulfill certain simple requirements.
It was one of the Professor's pet schemes to bring together men of different race and belief and he would turn a discussion so as to interest them and draw out their opinions.
During the summer of 1893 several foreigners passed through New York on their way to the World's Fair at Chicago. Two merchants, an Arab and a Japanese, had business with Mr. August Berger, a member of the club, and an Indian Prince, travelling incognito, was an old friend of the Professor's whom he had met in India. The Prince was a Kshattriya, i. e., of the Warrior caste, and I shall call him by his first name simply, Mr. Rama.[2]
Mr. Berger invited these foreigners and three or four members of the club to spend a few days at his country place, a few miles from New York, on the Hudson River.
On the evening of our arrival, when it was getting pretty late, the conversation turned on the test of reality. Mr. Berger had been singing and Dr. Roberts, whom I would describe as an optimistic materialist, spoke of the tendency which some natures had to drift away from the reality and to live in mere fancy and dream-land. "There are so many," he said, "who, when listening to music, for instance, just let themselves go and forget all about present surroundings. This tendency is sometimes the expression of some constitutional weakness, but more often the result of faulty systems of education and training."
The Professor.—It is not at all such a simple question as you may suppose, Doctor, as to what is real and what is not. The only thing which any one can be certain about is his own existence, his own being. Even in the last analysis no one can imagine himself as ceasing to be. My body, for example, is changing all the time, it will die, but the Ego, the I, will still live on. Then again nothing is real to me of which I can form no conception and which cannot be related to my consciousness, but when it is so related, then in that proportion it assumes reality for me.
Dr. Roberts.—Do you mean, Professor, to deny the existence of this table, for instance? To me it is real enough, (and he rapped it sharply with his knuckles), and as to myself, I mean my
275 body, you know;—I never could follow that whimsical and ultra-metaphysical statement that I am different from my body—I am sure I am real enough; I can feel pain and pleasure, I enjoy my food and my work and my sleep. Of course I'm sure of my existence. I never doubted it. But anything to be real must be material.
Rev. Alex. Fulsom.—I think the Doctor goes a little too far in so completely identifying himself with his body, but I do not agree with the Professor that the external world does not exist except in my mind or consciousness. Suppose I were wiped out of existence, annihilated, that would not wipe out the universe, it would still exist for you and for all others still living. The universe depends upon the absolute God, who made it, and not upon you or me.
Mr. Berger.—Ha! Ha! that's an objection and a half; but neither of you has given the Professor a chance to complete his statement, which he only began. Now Professor, let's hear some more.
Dr. Roberts.—Pardon my interruption, but before you go on, Professor, I wish to remind the reverend gentleman that his statement that God made the universe is one of those unscientific and illogical statements, not susceptible of proof, which I, for one, would like an explanation of, before I can ever accept it. However, that is slightly off the subject.
The Professor.—Not altogether off the subject, Doctor, as you seem to suppose, though we might have to construe the Dominie's words a little differently. I did not expect, however, to run counter to both of you and, pardon me, I think neither of you followed my statement accurately. In the first place I was speaking of the reality of things with reference to one's self and not in a universal sense; though perhaps we may discuss that later. Suppose, now, Doctor, I ask you to describe to me a——— What shall I say? Well, a mahbub; I venture to say, you have never seen or heard of a mahbub. ———No, I thought not. You don't know what the word means. To you it is nothing more than a mere word, it awakens no conception or idea in your mind, and for aught you know, it may be a word coined by myself, altogether fanciful and meaningless. You don't know whether it is something to eat or whether it is an animal or an abstract quality. On the other hand, if you understand to what I refer, it does not matter what term I use to describe it or in what language I speak, but the mere mention of it immediately brings it more or less vividly to your consciousness.
Rev. Alex. Fulsom.—I suppose you mean to infer that "a rose—
276 or, I should say, a mahbub—by any other name would——— what? What is a mahbub, Professor?
The Professor.—I'll tell you in a moment, but first I wish to make it quite clear to you that an idea, or a rose, or a mahbub, or anything whatsoever, becomes real to you only in the measure in which it is related to your consciousness and experience. Let us now take another case: you are familiar with the phenomena of hypnotism, but none of your scientific men has yet given any satisfactory explanation of them. Let us take an example: I hypnotize a man and place a piece of ordinary plain paper on his arm, telling him it is a plaster. What happens? His arm becomes blistered. But if I put on a plaster, telling him it is only a bit of paper, it has no effect. Or suppose I were to tell you of people—and I know of such, especially in Ireland among my countrymen—who, at certain times of the year and moon and in certain parts of the country, see little elves and fairies and lights inside the mountains. How would you explain this? ...No, you need not answer, I know what you will say:—"Hallucination, disordered fancy, a diseased brain"—mere words, however, to label what you cannot explain.
Dr. Roberts.—Oh, come now, Professor, that's hardly a fair statement of the case. It has been proved beyond a doubt that such hallucinations are due to the abnormal excitation of the optic nerve and of certain of the brain centres and may be caused by disease or by drugs or the excessive use of alcoholic liquors. But what has all this to do with the subject in hand?
The Professor.—The connection is simple enough. The word mahbub does not bring you into conscious relation with that of which it is the name. I referred to a mahbub because I happen to have one with me. Here it is, it is a coin from Tripoli. If I had shown it to you, you would have known it for a coin, but the mere name gave you no clue, so a mahbub, as such, had no existence for you. As for the bit of paper, it certainly was not a belladonna plaster yet it produced the effects of one and vice versa because of the suggestion to the consciousness of the patient. Will the Doctor tell me what is the test of reality, or how we are to judge of things except in so far as they are related to ourselves, i. e., to our consciousness? The fairies are certainly real to those who see them, and I venture to say that if you, Doctor, were to see them, your opinion would undergo a change.
Dr. Roberts.—Never, Professor, never! In fact, I know I could never see them, at least so long as I am in my right mind, as I hope I am this moment.
277 Mr. Berger. (Laughing)—Granting your last statement as correct, I quite agree with you, Doctor. There's many a true word, spoken in jest, and I'll wager you will never see fairies in your present state of mind. But we haven't yet heard from our Indian friend. What view do you hold, Mr. Rama?
Mr. Rama.—I entirely agree with my friend the Professor, and if the Doctor will pardon my frankness, I think that his materialistic view of things arises mainly, if not solely, from his accepting only those things as real which he can weigh or analyze chemically. Whereas, if he would but trust himself to accept the higher and more subjective experiences of consciousness he would begin to live in a new world, far wider and more wonderful than this.
Dr. Roberts.—No, sir; I do not trust myself to go where I cannot see and feel and smell and taste, and above all things, use my reason. I do not believe in any visionary existence, but in a practical material life.
Mr. Rama.—But pause a moment, my dear sir; do not speak hastily. How comes it that you trust yourself to go to sleep? Can you see and feel and smell and taste and use your reasoning powers when you are asleep?
The Professor.—Yes! Sleep is another of the riddles of life; riddles, that is, to the modern scientific men, but not to those who have studied the ancient and ever-living Science of Life and Nature. But it is getting late and we will have to leave the matter for to-night.
Dr. Roberts.—Well, Professor, the ideas you advance seem very beautiful, but I still hold to my position; to me they are visionary and will not stand the test of practical life.
The Professor.—Don't be so anxious, Doctor, to make everything fit in and square with your reason. There may be some ideas too big for any of us, and our reason may have to be widened considerably to take them in. Don't trouble so much about knowing and reasoning, but strive to become and to be. That alone will bring you to the heart of things. Good night.
Solon.
(To be continued.)
Footnotes
- ↑ The reader may perhaps be inclined to imagine that the Theosophical Society is here referred to, but the writer wishes to disabuse the reader's mind of any such idea. The club has however an actual existence but whether under this or another name matters not.
- ↑ He did not appear publicly in connection with the World's Fair or at any time during his stay in America.