Bots, Editors (Semantic MediaWiki), trusted
12,543
edits
m (Add the July-September 1896 (no. 4-6) installments) |
m (Add the October-December 1896 (no. 7-9) installments) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
| title = Questions and Answers | | title = Questions and Answers | ||
| author = Hargrove, Ernest Temple | | author = Hargrove, Ernest Temple | ||
| description = A recurring Q&A column. The April 1896 installment answers questions on the superstition that "advanced Theosophists" need to smoke to ward off bad influences, and on the relation between reading Theosophical literature and finding truth within oneself. The June 1896 installment answers questions on the "E.S.T." (the Esoteric Section, of which Katherine A. Tingley was now Outer Head), on the connection between Freemasonry and the Theosophical Society, and on whether an investigator of Spiritualism can become an Adept in this life. The July 1896 installment answers questions on the necessity of the Theosophical Crusade and on finding time for inner study and self-knowledge. The August 1896 installment answers a question on the significance of the close of the century, quoting at length from H. P. Blavatsky's "The Esoteric Character of the Gospels" and W. Q. Judge's article "Cycles." The September 1896 installment answers questions on a Society officer's freedom to express personal political or religious opinions, and on how to write an article for a Theosophical magazine. | | description = A recurring Q&A column. The April 1896 installment answers questions on the superstition that "advanced Theosophists" need to smoke to ward off bad influences, and on the relation between reading Theosophical literature and finding truth within oneself. The June 1896 installment answers questions on the "E.S.T." (the Esoteric Section, of which Katherine A. Tingley was now Outer Head), on the connection between Freemasonry and the Theosophical Society, and on whether an investigator of Spiritualism can become an Adept in this life. The July 1896 installment answers questions on the necessity of the Theosophical Crusade and on finding time for inner study and self-knowledge. The August 1896 installment answers a question on the significance of the close of the century, quoting at length from H. P. Blavatsky's "The Esoteric Character of the Gospels" and W. Q. Judge's article "Cycles." The September 1896 installment answers questions on a Society officer's freedom to express personal political or religious opinions, and on how to write an article for a Theosophical magazine. The October 1896 installment answers a question on the attitude a Theosophist should take towards the questions of the day. The November 1896 installment answers a question on whether the Theosophical Crusade is an official activity of the Theosophical Society in America, and a question on the place of desire in life, discussing the injunction to "kill out desire" in ''The Voice of the Silence'' and quoting the Secret Doctrine on Kama as the first-arising cosmic desire. The December 1896 installment answers a question on why Theosophical teaching should be veiled in secrecy and why there should be an "Inner Circle," quoting at length from the Secret Doctrine (Vol. I, Introd., p. xxxiv) on the danger of imparting the doctrine of the septenary constitution of man to the unprepared. | ||
| work type = articles | | work type = articles | ||
| publication date = April, June, July, August, September 1896 | | publication date = April, June, July, August, September, October, November, December 1896 | ||
| publication date sortable = 1896-04 | | publication date sortable = 1896-04 | ||
| publication place = ''Theosophy'' | | publication place = ''Theosophy'' | ||
| publications = [[Theosophy/Vol11|''Theosophy'', vol. XI, no. 1]], April 1896, pp. 26-27; no. 3, June 1896, pp. 88-90; no. 4, July 1896, pp. 120-122; no. 5, August 1896, pp. 154-156; no. 6, September 1896, pp. 188-189 | | publications = [[Theosophy/Vol11|''Theosophy'', vol. XI, no. 1]], April 1896, pp. 26-27; no. 3, June 1896, pp. 88-90; no. 4, July 1896, pp. 120-122; no. 5, August 1896, pp. 154-156; no. 6, September 1896, pp. 188-189; no. 7, October 1896, pp. 216-217; no. 8, November 1896, pp. 249-251; no. 9, December 1896, pp. 279-281 | ||
| read links = [[Theosophy/Vol11|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]] | | read links = [[Theosophy/Vol11|Electronic journal edition in Teopedia]] | ||
| note = Answered principally by E. T. Hargrove, signed "E. T. H."; one answer in the June installment signed "S. G. P. Coryn."; the July and | | note = Answered principally by E. T. Hargrove, signed "E. T. H."; one answer in the June installment signed "S. G. P. Coryn."; the July, August, October, one of the two November answers, and the December answer signed "J. H. F." | ||
| ctd rus = Хэргроув, Эрнест Темпл - Вопросы и ответы | | ctd rus = Хэргроув, Эрнест Темпл - Вопросы и ответы | ||
}} | }} | ||
| Line 160: | Line 160: | ||
{{Style P-Signature|E. T. H.}} | {{Style P-Signature|E. T. H.}} | ||
{{Vertical space|2em}} | |||
<hr> | |||
{{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=7|p=216}} | |||
T. V.—What should be the attitude of a Theosophist towards the Questions of the day? | |||
''Ans.''—It would be impossible to give any categorical answer to this question, for the attitude will vary with the individual and will depend upon the character, experience and knowledge of the individual. It must also be remembered that the T. S. leaves its members entirely free in all matters religious, social or political, requiring only the assent of each to its first object—to form the nucleus of a Universal Brotherhood of humanity without any distinctions whatever. If it can be said that adherence to this object constitutes a Theosophist then we may also say that the attitude of a Theosophist on all questions should be in accordance with this idea of Universal Brotherhood. | |||
Taking this as our basis we may, however, go further and say the attitude of a Theosophist should also be marked by impersonality and harmonious relations with the whole of nature. The true bearings of any question cannot be seen except from an impersonal standpoint. Hence personal needs, personal gains and losses should sink into insignificance compared with the needs of humanity. If the non-separateness of all human beings be true, then it must follow that the ultimate welfare of the individual can come only through the welfare of humanity. And the welfare of humanity requires that harmonious relations exist through all its parts. So we may say that not only should the attitude of a Theosophist be impersonal and universal, but also be such as to bring about the greatest harmony. But this must be a true harmony, {{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=7|p=217}}not a false peace which comes from ignoring right and wrong and the true ethical side of the question. True harmony cannot result save from the rigid adherence to right. | |||
Such an attitude which would be in accord with the above can be reached only where there is freedom. We must be free to form our own opinions, we must learn to rely on ourselves and not on the authority of another. We must have the courage of our own convictions, but at the same time have that charity and toleration which will grant to others the same right. There is, however, another kind of freedom necessary, and this is allied to impersonality. It is freedom from attachment to results. We are rarely willing to act the best we know how at the time and then let the thing go, but we are all prone to look for certain results and are not satisfied unless the results turn out as we wish. | |||
This question of attachment to results is very interesting in its relation to Karma. Where there is attachment to results Karmic ties are made and one becomes entangled and involved in these results. | |||
Attachment to results hinders the mind from adapting itself to new conditions which may arise and perhaps change the whole aspect of a question. It is really the same as attachment to outer form and organization as opposed to the principle which these should embody. There is a tendency towards crystallization in all organizations as well as in matters of individual opinion, and there is always a danger of becoming imprisoned as it were by this crystallizing process. The only remedy against this is strict adherence to principle. Sacrifice the form to the principle, adjust the former to the latter, but never vice versa. Where there is real life, as in nature, the form is ever changing, ever being renewed—rigidity of form, cast iron rules, precede death. Therefore we may add as other characteristics of a theosophic attitude, adherence to principle, non-attachment to results. | |||
{{Style P-Signature|J. H. F.}} | |||
{{Vertical space|2em}} | |||
<hr> | |||
{{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=8|p=249}} | |||
F. T. S.—Is the "Crusade" an official activity of the Theosophical Society in America? | |||
''Ans.''—Certainly not. It is no more an "official activity" than any other enterprise entered into by members of the Society in connection with the work of promulgating Theosophy. Not a cent has been paid towards its expenses out of the Society's funds, and the officers of the Society who are taking part in the movement, do so in their private capacity as members. It cannot be too often repeated that the Theosophical Society in America, officially speaking, has no views on philosophical, religious or scientific questions, except in regard to Brotherhood. Any member has a perfect right to disagree with the views of the Crusaders—if he knows them. | |||
{{Style P-Signature|E. T. H.}} | |||
W. T. P.—I have never rightly understood the place that desire should hold in my life. We are told to kill out desire and yet I cannot see how we can do anything without it. | |||
''Ans.''—It is never wise to take isolated statements as finalities but the {{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=8|p=250}}context should always be studied. The injunction "Kill out desire" occurs in ''The Voice of the Silence'' and therefore to understand its meaning and application we must to some extent know what is the trend of the whole of that little book. We are told that it is "for the daily use of lanoos (disciples)" and it is "dedicated to the few." Its keynote is renunciation and compassion and it is written for the practical guidance of those who are striving to enter the "path." | |||
All this must be borne in mind if we wish to understand the question before us. Closely following this injunction to kill out desire comes this paragraph: | |||
{{Style P-Quote|Desire nothing. Chafe not at Karma, nor at Nature's changeless laws. But struggle only with the personal, the transitory, the evanescent and the perishable. | |||
Help Nature and work on with her——}} | |||
This shows clearly that the desire to be killed out is the personal desire, and is that which is related to this transitory life and to the lower self. A distinction must be made between the personal and the universal. Nature works for all, gives to all, and to help Nature we also must work for all, live for all. This means that every personal desire must finally give way to universal and impersonal desire. For back of Nature, back of the manifested Universe, is universal desire. In the Secret Doctrine we read: "Now Kama is 'Aja' (the unborn) and 'Atma-bhu' (the self-existent), and Aja is the Logos in the Rig-Veda, as he is shown therein to be the first manifestation of the One: 'Desire first arose in It, which was the primal germ of mind'; that 'which connects entity with non-entity' say the sages."<ref>Vol. II., p. 578 (old ed.)</ref> Hence so long as the soul remains in the manifested worlds it must be subject to universal desire which is the mainspring of manifestation. And even the soul that attains Nirvana and refuses it must use this universal force; though all thought of self, all desire that pertains to self, is slain. | |||
But what is meant by killing out desire, how is it to be accomplished? Desire is the basis of action and looked at as energy cannot be destroyed but may be applied in other directions and towards different ends. All progress is from step to step and no jumps can be made, hence the injunction to kill out desire is only for the few, for those who are ready; but for the many, if it were possible for them to kill out desire, to pass out of the personal life with its personal desires, its bonds and limitations, into the impersonal, the soul would find itself adrift or rather would not find or know itself at all. Man, the ordinary man, in his present stage of development needs his desires to help him forward, but his progress depends on his letting go of lower and taking hold of and following higher and ever higher desires. The higher desires can and {{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=8|p=251}}should be cultivated and in proportion as we become actuated by unselfish and pure desires the lower desires will cease to have power over us and will finally die out. | |||
The surest way of killing these lower desires is to follow the higher, putting forth our energy towards the attainment of nobler and loftier ideals. Then those desires which relate to the merely personal life will fade and disappear and at last give place to the impersonal and universal. Only step by step can we attain to this, but by using the energy of desire we may climb up to the very entrance of the Path and shall then perchance understand the injunction "Kill out desire." | |||
Let us desire to enter the Path; let us desire, with Nature, the good of all creatures. | |||
{{Style P-Signature|J. H. F.}} | |||
{{Vertical space|2em}} | |||
<hr> | |||
{{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=9|p=279}} | |||
D. L. I.—I do not see the slightest reason why everything that concerns scientific truth should not be plainly and accurately set forth. If Theosophy is of so great benefit and all appertaining to it is good why are portions of its setting forth veiled in such secrecy? In other words, why should there be an inner circle? This has been a stumbling block to me, as I believe that truth and goodness will harm no one. | |||
''Ans.''—This question is one that often arises and is a natural one to those educated in Western modes of thought. The sacredness and responsibility of knowledge have been to a very large extent lost sight of. The analytical methods of science and the general tendency to regard everything inanimate and animate as a subject for dissection—if not for vivisection—have given undue prominence to the material and external aspects of man and nature and have caused the spiritual and inner aspects to be for the most part forgotten or ignored. That which cannot be held up for the crowd to gaze at is of little importance nowadays. And yet do not misunderstand me and think that I advocate the concealment of truth or the hiding away of that which is good. Truth and goodness will not harm, but a dynamite bomb in the hands of a child or an ignorant person may cause great disaster. And a dynamite bomb in the hands of an evil-minded man may be the means of death and ruin to many. Is dynamite therefore evil? Is any force per se evil? Will D. L. I. however advocate the free and unlimited distribution of dynamite? I do not think so and those who know anything of the nature of man and of his powers, greater than those of dynamite, do not wonder at the secrecy with which certain knowledge is shrouded. | |||
The specific questions however are: Why are portions of the teachings of Theosophy veiled in such secrecy? and why should there be an Inner Circle? Let us first consider the latter question. In Theosophy, p. 88 of the current volume, E. T. H. says of the Inner Circle "Its members receive teachings that are not contained in the exoteric writings. But its prime object is to help its members to work for humanity and to teach them to love that work." This prime object really gives the reason for the existence of the Inner Circle and all those who sincerely endeavor to carry out this object form part of the real band of workers even though they may not outwardly be members of the Inner Circle or even of the T. S. Nature provides that all who follow the same end shall be linked together whether they be conscious or unconscious of it. | |||
To publish the fact that the real workers for humanity whether in or out of the T. S. are united by Nature into one body does not put any one either in or out of that circle of workers. And the links that bind {{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=9|p=280}}such workers together are known only to themselves and cannot be made known to those outside. There are many inner circles in Nature, circles within circles, and each circle has its interior knowledge unknown to those outside, and in fact Nature provides that such knowledge shall be kept secret from all those not entitled to it. It may be published and is so published but it remains secret still, it cannot become known except to such as have been tried and found worthy. | |||
Now any esoteric body that teaches true Wisdom must be in accordance with all the purposes of Nature and the ultimate destiny of man. What need is there, however, for pledges and for secrecy other than that compelled by nature as above referred to? The need lies in this, that while man is a part of Nature as a whole, and partakes of the gradual evolution of nature, yet that evolution is to a large extent dependent upon him and he can progress as it were in advance of nature although by so doing he also raises up the whole of nature. Those beings, therefore, who have progressed beyond the human stage of evolution and who have realized the possibilities of development that lie before humanity are ever seeking to assist mankind to greater heights. And they ever seek for those among men who are willing to take that step which shall bring them to a fuller knowledge of the powers of man and nature and who will use this knowledge for the benefit of humanity. | |||
This implies a forcing and a forestalling of Nature; consequently means have to be taken to ensure that such persons are strong enough to bear this forcing and worthy and well qualified to receive the further light. If knowledge be given which in the ordinary course of evolution would not be acquired for many lives, means must also be taken to ensure the right use of this knowledge. In other words applicants for esoteric knowledge have to show their fitness and worthiness and before such knowledge can be theirs they have to learn "to know, to will, to dare and to keep silent." It is the last of these qualifications which concerns us at present—the power of silence. The secrecy that is imposed upon members of the Inner Circle is for their own safety and discipline; it provides an opportunity for them to acquire strength. | |||
No knowledge or powers in the Universe can be kept from him who is entitled to them. It needs only that he who desires knowledge and power should make himself fit and worthy to receive the same. The highest powers in nature are only for him who will work with nature, for all and not for self. And the E.S.T. is for the purpose of enabling students to take those preliminary steps that will lead them to the gateway of knowledge. The mere gaining of admission to the E.S.T. does not mean the acquirement of powers or even of greater knowledge. It does mean a greater opportunity to work for others and if this be used it means also a greater opportunity to learn to know one's self. | |||
{{Page aside in Theosophy|v=11|n=9|p=281}}Another important point to be considered in connection with this question is that information, often miscalled knowledge is of little value in itself. But knowledge, the result of experience, cannot fail of its effect on life and character and thus upon the world. Most of the objections to esotericism arise from curiosity and most of those who object seek information, not knowledge. Information may be communicated, but not knowledge, the latter is the result of growth. All schools of true esotericism seek to aid all men in acquiring knowledge and wisdom, they never hold this back because they cannot, nor can they confer it, but they can help others to acquire it. They cannot, however, help everyone to acquire it, but only those who seek it, and no sincere seeker for truth is debarred from seeking it. The E.S.T. is for the purpose of helping those who desire help, not for themselves, but to help others. The path lies before each of us, no one prevents our entry except ourselves. | |||
The following extract from the Secret Doctrine (Vol. I, Introd., p. xxxiv), bears directly upon this question: | |||
{{Style P-Quote|It is not the fault of the initiates that these documents are now 'lost' to the profane; nor was their policy dictated by selfishness, or any desire to monopolize the life-giving sacred lore. . . . But this was because to impart to the unprepared multitude secrets of such tremendous importance, was equivalent to giving a child a lighted candle in a powder magazine. . . . | |||
The danger was this: Doctrines such as the planetary chain, or the seven races, at once give a clue to the seven-fold nature of man, for each principle is correlated to a plane, a planet, and a race; and the human principles are, on every plane, correlated to seven-fold occult forces—those of the higher planes being of tremendous power. So that any septenary division at once gives a clue to tremendous occult powers, the abuse of which would cause incalculable evil to humanity. A clue, which is, perhaps, no clue to the present generation—especially the Westerns—protected as they are by their very blindness and ignorant materialistic disbelief in the occult; but a clue which would nevertheless, have been very real in the early centuries of the Christian era, to people fully convinced of the reality of occultism, and entering a cycle of degradation, which made them ripe for abuse of occult powers and sorcery of the worst description.}} | |||
{{Style P-Signature|J. H. F.}} | |||
{{Footnotes}} | {{Footnotes}} | ||