Pentaur - Neglected Factors in the Educational Problem

From Teopedia
Books • Articles • Stories • Letters • All works
⇐ • ⇒
Information about the work
Terms (+) • Literature (+) • Persons (+) • Periodicals (+) • Sources
H A L P S

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Neglected Factors in the Educational Problem

William Quan Judge

(October 1897)

Argues that the educational problem remains the most vital of all, since solving it would dissolve the social evil, the struggle of rich and poor, and most poverty and crime; that the past quarter-century's gains have been chiefly in the "machinery" of education (buildings, equipment, the arousing of the pupil's interest) rather than in any deeper principle, and that these gains show no corresponding increase in common sense, virtue or happiness. Identifies two neglected factors: first, a right knowledge of the nature of man as essentially divine, the mind, passions and body being only instruments of an inner being who must learn to use them as a workman uses his tools, so that education must work from within outward, awakening the soul, rather than from without inward, merely perfecting the instrument; and second, the fact (or working theory) of reincarnation, which alone explains each child as an old soul bringing its own already-built character and past experience into the new life, responsible for itself as it now is, and which therefore charges the educator with learning to read and speak to that soul rather than merely to pass intellectual examinations. Closes insisting that the heart, not mere book-knowledge, makes the true teacher as it makes the true physician, that intuition has been neglected in favor of reason, and that teachers need only have these two neglected factors called to their attention to find in them the solution they already seek.

Publications:

Read:

DATA

Title for references: Pentaur - Neglected Factors in the Educational Problem
Short description: Argues that the educational problem remains the most vital of all, since solving it would dissolve t...

William Quan Judge

Neglected Factors in the Educational Problem

No byline; closes with the signature printed "Pextacr." in the scan, a routine OCR letter-level misreading of "Pentaur." — confirmed against the issue's own (otherwise unreliable) printed table of contents, which lists this same article as by '"Pentaur."' (quoted, as the magazine's convention for a pen-name, like "Solon." in no. 6). No title heading appears over the author's name other than the article's own printed title; "Pentaur" is evidently a pseudonym (the name of a historical Egyptian scribe/poet, in the classical-pen-name style occasionally used in this magazine) and no author card has been found for it. Kept as a standalone page on the strength of its own printed title and closing signature, per the project's three-feature test (own title and signature; no identified author with a card), as with "Solon." in the previous issue. No further instalment has been located. One further OCR letter-level scanno corrected without comment: "hampered" for a run of garbled letters; the phrase "the interests of cohere" (clearly a scanno, sense otherwise unclear) is left flagged inline rather than silently emended, per project rule.

357

Neglected Factors in the Educational Problem.

In spite of the great advance that has been made along many lines in education, the educational problem is still the most vital today. Solve this problem and the suffering and misery that exist in the world will disappear; the social evil, the struggle between rich and poor, poverty and crime, all arise from lack of education. It will be evident that I am using the term education in a very broad sense and with a very deep meaning and I shall presently endeavor to make clear my view of the matter.

The greatest advance made during the past twenty-five years has been in the machinery of education, in the building and equipping of public schools. A very important step was taken when educators realized the value of making the lessons interesting to the children. The fact of the realization of the necessity to arouse the interest of scholars and so remove the sense of compulsion and servitude which formerly characterized the school-life is the most hopeful sign in the whole history of modern education.

But what means have we of judging of the great advance said to have been made during the past twenty-five or fifty years? Only by results, and these will show that there is still something vital lacking. Quite true it is that more men and women can read and write, but I doubt if they have developed a sounder judgment than their grandparents who could do neither. Does the government of this or any other country show an improvement commensurate with the alleged improvement in education; do those who have received most benefit through education show any evidences of possessing more common-sense than their forefathers; is there a keener sense of the eternal fitness of things, is there more virtue in the world, is there more sobriety, more happiness, more contentment and peace? If not, where has been the gain? The people no doubt show more sharpness of intellect, and have more general information, but the acquirement of these is surely not the end or purpose of education. What then has been lacking? Have we got to the root of the matter, or must we go deeper still?

According to our ultimate view of life and of man will be the keynote of our educational system. If this view be materialistic, all education will tend in that direction; if the general belief be held that we live but one life on earth, the influence of this be- 358lief will show itself in the school-room as in the life of the outside world, where competition, each man for himself, is the rule; or putting it in another way, let us eat and drink, let us look after number one, for to-morrow we die. We do not have to force these things and we cannot prevent them. The little world of the school-room reflects the greater world. But there is also the reaction and the outer world is in some measure,—in fact in a greater measure than might be supposed,—affected by the child world. Indeed the influence of the children upon the world is one of the greatest factors in the progress of humanity. The child-nature is not hampered with preconceived notions and custom and conventionality but is free, spontaneous, living in the present. If the grown-ups would but turn around and learn of the children, life would have a new meaning and maybe if we could "become as little children" the riddles of life would be found to have a solution after all.

The most important factor in the problem of education is a right knowledge of the nature of man. Who, or what, is this little child;—a little animal, a thinking machine, or a divine human being? I would say all these but that the essential nature is divine and that the mind, the passions and desires, and the body are but the instruments of the inner-being who stands back of all, ready to use them, but not identical with them. The inner being must learn to use these instruments and to gain complete control over them as does a workman over his tools, or a musician over his musical instrument. But if the workman simply uses his tools as a machine and if the musician plays only mechanically and cannot create, both have failed. So in the training of the mind and intellect, these may be perfected as machines, may become stored with information and be able to perform all the processes of reasoning, but if the creative power of the soul is not awakened, the so-called education has been to no purpose. It is not enough to make the instruments perfect, that which is of first importance is to awaken the soul behind.

Plato held that all knowledge was recollection and the most ancient teaching was that all souls possess the potentiality of all wisdom. This at once gives us a basis on which to work. Once realize this and it will become clear that the most important thing is not the acquiring of information but to unlock the fetters which bind the soul. I do not deny that this is already aimed at and accomplished to a large extent, but I claim that the basis of action is not rightly understood by the majority of educators, nor does it even 359exist for many. If it were understood how much is within, locked up in the heart of each, and that the inner potentiality in all alike is infinite, we should cease to spend so much time in drudgery and technicalities and would pay more attention to principles. Speaking generally, modern education starts at the wrong end of the line, though most certainly the outer expression of the soul,—the child as he ordinarily appears, must not be disregarded, but should be an index to the real development of the soul within. Yet the work done in our schools to-day is mainly from without within, our teachers have still to learn how to act from within without. There is too much time spent in pruning and trimming and embellishing. We must get at the centre and work from there, then the growth will be like a flower's, natural, harmonious, beautiful.

There is another factor which has been overlooked but which is of the greatest importance in this problem. It is a factor which seems to have been almost totally lost sight of in modern philosophy, though it was universally held by the ancients. It is, however, now being restored to its place and Schopenhauer and others have recognized its importance. I refer to the belief or theory to some, though a proven fact, so it is claimed, to others, that we live many lives on earth, that each life is the outcome and the result of previous lives; that each one's character has been built by himself, that each is responsible for himself as he now is. What a different aspect is at once put upon the educational problem if this idea of many lives is accepted! Each child has its own individuality, the soul back of that bright childish face is an old soul which has had ages of experience and is now asking us to help it unlock its own powers and make use of its past experiences. If the educational problem were simply considered in the light of modern theories of evolution and heredity it would appear in an altogether different aspect. But these do not go half way, we must go further and consider the many lives of the soul in order to fully solve the problem. We must find some means of reading and understanding the children and ourselves from this standpoint. When we are able to do this we shall see that every trait of character is the result of growth and that each child himself, or rather the soul back of each, is responsible for this. Ah, if only we could see these things, could see the tendencies and possibilities in the child's nature, then might we truly help the child. The true educator must attain to this power, he must learn to use the power of his own soul and to recognize and speak to the soul of the child. But instead of placing the greatest importance upon this, the chief qualification of a teacher today is the ability to pass certain intellectual examinations and these finer perceptions, if not altogether ignored, are accorded an in- 360ferior place.

What folly to think that any one can truly educate who cannot awaken affection and love in the heart of the child. Yet how large a place does this power hold in the choice of teachers for our public schools? The obstacles that children have to overcome are stupendous. Not only have they to fight their way through the veils of oblivion that nature has thrown around them in their new birth into earth life, but they have even to overcome the obstacles which parents and teachers place in their way due to their ignorance of life and of their own nature. In 999 cases out of 1,000, true education does not take place in school, save in very small degree, but is carried on outside, in the home, among playmates, and in the struggle for life that so many of our little ones have to face so early. And the majority of us who have reached maturer years will, I think, say that until we were grown and out in the battle of life we did not realize that life is the great educator, and that we must join hands with life in seeking to lead out our own powers and express the inmost nature of our souls. The true education of children consists far more in the guidance of a loving and wise hand and in the hard knocks of experience than in storing the little heads with information. I would not be understood to undervalue the imparting of information or the training of the mind—even as ordinarily understood—but the importance placed upon these has been altogether out of proportion when compared with the essentials of education. It is heart-breaking to read the learned discussions of the amount of time that ought to be given to spelling and grammar, etc., and to see the insistance of the attainment of a certain standard of proficiency; too much attention is given to appearances, the reality is thrust almost out of sight. We have attended to the "anise and cummin," but have neglected the weightier matters.

What do we need, then, in order to work along the right lines? We have the children, and if we can accept the opinion of some, nay, we may know it from observation, there are many souls coming back to earth life in this country that are strong, wise souls, perhaps far further along the pathway of evolution than we; so we have the best of material to work with, and may feel assured that the children themselves will give us their assistance. But what we need is teachers. We have not enough teachers capable, or if capable, most of them are as yet ignorant of their powers to do this work.

I believe that most teachers are fully alive to the importance 361and responsibility of their profession, and that they need only that these neglected factors in the problem of education should be called to their attention to recognize that through them is to be found a solution. Many teachers have broken free from a mechanical system and follow their intuitions, but how many are there who are controlled by school boards and school organizations and are hampered by rules and regulations? Yet an awakening is certainly taking place in the profession and the principles that underlie true education are receiving an ever-increasing attention. It is a most important matter that we have a right basis on which to build. Then if we know what we are aiming at we can certainly advance a short distance, if only a few steps.

Fortunately more attention has been given of late years to the faculty of teaching and to improved methods of imparting knowledge but the mental and mechanical qualifications are still regarded as the most important and not only in the choice of teachers but in all professions alike. Perhaps the most forcible illustration is in the medical profession. What do the examiners in the medical schools know of the real "fitness" of the candidates for the profession? Do they take into account those qualities which characterize the true physician? Have they any means of discovering whether the candidate possesses these qualities, whether he is in reality a physician apart from any book knowledge? A true physician must be one at heart, it is not book-knowledge that makes one. All the knowledge of anatomy, physiology, therapeutics, what-not, never yet made a physician, though unfortunately a medical diploma depends more upon these than upon anything else. And just the same is true of the teachers.

But the case is by no means a hopeless one. We find, or may find, if we will but open our eyes, some people who have the finer perceptions which are needed, the power of speaking to the heart, awakening the inner nature of men and women and of coming into touch with the soul of things. Some have these powers developed, all have them potentially, and what we need to do is to begin to develop within ourselves these finer faculties, to seek to draw them forth in the children and the change will come imperceptibly, gradually, but with a rapidity that will startle us. All this means an increased responsibility on our own part, which will force us to make our motives OCR illegible: printed as a run of garbled letters, guessed as "higher" from context, our lives purer and broader, and in short to develop the heart side of our nature. We have followed too much the reason and have neglected the intuition. The latter has been almost atrophied and forgotten so that with many it is a thing of 362the imagination, but not so to a child and it will come back to us in proportion as we, ourselves, become child-like.

"Pentaur."